Angular momentum loss in gravitational scattering, radiation reaction, and the Bondi gauge ambiguity

Abstract

Recently, Damour computed the radiation reaction on gravitational scattering as the (linear) response to the angular momentum loss which he found to be of $\mathcal{O}(G^2)$ in the gravitational constant. This is a puzzle because any amplitude calculation would produce both energy and angular momentum losses starting only at $\mathcal{O}(G^3)$. Another puzzle is that the resultant radiation reaction, of $\mathcal{O}(G^3)$, is nevertheless correct and confirmed by a number of direct calculations. We ascribe these puzzles to the BMS ambiguity in defining angular momentum. The loss of angular momentum is to be counted out from the ADM value and, therefore, should be calculated in the so-called canonical gauge under the BMS transformations in which the remote-past limit of the Bondi angular momentum coincides with the ADM angular momentum. This calculation correctly gives the $\mathcal{O}(G^3)$ loss. On the other hand, we introduce a gauge in which the Bondi light cones tend asymptotically to those emanating from the center of mass world line. We find that the angular momentum flux in this gauge is precisely the one used by Damour for his radiation reaction result. We call this new gauge "intrinsic" and argue that, although the correct angular momentum flux is to be computed in the canonical gauge, any mechanical calculation of gauge-dependent quantities -- such as angular momentum -- gives the result in the intrinsic gauge. Therefore, it is this gauge that should be used in the linear response formula. This solves the puzzles and establishes the correspondence between the intrinsic mechanical calculations and the Bondi formalism.

13 pages, added explanations and references. Version accepted for publication (Phys. Lett. B)

References in corpus (4)

• Scattering Amplitudes and the Conservative Hamiltonian for Binary Systems at Third Post-Minkowskian Order
• Angular momentum of zero-frequency gravitons
• Compact binary coalescences: The subtle issue of angular momentum
• Classical gravitational scattering from a gauge-invariant double copy

Cited by in corpus (22)

• Classical Gravitational Observables from the Eikonal Operator
• Angular Momentum Loss Due to Tidal Effects in the Post-Minkowskian Expansion
• Radiation-reaction and angular momentum loss at the second Post-Minkowskian order
• Gravitational Bound Waveforms from Amplitudes
• A Supertranslation-Invariant Formula for the Angular Momentum Flux in Gravitational Scattering
• Large Gauge Effects and the Structure of Amplitudes
• Null Infinity and Horizons: A New Approach to Fluxes and Charges
• Unified Treatment of null and Spatial Infinity IV: Angular Momentum at Null and Spatial Infinity
• Angular momentum and memory effect
• Electromagnetic fields in compact binaries: post-Newtonian wave generation and application to double white dwarfs systems
• Dirac brackets for classical radiative observables
• The spinning self-force EFT: 1SF waveform recursion relation and Compton scattering
• Next-to-eikonal corrected double graviton dressing and gravitational wave observables at $\mathcal{O}(G^2)$
• Can Two Ultrarelativistic Objects Lose Almost All Their Energy to Gravitational Radiation?
• ADM, BMS, and some puzzling interconnections
• On the Definition of the Spin Charge in Asymptotically-Flat Spacetimes
• Supertranslation ambiguity in post-Minkowskian expansion
• Gravitational vacua in the Newman-Penrose formalism
• Frames and Slicings for Angular Momentum in Post-Minkowski Scattering
• Double soft graviton factors from the gravitational Wilson line
• Lorentz Covariant Supertranslation Frames for the Angular Momentum Aspect
• Note on post-Minkowskian expansion and Bondi coordinates