Lensing or luck? False alarm probabilities for gravitational lensing of gravitational waves

Abstract

Strong gravitational lensing of gravitational waves (GWs) has been forecasted to become detectable in the upcoming observing runs. However, definitively distinguishing pairs of lensed sources from random associations is a challenging problem. We investigate the degree to which unlensed events mimic lensed ones because of the overlap of parameters due to a combination of random coincidence and errors in parameter estimation. We construct a mock catalog of lensed and unlensed events. We find that the false alarm probability (FAP) based on coincidental overlaps of the chirp mass, sky location, and coalescence phase are approximately $9\%$, $1\%$, and $10\%$ per pair, respectively. Combining all three, the overall FAP per pair is $\sim 10^{-4}$. As the number of events, $N$, in the GW catalogs increases, the number of random pairs of events increases as $\sim N^2$. Meanwhile, the number of lensed events will increase linearly with $N$, implying that for sufficiently high $N$, the false alarms will always dominate over the true lensing events. This issue can be compensated for by placing higher thresholds on the lensing candidates (e.g., selecting a higher signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) threshold), which will lead to better parameter estimation and, thus, lower FAP per pair -- at the cost of dramatically decreasing the size of the lensing sample (by $\sim 1/\mbox{SNR}^3$). We show that with our simple overlap criteria for current detectors at design sensitivity, the false alarms will dominate for realistic lensing rates ($\lesssim 10^{-3}$) even when selecting the highest SNR pairs. These results highlight the necessity to design alternative identification criteria beyond simple waveform and sky location overlap. Future GW detectors Cosmic Explorer and Einstein Telescope may provide sufficient improvement in parameter estimation, allowing for the conclusive detection of strong lensing of GWs.

17 pages, 14 figures. Matches the version published in Phys. Rev. D 107, 063023 (2023)

References in corpus (31)

• Advanced Virgo: a 2nd generation interferometric gravitational wave detector
• Cosmic Star Formation History
• Advanced LIGO
• GWTC-2: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the First Half of the Third Observing Run
• Search for gravitational lensing signatures in LIGO-Virgo binary black hole events
• Phase effects from strong gravitational lensing of gravitational waves
• Localizing merging black holes with sub-arcsecond precision using gravitational-wave lensing
• What if LIGO's gravitational wave detections are strongly lensed by massive galaxy clusters?
• Observational signatures of microlensing in gravitational waves at LIGO/Virgo frequencies
• Please repeat: Strong lensing of gravitational waves as a probe of compact binary and galaxy populations
• Identifying strong gravitational-wave lensing during the second observing run of Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo
• What does strong gravitational lensing? The mass and redshift distribution of high-magnification lenses
• Probing Dark Low-mass Halos and Primordial Black Holes with Frequency-dependent Gravitational Lensing Dispersions of Gravitational Waves
• Beyond the detector horizon: Forecasting gravitational-wave strong lensing
• Testing the nature of gravitational-wave polarizations using strongly lensed signals
• Identifying Type II Strongly Lensed Gravitational-Wave Images in Third-Generation Gravitational-Wave Detectors
• A fast and precise methodology to search for and analyse strongly lensed gravitational-wave events
• Observability of lensing of gravitational waves from massive black hole binaries with LISA
• Breaking the mass-sheet degeneracy with gravitational wave interference in lensed events
• Constraining cosmological parameters in FLRW metric with lensed GW+EM signals
• On the identification of individual gravitational wave image types of a lensed system using higher-order modes
• Impact of astrophysical binary coalescence timescales on the rate of lensed gravitational wave events
• Strong lensing as a giant telescope to localize the host galaxy of gravitational wave event
• Lensed or not lensed: Determining lensing magnifications for binary neutron star mergers from a single detection
• On building a cluster watch-list for identifying strongly lensed supernovae, gravitational waves and kilonovae
• Improved statistic to identify strongly lensed gravitational wave events
• lensingGW: a Python package for lensing of gravitational waves
• Constraining the lensing of binary black holes from their stochastic background
• CMB Cluster Lensing: Cosmography with the Longest Lever Arm
• Search for Black Hole Merger Families
• On similarity of binary black hole gravitational-wave skymaps: to observe or to wait?

Cited by in corpus (28)

• Gravitational wave lensing as a probe of halo properties and dark matter
• Follow-up Analyses to the O3 LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Lensing Searches
• Exploring the hidden Universe: A novel phenomenological approach for recovering arbitrary gravitational-wave millilensing configurations
• Weakly Lensed Gravitational Waves: Probing Cosmic Structures with Wave-Optics Features
• Cosmography using strongly lensed gravitational waves from binary black holes
• Detection and parameter estimation challenges of Type-II lensed binary black hole signals
• Exploring the Impact of Microlensing on Gravitational Wave Signals: Biases, Population Characteristics, and Prospects for Detection
• Probing wave-optics effects and low-mass dark matter halos with lensing of gravitational waves from massive black holes
• Modified gravitational wave propagation with higher modes and its degeneracies with lensing
• On the detection and precise localisation of merging black holes events through strong gravitational lensing
• Frequency- and polarization-dependent lensing of gravitational waves in strong gravitational fields
• Identifying strongly lensed gravitational waves through their phase consistency
• Multi-messenger Gravitational Lensing
• SLICK: Strong Lensing Identification of Candidates Kindred in gravitational wave data
• GLANCE -- Gravitational Lensing Authenticator using Non-Modelled Cross-Correlation Exploration of Gravitational Wave Signals
• Microlensing bias on the detection of strong lensing gravitational wave
• Strong-lensing cosmography using third-generation gravitational-wave detectors
• An interference-based method for the detection of strongly lensed gravitational waves
• Waveform systematics in identifying strongly gravitationally lensed gravitational waves: Posterior overlap method
• Identifying Strongly Lensed Gravitational Waves with the Third-generation Detectors
• False positives for gravitational lensing: the gravitational-wave perspective
• Event Rate of Strongly Lensed Gravitational Waves of Stellar Binary Black Hole Mergers Produced by Dynamical Interactions
• Uncovering faint lensed gravitational-wave signals and reprioritizing their follow-up analysis using galaxy lensing forecasts with detected counterparts
• Mitigating the effect of the population model uncertainty on the strong lensing Bayes factor using nonparametric methods
• Strong-lensing rates of massive black hole binaries in LISA
• Gravitational Lensing of Gravitational Waves from Astrophysical Sources: Theory, Detection, and Applications
• Mock Catalogs of Strongly Lensed Gravitational Waves via A Halo Model Approach with Ground-based Detectors
• Can Eccentric Binary Black Hole Signals Mimic Gravitational-Wave Microlensing?