No second law of entanglement manipulation after all

Abstract

Many fruitful analogies have emerged between the theories of quantum entanglement and thermodynamics, motivating the pursuit of an axiomatic description of entanglement akin to the laws of thermodynamics. A long-standing open problem has been to establish a true second law of entanglement, and in particular a unique function which governs all transformations between entangled systems, mirroring the role of entropy in thermodynamics. Contrary to previous promising evidence, here we show that this is impossible, and no direct counterpart to the second law of thermodynamics can be established. This is accomplished by demonstrating the irreversibility of entanglement theory from first principles -- assuming only the most general microscopic physical constraints of entanglement manipulation, we show that entanglement theory is irreversible under all non-entangling transformations. We furthermore rule out reversibility without significant entanglement expenditure, showing that reversible entanglement transformations require the generation of macroscopically large amounts of entanglement according to certain measures. Our results not only reveal fundamental differences between quantum entanglement transformations and thermodynamic processes, but also showcase a unique property of entanglement which distinguishes it from other known quantum resources.

arXiv comment21+36 pages, 3 figures. Final published version. v3: significant revisions of the presentation, many additional clarifications

References in corpus (53)

• Quantum entanglement
• Mixed State Entanglement and Quantum Error Correction
• Separability Criterion for Density Matrices
• A computable measure of entanglement
• Concentrating Partial Entanglement by Local Operations
• Area laws for the entanglement entropy - a review
• Quantifying Entanglement
• The logarithmic negativity: A full entanglement monotone that is not convex
• Entanglement Measures and Purification Procedures
• Fundamental Limits of Repeaterless Quantum Communications
• General Benchmarks for Quantum Repeaters
• Quantum Resource Theories
• Quantum many-body systems out of equilibrium
• The foundations of statistical mechanics from entanglement: Individual states vs. averages
• Operational Resource Theory of Coherence
• The role of quantum information in thermodynamics --- a topical review
• Fundamental limitations for quantum and nano thermodynamics
• Entanglement monotones
• Quantum correlations with no causal order
• The Resource Theory of Quantum States Out of Thermal Equilibrium
• General Entanglement Breaking Channels
• Robustness of entanglement
• The Physics and Mathematics of the Second Law of Thermodynamics
• Quantum computations without definite causal structure
• Min- and Max- Relative Entropies and a New Entanglement Monotone
• Jerusalem Lectures on Black Holes and Quantum Information
• Thermodynamics and the Measure of Entanglement
• Exact and Asymptotic Measures of Multipartite Pure State Entanglement
• Entanglement-assisted local manipulation of pure quantum states
• Limits for entanglement measures
• The entanglement cost under operations preserving the positivity of partial transpose
• The Uniqueness Theorem for Entanglement Measures
• Entanglement Theory and the Second Law of Thermodynamics
• Are the laws of entanglement theory thermodynamical?
• Irreversibility in asymptotic manipulations of entanglement
• A reversible theory of entanglement and its relation to the second law
• Relative Entropy of Entanglement and Restricted Measurements
• One-Shot Coherence Dilution
• A Resource Theory for Work and Heat
• Entanglement Cost of Quantum Channels
• Axiomatic relation between thermodynamic and information-theoretic entropies
• Fundamental limitations on distillation of quantum channel resources
• Thermodynamic Capacity of Quantum Processes
• Improved Semidefinite Programming Upper Bound on Distillable Entanglement
• On a gap in the proof of the generalised quantum Stein's lemma and its consequences for the reversibility of quantum resources
• Irreversibility of Asymptotic Entanglement Manipulation Under Quantum Operations Completely Preserving Positivity of Partial Transpose
• The first law of general quantum resource theories
• Dephasing-Covariant Operations Enable Asymptotic Reversibility of Quantum Resources
• "Pretty strong" converse for the quantum capacity of degradable channels
• Completing the Grand Tour of asymptotic quantum coherence manipulation
• Asymptotic state transformations of continuous variable resources
• Macroscopic Thermodynamic Reversibility in Quantum Many-Body Systems
• Computable lower bounds on the entanglement cost of quantum channels

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Semidefinite programming relaxations for quantum correlations
• On a gap in the proof of the generalised quantum Stein's lemma and its consequences for the reversibility of quantum resources
• Testing the quantum nature of gravity without entanglement
• Magic-induced computational separation in entanglement theory
• Every quantum helps: Operational advantage of quantum resources beyond convexity
• A solution of the generalised quantum Stein's lemma
• No-Go Theorems for Universal Entanglement Purification
• Robustness- and weight-based resource measures without convexity restriction: Multicopy witness and operational advantage in static and dynamical quantum resource theories
• Attainability and lower semi-continuity of the relative entropy of entanglement, and variations on the theme
• Maximally entangled mixed states for a fixed spectrum do not always exist
• No-go theorem for entanglement distillation using catalysis
• Catalytic and asymptotic equivalence for quantum entanglement
• Overcoming entropic limitations on asymptotic state transformations through probabilistic protocols
• Continuity of entropies via integral representations
• Second Law of Entanglement Manipulation with Entanglement Battery
• What can we learn about islands and state paradox from quantum information theory?
• Interplay among entanglement, measurement incompatibility, and nonlocality
• Resource engines
• Computable lower bounds on the entanglement cost of quantum channels
• A Compendious Review of Majorization-Based Resource Theories: Quantum Information and Quantum Thermodynamics
• Geometric genuine multipartite entanglement for four-qubit systems
• Computable entanglement cost under positive partial transpose operations
• Fundamental limitations to key distillation from Gaussian states with Gaussian operations
• Non-stabilizerness and entanglement from cat-state injection
• Multipartite entanglement theory with entanglement-nonincreasing operations
• Robustness of tripartite entangled states in passive PT-symmetric qubits
• Markov Gap and Bound Entanglement in Haar Random State
• Generalized Entanglement of Purification Criteria for 2-Producible States in Multipartite Systems
• Nonexistence of maximally entangled mixed states for a fixed spectrum