Energy conservation and fluctuation theorem are incompatible for quantum work

Abstract

Characterizing fluctuations of work in coherent quantum systems is notoriously problematic. Here we reveal the ultimate source of the problem by proving that ($\mathfrak{A}$) energy conservation and ($\mathfrak{B}$) the Jarzynski fluctuation theorem cannot be observed at the same time. Condition $\mathfrak{A}$ stipulates that, for any initial state of the system, the measured average work must be equal to the difference of initial and final average energies, and that untouched systems must exchange deterministically zero work. Condition $\mathfrak{B}$ is only for thermal initial states and encapsulates the second law of thermodynamics. We prove that $\mathfrak{A}$ and $\mathfrak{B}$ are incompatible for work measurement schemes that are differentiable functions of the state and satisfy two mild structural constraints. This covers all existing schemes and leaves the theoretical possibility of jointly observing $\mathfrak{A}$ and $\mathfrak{B}$ open only for a narrow class of exotic schemes. For the special but important case of state-independent schemes, the situation is much more rigid: we prove that, essentially, only the two-point measurement scheme is compatible with $\mathfrak{B}$.

5+15 pages; v4: accepted in Quantum

References in corpus (58)

• Stochastic thermodynamics, fluctuation theorems, and molecular machines
• Photonic quantum technologies
• Nonequilibrium fluctuations, fluctuation theorems, and counting statistics in quantum systems
• Colloquium. Quantum Fluctuation Relations: Foundations and Applications
• Fluctuation theorems: Work is not an observable
• Entanglement in continuous variable systems: Recent advances and current perspectives
• Maximal work extraction from quantum systems
• Minimal Energy Cost for Thermodynamic Information Processing: Measurement and Information Erasure
• Experimental Test of Quantum Jarzynski Equality with a Trapped Ion System
• Experimental reconstruction of work distribution and verification of fluctuation relations at the full quantum level
• Adaptive homodyne measurement of optical phase
• Understanding quantum measurement from the solution of dynamical models
• The role of quantum measurement in stochastic thermodynamics
• No-go theorem for the characterisation of work fluctuations in coherent quantum systems
• Non-equilibrium quantum fluctuations of work
• Employing trapped cold ions to verify the quantum Jarzynski equality
• Full counting statistics of a general quantum mechanical variable
• A Quantum Fluctuation Theorem
• Fidelity for displaced squeezed states and the oscillator semigroup
• Ab-initio Quantum Enhanced Optical Phase Estimation Using Real-time Feedback Control
• Ideal Projective Measurements Have Infinite Resource Costs
• Quantum work and the thermodynamic cost of quantum measurements
• Fully quantum fluctuation theorems
• Quantum fluctuation theorems for arbitrary environments: adiabatic and non-adiabatic entropy production
• Quantum fluctuation theorems, contextuality and work quasi-probabilities
• Full distribution of work done on a quantum system for arbitrary initial states
• The second law of quantum thermodynamics as an equality
• A quasiprobability distribution for heat fluctuations in the quantum regime
• A Quantum Analogue of the Jarzynski Equality
• The quantum-classical correspondence principle for work distributions
• Path integral approach to quantum thermodynamics
• Time-reversal symmetric work distributions for closed quantum dynamics in the histories framework
• Work extraction from unknown quantum sources
• The measurement postulates of quantum mechanics are operationally redundant
• Quasi-probability distributions for observables in dynamic systems
• Work as an external quantum observable and an operational quantum work fluctuation theorem
• Effects of Quantum Coherence on Work Statistics
• The role of quantum coherence in energy fluctuations
• Quantum Work in the Bohmian framework
• Experimentally reducing the quantum measurement back-action in work distributions by a collective measurement
• Quantum current in dissipative systems
• Energetic footprints of irreversibility in the quantum regime
• Probabilistically Violating the First Law of Thermodynamics in a Quantum Heat Engine
• Minimizing back-action through entangled measurements
• Exploring quasiprobability approach to quantum work in the presence of initial coherence: Advantages of the Margenau-Hill distribution
• Conditional work statistics of quantum measurements
• Quantum corrections of work statistics in closed quantum systems
• Joint measurability in nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics
• Fluctuating work in coherent quantum systems: proposals and limitations
• Fundamental energy cost for quantum measurement
• Generalized energy measurements and quantum work compatible with fluctuation theorems
• A quantum fluctuation theorem for any Lindblad master equation
• Semiclassical approach to the work distribution
• Thermodynamically free quantum measurements
• Quantum mean-square predictors and thermodynamics
• Semi-classical work and quantum work identities in Weyl representation
• Quantum-classical correspondence of work distributions for initial states with quantum coherence
• Extracting Bayesian networks from multiple copies of a quantum system

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Operational work fluctuation theorem for open quantum systems
• Revising the quantum work fluctuation framework to encompass energy conservation
• Quantum Coherence and Anomalous Work Extraction in Qubit Gate Dynamics
• Energy exchange statistics and fluctuation theorem for non-thermal asymptotic states