Experimental tests of sub-surface reflectors as an explanation for the ANITA anomalous events

Abstract

The balloon-borne ANITA experiment is designed to detect ultra-high energy neutrinos via radio emissions produced by an in-ice shower. Although initially purposed for interactions within the Antarctic ice sheet, ANITA also demonstrated the ability to self-trigger on radio emissions from ultra-high energy charged cosmic rays interacting in the Earth's atmosphere. For showers produced above the Antarctic ice sheet, reflection of the down-coming radio signals at the Antarctic surface should result in a polarity inversion prior to subsequent observation at the $\sim$35-40 km altitude ANITA gondola. ANITA has published two anomalous instances of upcoming cosmic-rays with measured polarity opposite the remaining sample of $\sim$50 UHECR signals. The steep observed upwards incidence angles (25--30 degrees relative to the horizontal) require non-Standard Model physics if these events are due to in-ice neutrino interactions, as the Standard Model cross-section would otherwise prohibit neutrinos from penetrating the long required chord of Earth. Shoemaker et al. posit that glaciological effects may explain the steep observed anomalous events. We herein consider the scenarios offered by Shoemaker et al. and find them to be disfavored by extant ANITA and HiCal experimental data. We note that the recent report of four additional near-horizon anomalous ANITA-4 events, at $>3\sigma$ significance, are incompatible with their model, which requires significant signal transmission into the ice.

References in corpus (21)

• Time-integrated Neutrino Source Searches with 10 years of IceCube Data
• Differential limit on the extremely-high-energy cosmic neutrino flux in the presence of astrophysical background from nine years of IceCube data
• The Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna Ultra-high Energy Neutrino Detector Design, Performance, and Sensitivity for 2006-2007 Balloon Flight
• Observation of Ultra-high-energy Cosmic Rays with the ANITA Balloon-borne Radio Interferometer
• Characteristics of Four Upward-pointing Cosmic-ray-like Events Observed with ANITA
• Observation of an Unusual Upward-going Cosmic-ray-like Event in the Third Flight of ANITA
• Probing the origin of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays with neutrinos in the EeV energy range using the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Performance and Simulation of the RICE detector
• Energy and Flux Measurements of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays Observed During the First ANITA Flight
• Updated Results from the RICE Experiment and Future Prospects for Ultra-High Energy Neutrino Detection at the South Pole
• A comprehensive analysis of anomalous ANITA events disfavors a diffuse tau-neutrino flux origin
• Limits on point-like sources of ultra-high-energy neutrinos with the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Observation of classically `forbidden' electromagnetic wave propagation and implications for neutrino detection
• Coherent transition radiation from the geomagnetically-induced current in cosmic-ray air showers: Implications for the anomalous events observed by ANITA
• A search for IceCube events in the direction of ANITA neutrino candidates
• Reflections On the Anomalous ANITA Events: The Antarctic Subsurface as a Possible Explanation
• Unusual Near-horizon Cosmic-ray-like Events Observed by ANITA-IV
• Design and Performance of the ARIANNA Hexagonal Radio Array Systems
• HiCal 2: An instrument designed for calibration of the ANITA experiment and for Antarctic surface reflectivity measurements
• Antarctic Surface Reflectivity Calculations and Measurements from the ANITA-4 and HiCal-2 Experiments
• General Treatment of Reflection of Spherical Electromagnetic Waves from a Spherical Surface and its Implications for the ANITA Anomalous Polarity Events

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Detecting Neutrino Mass by Combining Matter Clustering, Halos, and Voids
• The Payload for Ultrahigh Energy Observations (PUEO): A White Paper
• Tau Neutrinos in the Next Decade: from GeV to EeV
• Unusual Near-horizon Cosmic-ray-like Events Observed by ANITA-IV
• Analysis of a Tau Neutrino Origin for the Near-Horizon Air Shower Events Observed by the Fourth Flight of the Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna (ANITA)
• The ANITA Anomalous Events and Axion Quark Nuggets
• TAROGE-M: Radio Antenna Array on Antarctic High Mountain for Detecting Near-Horizontal Ultra-High Energy Air Showers
• Triboelectric Backgrounds to radio-based UHE Neutrino Exeperiments