Beware of commonly used approximations I: errors in forecasts

Abstract

In the era of precision cosmology, establishing the correct magnitude of statistical errors in cosmological parameters is of crucial importance. However, widely used approximations in galaxy surveys analyses can lead to parameter uncertainties that are grossly mis-estimated, even in a regime where the theory is well understood (e.g., linear scales). These approximations can be introduced at three different levels: in the form of the likelihood, in the theoretical modelling of the observable and in the numerical computation of the observable. Their consequences are important both in data analysis through e.g., Markov Chain Monte Carlo parameter inference, and when survey instrument and strategy are designed and their constraining power on cosmological parameters is forecasted, for instance using Fisher matrix analyses. In this work, considering the galaxy angular power spectrum as the target observable, we report one example of approximation for each of such three categories: neglecting off-diagonal terms in the covariance matrix, neglecting cosmic magnification and using the Limber approximation on large scales. We show that these commonly used approximations affect the robustness of the analysis and lead, perhaps counter-intuitively, to unacceptably large mis-estimates of parameters errors (from few~$10\%$ up to few~$100\%$) and correlations. Furthermore, these approximations might even spoil the benefits of the nascent multi-tracer and multi-messenger cosmology. Hence we recommend that the type of analysis presented here should be repeated for every approximation adopted in survey design or data analysis, to quantify how it may affect the results. To this aim, we have developed \texttt{Multi\_CLASS}, a new extension of \texttt{CLASS} that includes the angular power spectrum for multiple (galaxy and other tracers such as gravitational waves) populations.

43 pages, 9 figures. Matches the published version. \texttt{Multi\_CLASS} is now available at https://github.com/nbellomo/Multi_CLASS

References in corpus (119)

• Multi-messenger Observations of a Binary Neutron Star Merger
• Non-Gaussian features of primordial fluctuations in single field inflationary models
• Weak Gravitational Lensing
• The Cosmic Linear Anisotropy Solving System (CLASS) II: Approximation schemes
• Stable clustering, the halo model and nonlinear cosmological power spectra
• Revising the Halofit Model for the Nonlinear Matter Power Spectrum
• Multi-messenger observations of a flaring blazar coincident with high-energy neutrino IceCube-170922A
• Acoustic Signatures in the Primary Microwave Background Bispectrum
• Cosmology and Fundamental Physics with the Euclid Satellite
• Halo occupation numbers and galaxy bias
• Karhunen-Loeve eigenvalue problems in cosmology: how should we tackle large data sets?
• The imprints of primordial non-gaussianities on large-scale structure: scale dependent bias and abundance of virialized objects
• Large-Scale Galaxy Bias
• Second-Order Cosmological Perturbations from Inflation
• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Parameter Estimation Methodology
• The linear power spectrum of observed source number counts
• The Three--Point Correlation Function of the Cosmic Microwave Background in Inflationary Models
• The Nature of Galaxy Bias and Clustering
• What galaxy surveys really measure
• Extended Limber Approximation
• Estimating the Power Spectrum of the Cosmic Microwave Background
• EMU: Evolutionary Map of the Universe
• Baryon Acoustic Oscillations in 2D: Modeling Redshift-space Power Spectrum from Perturbation Theory
• An accurate halo model for fitting non-linear cosmological power spectra and baryonic feedback models
• Clustering of dark matter tracers: generalizing bias for the coming era of precision LSS
• The effect of primordial non-Gaussianity on halo bias
• Weak Lensing and Cosmology
• Stochastic Nonlinear Galaxy Biasing
• Large-scale structure, the cosmic microwave background, and primordial non-gaussianity
• Measuring primordial non-gaussianity without cosmic variance
• Massive Neutrinos and the Non-linear Matter Power Spectrum
• Correlation of CMB with large-scale structure: I. ISW Tomography and Cosmological Implications
• Cosmology with Phase 1 of the Square Kilometre Array; Red Book 2018: Technical specifications and performance forecasts
• The abundance of high-redshift objects as a probe of non-Gaussian initial conditions
• Large-scale clustering of galaxies in general relativity
• Radical Compression of Cosmic Microwave Background Data
• How to measure redshift-space distortions without sample variance
• Likelihood Analysis of CMB Temperature and Polarization Power Spectra
• Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA): improved cosmic growth measurements using multiple tracers of large-scale structure
• Correlation of CMB with large-scale structure: II. Weak lensing
• Bias in the Effective Field Theory of Large Scale Structures
• Renormalized Halo Bias
• Understanding higher-order nonlocal halo bias at large scales by combining the power spectrum with the bispectrum
• Biased Tracers and Time Evolution
• The cosmic merger rate of stellar black hole binaries from the Illustris simulation
• Redshift evolution of clustering
• A Spherical Harmonic Analysis of Redshift Space
• The Impact of Inhomogeneous Reionization on Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy
• Eigenmode Analysis of Galaxy Redshift Surveys I. Theory and Methods
• Large-scale non-Gaussian mass function and halo bias: tests on N-body simulations
• Neutrino masses and cosmological parameters from a Euclid-like survey: Markov Chain Monte Carlo forecasts including theoretical errors
• On model selection forecasting, Dark Energy and modified gravity
• The CLASSgal code for Relativistic Cosmological Large Scale Structure
• Precision calculations of the cosmic shear power spectrum projection
• Effects of Systematic Uncertainties on the Supernova Determination of Cosmological Parameters
• Figure of Merit for Dark Energy Constraints from Current Observational Data
• Redshift Space Distortions of the Correlation Function in Wide Angle Galaxy Surveys
• Modeling Biased Tracers at the Field Level
• Probing dark energy with the shear-ratio geometric test
• Beyond the plane-parallel and Newtonian approach: Wide-angle redshift distortions and convergence in general relativity
• Dependence of cosmic shear covariances on cosmology - Impact on parameter estimation
• On the assumption of Gaussianity for cosmological two-point statistics and parameter dependent covariance matrices
• Beyond Concordance Cosmology with Magnification of Gravitational-Wave Standard Sirens
• The Correlation Function in Redshift Space: General Formula with Wide-angle Effects and Cosmological Distortions
• A generalized local ansatz and its effect on halo bias
• How accurate is Limber's equation?
• Non-Perturbative Effects of Geometry in Wide-Angle Redshift Distortions
• The Galaxy Power Spectrum and Bispectrum in Redshift Space
• Cosmology in the era of Euclid and the Square Kilometre Array
• Anisotropic Magnification Distortion of the 3D Galaxy Correlation: I. Real Space
• The Limits of Cosmic Shear
• A reassessment of the evidence of the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect through the WMAP-NVSS correlation
• Cross-correlations as a cosmological carbon monoxide detector
• Projection effects on the observed angular spectrum of the astrophysical stochastic gravitational wave background
• Bias due to neutrinos must not uncorrect'd go
• GW$\times$LSS: Chasing the Progenitors of Merging Binary Black Holes
• The effect of Limber and flat-sky approximations on galaxy weak lensing
• Measuring the lensing potential with tomographic galaxy number counts
• The BOSS-WiggleZ overlap region I: Baryon Acoustic Oscillations
• Breaking the spell of Gaussianity: forecasting with higher order Fisher matrices
• Simulating Redshift-Space Distortions for Galaxy Pairs with Wide Angular Separation
• On the complementarity of galaxy clustering with cosmic shear and flux magnification
• N-body simulations with generic non-Gaussian initial conditions II: Halo bias
• All-Sky Analysis of the General Relativistic Galaxy Power Spectrum
• Testing Gravity Using Large-Scale Redshift-Space Distortions
• Total Angular Momentum Waves for Scalar, Vector, and Tensor Fields
• Detecting the anisotropic astrophysical gravitational wave background in the presence of shot noise through cross-correlations
• Biases from neutrino bias: to worry or not to worry?
• The Gravitational Lensing in Redshift-space Correlation Functions of Galaxies and Quasars
• Efficient Computation of Galaxy Bias with Neutrinos and Other Relics
• Lensing convergence and the neutrino mass scale in galaxy redshift surveys
• The Impact of Magnification and Size Bias on Weak Lensing Power Spectrum and Peak Statistics
• What can be learned from the lensed cosmic microwave background B-mode polarization power spectrum?
• Likelihood methods for the combined analysis of CMB temperature and polarisation power spectra
• The effect on cosmological parameter estimation of a parameter dependent covariance matrix
• Cross-correlating galaxy catalogs and gravitational waves: a tomographic approach
• Lensing Corrections to Features in the Angular Two-Point Correlation Function and Power Spectrum
• Power spectrum multipoles on the curved sky: an application to the 6-degree Field Galaxy Survey
• 2-FAST: Fast and accurate computation of projected two-point functions
• Beyond the traditional Line-of-Sight approach of cosmological angular statistics
• Systematic errors in the measurement of neutrino masses due to baryonic feedback processes: Prospects for stage IV lensing surveys
• Forecasts of non-Gaussian parameter spaces using Box-Cox transformations
• Interloper bias in future large-scale structure surveys
• The BOSS-WiggleZ overlap region II: dependence of cosmic growth on galaxy type
• A fast, always positive definite and normalizable approximation of non-Gaussian likelihoods
• Developing a unified pipeline for large-scale structure data analysis with angular power spectra -- I. The importance of redshift-space distortions for galaxy number counts
• Wide-angle redshift-space distortions at quasi-linear scales: cross-correlation functions from Zel'dovich approximation
• A Cross-Correlation Study of High-energy Neutrinos and Tracers of Large-Scale Structure
• Improving Fisher matrix forecasts for galaxy surveys: window function, bin cross-correlation, and bin redshift uncertainty
• Optimization of spectroscopic surveys for testing non-Gaussianity
• Developing a unified pipeline for large-scale structure data analysis with angular power spectra -- II. A case study for magnification bias and radio continuum surveys
• The Impact of Non-Gaussianity upon Cosmological Forecasts
• Probing $\Lambda$CDM cosmology with the Evolutionary Map of the Universe survey
• Generalised Fisher Matrices
• BE-HaPPY: Bias Emulator for Halo Power Spectrum including massive neutrinos
• Effect of model-dependent covariance matrix for studying Baryon Acoustic Oscillations
• Lensing corrections on galaxy-lensing cross correlations and galaxy-galaxy auto correlations
• Optimizing parameter constraints: a new tool for Fisher matrix forecasts
• Cross-correlating 2MRS galaxies with UHECR flux from Pierre Auger Observatory

Cited by in corpus (31)

• $Euclid$ preparation: XV. Forecasting cosmological constraints for the $Euclid$ and CMB joint analysis
• GW$\times$LSS: Chasing the Progenitors of Merging Binary Black Holes
• Robustness of baryon acoustic oscillation constraints for early-Universe modifications to $\Lambda$CDM
• CLASS_GWB: robust modeling of the astrophysical gravitational wave background anisotropies
• Euclid preparation: XIX. Impact of magnification on photometric galaxy clustering
• Forecasts on Primordial non-Gaussianity from 21 cm Intensity Mapping experiments
• Exploring galaxies-gravitational waves cross-correlations as an astrophysical probe
• Modified gravity and massive neutrinos: constraints from the full shape analysis of BOSS galaxies and forecasts for Stage IV surveys
• Gravitational waves $\times$ HI intensity mapping: cosmological and astrophysical applications
• Precise and Accurate Cosmology with CMBxLSS Power Spectra and Bispectra
• Signatures of primordial black holes in gravitational wave clustering
• Reconstruction of late-time cosmology using Principal Component Analysis
• Analytic marginalization of $N(z)$ uncertainties in tomographic galaxy surveys
• Constraining extended cosmologies with GW$\times$LSS cross-correlations
• Testing gravity with gravitational waves $\times$ electromagnetic probes cross-correlations
• Constraining Cosmic Inflation with Observations: Prospects for 2030
• Searching for blue in the dark
• The First Billion Years in Seconds: An Effective Model for the 21-cm Signal with Population III Stars
• Joint analyses of 2D CMB lensing and 3D galaxy clustering in the spherical Fourier-Bessel basis
• The full-sky Spherical Fourier-Bessel power spectrum in general relativity
• Dark ages, a window on the dark sector. Hunting for ultra-light axions
• Towards Accurate Modeling of Line-Intensity Mapping One-Point Statistics: Including Extended Profiles
• Beyond Fisher Forecasting for Cosmology
• ${\text{SwiftC}}_{\ell }$: fast differentiable angular power spectra beyond Limber
• Improving CMB constraints on early Universe physics with LSS: A multi-probe forecast including cross-covariance
• Cosmological Simulations of Number Counts
• Inference of cosmological models with principal component analysis
• Delensing CMB B-modes using galaxy surveys: the effect of galaxy bias and matter clustering non-linearities
• Synergy between CSST and third-generation gravitational-wave detectors: Inferring cosmological parameters using cross-correlation of dark sirens and galaxies
• Testing the growth of cosmic structures during the Dark Ages
• Detecting Local and Integrated Relativistic Effects by Multi-Tracing a Single Galaxy Population in Harmonic Space