A Word to the WISE: Confusion is Unavoidable for WISE-selected Infrared Excesses

Abstract

Stars with excess infrared radiation from circumstellar dust are invaluable for studies of exoplanetary systems, informing our understanding on processes of planet formation and destruction alike. All-sky photometric surveys have made the identification of dusty infrared excess candidates trivial, however, samples that rely on data from WISE are plagued with source confusion, leading to high false positive rates. Techniques to limit its contribution to WISE-selected samples have been developed, and their effectiveness is even more important as we near the end-of-life of Spitzer, the only facility capable of confirming the excess. Here, we present a Spitzer follow-up of a sample of 22 WISE-selected infrared excess candidates near the faint-end of the WISE detection limits. Eight of the 22 excesses are deemed the result of source confusion, with the remaining candidates all confirmed by the Spitzer data. We consider the efficacy of ground-based near-infrared imaging and astrometric filtering of samples to limit confusion among the sample. We find that both techniques are worthwhile for vetting candidates, but fail to identify all of the confused excesses, indicating that they cannot be used to confirm WISE-selected infrared excess candidates, but only to rule them out. This result confirms the expectation that WISE-selected infrared excess samples will always suffer from appreciable levels of contamination, and that care should be taken in their interpretation regardless of the filters applied.

arXiv comment13 pages, 4 Figures; Accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (43)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• The Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE): Mission Description and Initial On-orbit Performance
• The Gaia mission
• The Infrared Array Camera (IRAC) for the Spitzer Space Telescope
• The Spitzer Space Telescope Mission
• The UKIRT Infrared Deep Sky Survey (UKIDSS)
• The Galaxy Evolution Explorer: A Space Ultraviolet Survey Mission
• The James Webb Space Telescope
• New evolutionary models for pre-main sequence and main sequence low-mass stars down to the hydrogen-burning limit
• The Tenth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: First Spectroscopic Data from the SDSS-III Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
• Initial Performance of the NEOWISE Reactivation Mission
• VOSA: Virtual Observatory SED Analyzer. An application to the Collinder 69 open cluster
• The WFCAM Science Archive
• A $Gaia$ Data Release 2 catalogue of white dwarfs and a comparison with SDSS
• SkyMapper Southern Survey: First Data Release (DR1)
• The unWISE Catalog: Two Billion Infrared Sources from Five Years of WISE Imaging
• Circumstellar Debris and Pollution at White Dwarf Stars
• The VISTA Science Archive
• DA white dwarfs in SDSS DR7 and a search for infrared excess emission
• Gaia Data Release 2. Cross-match with external catalogues - Algorithms and results
• The WIRED Survey II: Infrared Excesses in the SDSS DR7 White Dwarf Catalog
• The chemical diversity of exo-terrestrial planetary debris around white dwarfs
• Spitzer IRAC Observations of White Dwarfs. I. Warm Dust at Metal-Rich Degenerates
• The unbiased frequency of planetary signatures around single and binary white dwarfs using $Spitzer$ and $Hubble$
• The Frequency of Debris Disks at White Dwarfs
• A Comprehensive Census of Nearby Infrared Excess Stars
• A Sensitive Identification of Warm Debris Disks in the Solar Neighborhood Through Precise Calibration of Saturated WISE Photometry
• The WIRED Survey I: A Bright IR Excess Due to Dust Around the Heavily Polluted White Dwarf GALEX J193156.8+011745
• The WIRED Survey. IV. New Dust Disks from the McCook & Sion White Dwarf Catalog
• Confusion limited surveys: using WISE to quantify the rarity of warm dust around Kepler stars
• Infrared-excess white dwarfs in the Gaia 100 pc sample
• Gaia Data Release 1. Cross-match with external catalogues - Algorithm and results
• Dusty WDs in the $WISE$ All Sky Survey $\cap$ SDSS
• A 3 Gyr White Dwarf with Warm Dust Discovered via the Backyard Worlds: Planet 9 Citizen Science Project
• A WISE-based search for debris discs amongst M-dwarfs in nearby, young, moving groups
• WIRED for EC: New White Dwarfs with $\text{WISE}$ Infrared Excesses and New Classification Schemes from the Edinburgh-Cape Blue Object Survey
• Follow-up Imaging of Disk Candidates from the Disk Detective Citizen Science Project: New Discoveries and False-Positives in WISE Circumstellar Disk Surveys
• A subtle IR excess associated with a young White Dwarf in the Edinburgh-Cape Blue Object Survey
• A catalogue of white dwarf candidates in VST ATLAS
• The Faintest WISE Debris Disks: Enhanced Methods for Detection and Verification
• The Effect of Unresolved Contaminant Stars on the Cross-Matching of Photometric Catalogues
• A Contaminant-Free Catalogue of Gaia DR2-WISE Galactic Plane Matches: Including the Effects of Crowding in the Cross-Matching of Photometric Catalogues

Cited by in corpus (24)

• Recurring Planetary Debris Transits and Circumstellar Gas around White Dwarf ZTF J0328$-$1219
• unTimely: a Full-sky, Time-Domain unWISE Catalog
• Relentless and Complex Transits from a Planetesimal Debris Disk
• White dwarfs with planetary remnants in the era of Gaia I: six emission line systems
• Infrared Excesses around Bright White Dwarfs from Gaia and unWISE I
• Five New Post-Main-Sequence Debris Disks with Gaseous Emission
• The dust never settles: collisional production of gas and dust in evolved planetary systems
• Infrared Excesses around Bright White Dwarfs from Gaia and unWISE. II
• Where are the Extrasolar Mercuries?
• The Geometry of the G29-38 White Dwarf Dust Disk from Radiative Transfer Modeling
• Project Hephaistos - II. Dyson sphere candidates from Gaia DR3, 2MASS, and WISE
• Asteroseismology of luminous red giants with Kepler. II. Dependence of mass loss on pulsations and radiation
• White Dwarfs with Infrared Excess from LAMOST Data Release 5
• 8.9-hr Rotation in the Partly Burnt Runaway Stellar Remnant LP 40-365 (GD 492)
• Velocity-imaging the rapidly precessing planetary disc around the white dwarf HE 1349-2305 using Doppler tomography
• Sensitivity of the Roman Coronagraph Instrument to Exozodiacal Dust
• Disks in Nearby Young Stellar Associations Found Via Virtual Reality
• Infrared and Optical Detectability of Dyson Spheres at White Dwarf Stars
• Serendipitous discovery of a dusty disc around WDJ181417.84-735459.83
• A Data-Driven Search For Mid-Infrared Excesses Among Five Million Main-Sequence FGK Stars
• Gaia white dwarfs with infrared excess I. The 100 pc catalogue
• The SNIa Runaway LP 398-9: Detection of Circumstellar Material and Surface Rotation
• I Can Do It With A Broken Planetesimal: Characterising the planetary debris in heavily polluted cool white dwarfs
• A machine learning approach to estimate mid-infrared fluxes from WISE data