Exploring Whether Super-Puffs Can Be Explained as Ringed Exoplanets

Abstract

An intriguing, growing class of planets are the "super-puffs," objects with exceptionally large radii for their masses and thus correspondingly low densities ($\lesssim 0.3\mathrm{g}\mathrm{c}{\mathrm{m}}^{-3}$). Here we consider whether they could have large inferred radii because they are in fact ringed. This would naturally explain why super-puffs have thus far only shown featureless transit spectra. We find that this hypothesis can work in some cases but not all. The close proximity of the super-puffs to their parent stars necessitates rings with a rocky rather than icy composition. This limits the radius of the rings, and makes it challenging to explain the large size of Kepler 51b, 51c, 51d, and 79d unless the rings are composed of porous material. Furthermore, the short tidal locking timescales for Kepler 18d, 223d, and 223e mean that these planets may be spinning too slowly, resulting in a small oblateness and rings that are warped by their parent star. Kepler 87c and 177c have the best chance of being explained by rings. Using transit simulations, we show that testing this hypothesis requires photometry with a precision of somewhere between ~10 ppm and ~50 ppm, which roughly scales with the ratio of the planet and star's radii. We conclude with a note about the recently discovered super-puff HIP 41378f.

10 pages, 9 figures, updated with minor changes to match version accepted for publication in AJ

References in corpus (52)

• The Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite
• On detecting terrestrial planets with timing of giant planet transits
• DHP Framework: Digital Health Passports Using Blockchain -- Use case on international tourism during the COVID-19 pandemic
• Architecture of Kepler's Multi-transiting Systems: II. New investigations with twice as many candidates
• Overview of the Kepler Science Processing Pipeline
• Density of asteroids
• Breeding Super-Earths and Birthing Super-Puffs in Transitional Disks
• The Heavy Element Masses of Extrasolar Giant Planets, Revealed
• Densities and Eccentricities of 139 Kepler Planets from Transit Time Variations
• A resonant chain of four transiting, sub-Neptune planets
• Kepler Planet Masses and Eccentricities from TTV Analysis
• Bayesian Analysis of Hot Jupiter Radius Anomalies: Evidence for Ohmic Dissipation?
• Very Low-Density Planets around Kepler-51 Revealed with Transit Timing Variations and an Anomaly Similar to a Planet-Planet Eclipse Event
• Kepler 18-b, c, and d: A System Of Three Planets Confirmed by Transit Timing Variations, Lightcurve Validation, Spitzer Photometry and Radial Velocity Measurements
• Satellite dynamics on the Laplace surface
• The Hunt for Exomoons with Kepler (HEK): I. Description of a New Observational Project
• Evidence for a Large Exomoon Orbiting Kepler-1625b
• Measuring the Oblateness and Rotation of Transiting Extrasolar Giant Planets
• Transit Detectability of Ring Systems Around Extrasolar Giant Planets
• Modeling giant extrasolar ring systems in eclipse and the case of J1407b: sculpting by exomoons?
• The Featureless Transmission Spectra of Two Super-Puff Planets
• KOI-152's Low Density Planets
• Obliquity-Driven Sculpting of Exoplanetary Systems
• Towards Space-like Photometric Precision from the Ground with Beam-Shaping Diffusers
• Predicting Photometric and Spectroscopic Signatures of Rings around Transiting Extrasolar Planets
• Tidally-Induced Radius Inflation of Sub-Neptunes
• Measuring Transit Signal Recovery in the Kepler Pipeline I: Individual Events
• The Planetary Mass-Radius Relation and its Dependence on Orbital Period as Measured by Transit Timing Variations and Radial Velocities
• The Boundary between Gas-rich and Gas-poor Planets
• No Evidence for Lunar Transit in New Analysis of Hubble Space Telescope Observations of the Kepler-1625 System
• A novel method for identifying exoplanetary rings
• Diffuser-Assisted Infrared Transit Photometry for Four Dynamically Interacting \textit{Kepler} Systems
• Dusty outflows in planetary atmospheres: Understanding "super-puffs" and transmission spectra of sub-Neptunes
• The Compositional Diversity of Low-Mass Exoplanets
• An Independent Planet Search In The Kepler Dataset. II. An extremely low-density super-Earth mass planet around Kepler-87
• An alternative interpretation of the exomoon candidate signal in the combined Kepler and Hubble data of Kepler-1625
• Detectable molecular features above hydrocarbon haze via transmission spectroscopy with JWST: Case studies of GJ 1214b-, GJ 436b-, HD 97658b-, and Kepler-51b-like planets
• Warm Saturns: On the Nature of Rings around Extrasolar Planets that Reside Inside the Ice Line
• Detecting ring systems around exoplanets using high resolution spectroscopy: the case of 51Pegb
• Probing Structures of Distant Extrasolar Planets with Microlensing
• Detectability of shape deformation in short-period exoplanets
• Detecting transit signatures of exoplanetary rings using SOAP3.0
• Diffuser-assisted Photometric Follow-up Observations of the Neptune-sized Planets K2-28b and K2-100b
• Towards Detection of Exoplanetary Rings Via Transit Photometry: Methodology and a Possible Candidate
• First Light of Engineered Diffusers at the Nordic Optical Telescope Reveal Time Variability in the Optical Eclipse Depth of WASP-12b
• Exoplanets Torqued by the Combined Tides of a Moon and Parent Star
• Constraints on the size and dynamics of the J1407b ring system
• Kepler Object of Interest Network I. First results combining ground and space-based observations of Kepler systems with transit timing variations
• The Possible Moon of Kepler-90g is a False Positive
• Why are dense planetary rings only found between 8 and 20 AU?
• Systematic Search for Rings around Kepler Planet Candidates: Constraints on Ring Size and Occurrence Rate
• Can Rocky Exoplanets with Rings Pose as Sub-Neptunes?

Cited by in corpus (31)

• Evidence for the volatile-rich composition of a 1.5-$R_{\oplus }$ planet
• The First Near-Infrared Transmission Spectrum of HIP 41378 f, a Low-Mass Temperate Jovian World in a Multi-Planet System
• A Featureless Infrared Transmission Spectrum for the Super-Puff Planet Kepler-79d
• Sculpting the sub-Saturn Occurrence Rate via Atmospheric Mass Loss
• Kepler-90: Giant transit-timing variations reveal a super-puff
• A Framework for Characterizing Transmission Spectra of Exoplanets with Circumplanetary Rings
• Oblique rings from migrating exomoons: A possible origin for long-period exoplanets with enlarged radii
• A fast-growing tilt instability of detached circumplanetary disks
• Cronomoons: origin, dynamics, and light-curve features of ringed exomoons
• Stability and detectability of exomoons orbiting HIP 41378 f, a temperate Jovian planet with an anomalously low apparent density
• Scattered light may reveal the existence of ringed exoplanets
• Architecture Classification for Extrasolar Planetary Systems
• A Circumplanetary Dust Ring May Explain the Extreme Spectral Slope of the 10 Myr Young Exoplanet K2-33b
• Detecting Planetary Oblateness in the Era of JWST: A Case Study of Kepler-167e
• The bright side of the light curve: a general photometric model of non-transiting exorings
• Future destabilisation of Titan as a result of Saturn's tilting
• An extremely low-density exoplanet spins slow
• Transit Depth Variations Reveal TOI-216 b to be a Super-Puff
• Scattered polarized radiation of extrasolar circumplanetary rings
• The K2-24 planetary system revisited by CHEOPS
• Kozai-Lidov oscillations triggered by a tilt instability of detached circumplanetary discs
• One of Everything: The Breakthrough Listen Exotica Catalog
• Transit Timing Variations in HIP 41378: CHEOPS and TESS confirm a non-transiting sixth planet in the system
• Exploring Exoplanet Dynamics with JWST: Tides, Rotation, Rings, and Moons
• A general polarimetric model for transiting and non-transiting ringed exoplanets
• Search for Exoplanetary Ring Systems with TESS
• The formation of transiting circumplanetary debris discs from the disruption of satellite systems during planet-planet scattering
• The Dynamical Viability of an Extended Jupiter Ring System
• TOI-3757 b: A low density gas giant orbiting a solar-metallicity M dwarf
• A Multi-Planet System's Sole Super-Puff: Exploring Allowable Physical Parameters for the Cold Super-Puff HIP 41378 f
• Grain Growth in Escaping Atmospheres: Implications for the Radius Inflation of Super-Puffs