The effects of numerical resolution, heating timescales and background heating on thermal non-equilibrium in coronal loops

Abstract

Thermal non-equilibrium (TNE) is believed to be a potentially important process in understanding some properties of the magnetically closed solar corona. Through one-dimensional hydrodynamic models, this paper addresses the importance of the numerical spatial resolution, footpoint heating timescales and background heating on TNE. Inadequate transition region (TR) resolution can lead to significant discrepancies in TNE cycle behaviour, with TNE being suppressed in under-resolved loops. A convergence on the periodicity and plasma properties associated with TNE required spatial resolutions of less than 2 km for a loop of length 180 Mm. These numerical problems can be resolved using an approximate method that models the TR as a discontinuity using a jump condition, as proposed by Johnston et al. (2017a,b). The resolution requirements (and so computational cost) are greatly reduced while retaining good agreement with fully resolved results. Using this approximate method we (i) identify different regimes for the response of coronal loops to time-dependent footpoint heating including one where TNE does not arise and (ii) demonstrate that TNE in a loop with footpoint heating is suppressed unless the background heating is sufficiently small. The implications for the generality of TNE are discussed.

arXiv comment15 pages, 10 figures, 1 table, accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (37)

• On Solving the Coronal Heating Problem
• Heating of the Solar Chromosphere and Corona by Alfven Wave Turbulence
• Highly Efficient Modeling of Dynamic Coronal Loops
• Key Aspects of Coronal Heating
• The Dynamic Formation of Prominence Condensations
• Observing the fine structure of loops through high resolution spectroscopic observations of coronal rain with the CRISP instrument at the Swedish Solar Telescope
• Evidence of Non-Thermal Particles in Coronal Loops Heated Impulsively by Nanoflares
• Coronal rain as a marker for coronal heating mechanisms
• An Ab Initio approach to Solar Coronal Loops
• The influence of numerical resolution on coronal density in hydrodynamic models of impulsive heating
• On active region loops: Hinode/EIS observations
• Constraints on the Heating of High Temperature Active Region Loops: Observations from Hinode and SDO
• Enthalpy-based Thermal Evolution of Loops: II. Improvements to the Model
• The multi-thermal and multi-stranded nature of coronal rain
• Can Thermal Nonequilibrium Explain Coronal Loops?
• Multidimensional modeling of coronal rain dynamics
• Evidence for evaporation-incomplete condensation cycles in warm solar coronal loops
• Constant cross section of loops in the solar corona
• The Role of Type II Spicules in the Upper Solar Atmosphere
• On the occurrence of thermal non-equilibrium in coronal loops
• Coronal rain in magnetic arcades: Rebound shocks, Limit cycles, and Shear flows
• On-disk coronal rain
• Long-period intensity pulsations in the solar corona during activity cycle 23
• Long-Period Intensity Pulsations in Coronal Loops Explained by Thermal Non-Equilibrium Cycles
• The Coronal Monsoon: Thermal Nonequilibrium Revealed by Periodic Coronal Rain
• Dynamics of coronal rain and descending plasma blobs in solar prominences: I. Fully ionised case
• Impact of Type II Spicules in the Corona: Simulations and Synthetic Observables
• Continuous upflows and sporadic downflows observed in active regions
• Coronal rain in magnetic bipolar weak fields
• Signatures of impulsive localized heating in the temperature distribution of multi-stranded coronal loops
• Inference of Heating Properties from "Hot" Non-flaring Plasmas in Active Region Cores. II. Nanoflare Trains
• Catastrophic cooling and cessation of heating in the solar corona
• A new approach for modelling chromospheric evaporation in response to enhanced coronal heating: I The method
• Identifying Observables that can Differentiate Between Impulsive and Footpoint Heating: Time Lags and Intensity Ratios
• Can Large Time Delays Observed in Light Curves of Coronal Loops be Explained by Impulsive Heating?
• Hard X-Ray Constraints on Small-Scale Coronal Heating Events
• A new approach for modelling chromospheric evaporation in response to enhanced coronal heating: II Non-uniform heating

Cited by in corpus (22)

• The Role of Asymmetries in Thermal Non-Equilibrium
• Transition region adaptive conduction (TRAC) in multidimensional magnetohydrodynamic simulations
• Multi-scale observations of thermal non-equilibrium cycles in coronal loops
• Electron Beams Cannot Directly Produce Coronal Rain
• Self-consistent 3D radiative MHD simulations of coronal rain formation and evolution
• Modelling the solar transition region using an adaptive conduction method
• Spatial and Temporal Analysis of Quiescent Coronal Rain over an Active Region
• Chromospheric evaporation and phase mixing of Alfvén waves in coronal loops
• Dynamic formation of multi-threaded prominences in arcade configurations
• EUV fine structure and variability associated with coronal rain revealed by Solar Orbiter/EUI HRIEUV and SPICE
• Relation of coronal rain originating from coronal condensations to interchange magnetic reconnection
• On the spectroscopic detection of periodic plasma flows in loops undergoing thermal non-equilibrium
• Winking filaments due to cyclic evaporation-condensation
• Modeling of Condensations in Coronal Loops Produced by Impulsive Heating
• Simulation of Thermal Nonequilibrium Cycles in the Solar Wind
• Implications of spicule activity on coronal loop heating and catastrophic cooling
• Transition region contribution to AIA observations in the context of coronal heating
• Spatiotemporal Low FIP Abundance: A Catalyst for Coronal Condensation
• Multi-Stranded Coronal Loops: Quantifying Strand Number and Heating Frequency from Simulated Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) Observations
• The Equilibrium of Coronal Loops Near Separatrices
• A fast multi-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic formulation of the transition region adaptive conduction (TRAC) method
• Thermal Non-equilibrium Cycles in a Non-eruptive Pseudo-Streamer