Can Thermal Nonequilibrium Explain Coronal Loops?

Abstract

Any successful model of coronal loops must explain a number of observed properties. For warm (~ 1 MK) loops, these include: 1. excess density, 2. flat temperature profile, 3. super-hydrostatic scale height, 4. unstructured intensity profile, and 5. 1000--5000 s lifetime. We examine whether thermal nonequilibrium can reproduce the observations by performing hydrodynamic simulations based on steady coronal heating that decreases exponentially with height. We consider both monolithic and multi-stranded loops. The simulations successfully reproduce certain aspects of the observations, including the excess density, but each of them fails in at least one critical way. Monolithic models have far too much intensity structure, while multi-strand models are either too structured or too long-lived. Our results appear to rule out the widespread existence of heating that is both highly concentrated low in the corona and steady or quasi-steady (slowly varying or impulsive with a rapid cadence). Active regions would have a very different appearance if the dominant heating mechanism had these properties. Thermal nonequilibrium may nonetheless play an important role in prominences and catastrophic cooling events (e.g., coronal rain) that occupy a small fraction of the coronal volume. However, apparent inconsistencies between the models and observations of cooling events have yet to be understood.

40 pages, 10 figures, accepted by the Astrophysical Journal (vol. 714)

References in corpus (5)

• Highly Efficient Modeling of Dynamic Coronal Loops
• Active region transition region loop populations and their relationship to the corona
• Signatures of impulsive localized heating in the temperature distribution of multi-stranded coronal loops
• The temporal evolution of coronal loops observed by GOES-SXI
• Are constant loop widths an artifact of the background and the spatial resolution?

Cited by in corpus (51)

• Heating of the Solar Chromosphere and Corona by Alfven Wave Turbulence
• Key Aspects of Coronal Heating
• Observing the fine structure of loops through high resolution spectroscopic observations of coronal rain with the CRISP instrument at the Swedish Solar Telescope
• The Properties of the Solar Corona and Its Connection to the Solar Wind
• Formation of Solar Filaments by Steady and Nonsteady Chromospheric Heating
• The multi-thermal and multi-stranded nature of coronal rain
• Multidimensional modeling of coronal rain dynamics
• Evidence for evaporation-incomplete condensation cycles in warm solar coronal loops
• Emission Measure Distribution and Heating of Two Active Region Cores
• The Role of Type II Spicules in the Upper Solar Atmosphere
• On the occurrence of thermal non-equilibrium in coronal loops
• The Spatial and Temporal Dependence of Coronal Heating by Alfven Wave Turbulence
• Long-period intensity pulsations in the solar corona during activity cycle 23
• Observations of Solar Coronal Rain in Null Point Topologies
• Modeling the Line-of-Sight Integrated Emission in the Corona: Implications for Coronal Heating
• Long-Period Intensity Pulsations in Coronal Loops Explained by Thermal Non-Equilibrium Cycles
• The Coronal Monsoon: Thermal Nonequilibrium Revealed by Periodic Coronal Rain
• The Role of Asymmetries in Thermal Non-Equilibrium
• Coronal cavities: observations and implications for the magnetic environment of prominences
• The effects of numerical resolution, heating timescales and background heating on thermal non-equilibrium in coronal loops
• A Comprehensive Radiative Magnetohydrodynamics Simulation of Active Region Scale Flux Emergence from the Convection Zone to the Corona
• Evidence of Impulsive Heating in Active Region Core Loops
• Multi-scale observations of thermal non-equilibrium cycles in coronal loops
• Catastrophic cooling and cessation of heating in the solar corona
• First radio evidence for impulsive heating contribution to the quiet solar corona
• Spectroscopic Observations of a Coronal Loop: Basic Physical Plasma Parameters Along the Full Loop Length
• Imaging and Spectroscopic Observations of a Transient Coronal Loop: Evidence for the Non-Maxwellian $\kappa$-Distributions
• Chromospheric Nanoflares as a Source of Coronal Plasma: II. Repeating Nanoflares
• Thermal non-equilibriuem revealed by periodic pulses of random amplitudes in solar coronal loops
• Identifying Observables that can Differentiate Between Impulsive and Footpoint Heating: Time Lags and Intensity Ratios
• Theory of gyroresonance and free-free emissions from non-Maxwellian quasi-steady-state electron distributions
• Can Large Time Delays Observed in Light Curves of Coronal Loops be Explained by Impulsive Heating?
• Active Region Moss: Doppler Shifts from Hinode/EIS Observations
• Dynamics of internetwork chromospheric fibrils: Basic properties and MHD kink waves
• Self-Organization of Reconnecting Plasmas to Marginal Collisionality in the Solar Corona
• Doppler shift of hot coronal lines in a moss area of an active region
• Modeling Coronal Response in Decaying Active Regions with Magnetic Flux Transport and Steady Heating
• Post-flare UV light curves explained with thermal instability of loop plasma
• On the Area Expansion of Magnetic Flux-Tubes in Solar Active Regions
• Non-equilibrium ionization by a periodic electron beam. I. Synthetic coronal spectra and implications for interpretation of observations
• Observations and modeling of the emerging EUV loops in the quiet Sun as seen with the Solar Dynamics Observatory
• Winking filaments due to cyclic evaporation-condensation
• Modeling of Condensations in Coronal Loops Produced by Impulsive Heating
• One dimensional prominence threads: I. Equilibrium models
• Are the brightest coronal loops always rooted in mixed-polarity magnetic flux?
• The nature of small scale EUV solar brightenings investigated as impulsive heating of short loops in 1D hydrododynamics simulations
• Dominance of Bursty over Steady Heating of the 4--8 MK Coronal Plasma in a Solar Active Region: Quantification using Maps of Minimum, Maximum, and Average Brightness
• Forward modelling of heating within a coronal arcade
• Three-Dimensional Reconstruction and Thermal Modelling of Observed Loops
• Long-lived coronal loops in solar active regions
• Formation and Characteristics of Filament Threads in Double-Dipped Magnetic Flux Tubes