Speaking with one voice: simulations and observations discuss the common envelope $\alpha$ parameter

Abstract

We present a comparative study between the results of most hydrodynamic simulations of the common envelope binary interaction to date and observations of post common envelope binaries. The goal is to evaluate whether this dataset indicates the existence of a formula that may predict final separations of post-common envelope systems as a function of pre-common envelope parameters. Some of our conclusions are not surprising while others are more subtle. We find that: (i) Values of the final orbital separation derived from common envelope simulations must at this time be considered upper limits. Simulations that include recombination energy do not seem to have systematically different final separations; these and other simulations imply ${\alpha }_{\mathrm{CE}}<0.6-1.0$. At least one simulation, {applicable to double-degenerate systems}, implies ${\alpha }_{\mathrm{CE}}<0.2$. (ii) Despite large reconstruction errors, the post-RGB observations reconstructed parameters are in agreement with some of the simulations. The post-AGB observations behave instead as if they had a systematically lower value of ${\alpha }_{\mathrm{CE}}$. The lack of common envelope simulations with low mass AGB stars leaves us with no insight as to why this is the case. (iii) The smallest mass companion that survives the common envelope with intermediate mass giants is 0.05-0.1~\ms. (iv) Observations of binaries with separations larger than $\sim$10~\rs, tend to have high $M_2/M_1$ mass ratios and may go through a relatively long phase of unstable Roche lobe mass transfer followed by a weakened common envelope (or with no common envelope at all). (v) The effect of the spatial resolution and of the softening length on simulation results remains poorly quantified.

arXiv commentAccepted by MNRAS

References in corpus (54)

• On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
• Accurate masses and radii of normal stars: modern results and applications
• Common Envelope Evolution: Where we stand and how we can move forward
• Enzo: An Adaptive Mesh Refinement Code for Astrophysics
• Phantom: A smoothed particle hydrodynamics and magnetohydrodynamics code for astrophysics
• Post-common-envelope binaries from SDSS. IX: Constraining the common-envelope efficiency
• Post-common-envelope binaries from SDSS. XI: The white dwarf mass distributions of CVs and pre-CVs
• An AMR Study of the Common Envelope Phase of Binary Evolution
• Low-Mass Binary Induced Outflows from Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars
• Simulating the Common Envelope Phase of a Red Giant Using SPH and Uniform Grid Codes
• The age, life expectancy, and space density of Post Common Envelope Binaries
• On the alpha formalism for the common envelope interaction
• Double Core Evolution X. Through the Envelope Ejection Phase
• The Interaction of Stellar Objects within a Common Envelope
• Hydrodynamic moving-mesh simulations of the common envelope phase in binary stellar systems
• On the Formation and Evolution of Common Envelope Systems
• Accretion in common envelope evolution
• The effect of a wider initial separation on common envelope binary interaction simulations
• Recombination energy in double white dwarf formation
• A comprehensive population synthesis study of post-common envelope binaries
• Hydrodynamic Simulations of the Interaction between Giant Stars and Planets
• Common envelope events with low-mass giants: understanding the transition to the slow spiral-in
• Observational Confirmation of a Link Between Common Envelope Binary Interaction and Planetary Nebula Shaping
• On the Formation of Helium Double Degenerate Stars and Pre-Cataclysmic Variables
• Binary central stars of PN discovered through photometric variability. I. What we know and what we would like to find out
• Common envelope events with low-mass giants: understanding the energy budget
• Extending Common Envelope Simulations from Roche Lobe Overflow to the Nebular Phase
• Companion-launched jets and their effect on the dynamics of common envelope interaction simulations
• Analytical expressions for the envelope binding energy of giants as a function of basic stellar parameters
• Magnetic Field Amplification During the Common Envelope Phase
• Hydrodynamic Simulations of the Interaction between an AGB Star and a Main Sequence Companion in Eccentric Orbits
• Is the common envelope ejection efficiency a function of the binary parameters?
• Constructing stable 3D hydrodynamical models of giant stars
• The limited role of recombination energy in common envelope removal
• The Formation of Cataclysmic Variables with Brown Dwarf Secondaries
• Population Synthesis Studies of Close Binary Systems Using a Variable Common Envelope Efficiency Parameter: I. Dependence upon Secondary Mass
• The post-common envelope central stars of the planetary nebulae Henize 2-155 and Henize 2-161
• On the use of hydrogen recombination energy during common envelope events
• The Role of Convection in Determining the Ejection Efficiency of Common Envelope Interactions
• Common Envelope Evolution on a Moving Mesh
• The effect of binding energy and resolution in simulations of the common envelope binary interaction
• Simulating a binary system that experiences the grazing envelope evolution
• Post-common-envelope binaries from SDSS. XIII: Mass dependencies of the orbital period distribution
• Simulating the Onset of Grazing Envelope Evolution of Binary Stars
• The mass and radius of the M dwarf companion to GD 448
• Radiating the hydrogen recombination energy during common envelope evolution
• Binary Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae Discovered Through Photometric Variability V: The Central Stars of HaTr 7 and ESO 330-9
• The evolution of the self-lensing binary KOI-3278: evidence of extra energy sources during CE evolution
• The short orbital period binary star at the heart of the planetary nebula M 3-1
• Energy Budget and Core-Envelope Motion in Common Envelope Evolution
• Binary Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae Discovered Through Photometric Variability III: The Central Star of Abell 65
• On the post-common-envelope central star of the planetary nebula NGC 2346
• A Moving Mesh Hydrodynamic Solver for ChaNGa
• Non-Detection of the Putative Substellar Companion to HD 149382

Cited by in corpus (44)

• The role of mass transfer and common envelope evolution in the formation of merging binary black holes
• The impact of common envelope development criteria on the formation of LIGO/Virgo sources
• Companion-launched jets and their effect on the dynamics of common envelope interaction simulations
• Luminous Red Novae: population models and future prospects
• Common-envelope evolution with an asymptotic giant branch star
• Common-Envelope Episodes that lead to Double Neutron Star formation
• A Catalogue of Potential Post Common Envelope Binaries
• A two-stage formalism for common-envelope phases of massive stars
• Pre-Common-Envelope Mass Loss from Coalescing Binary Systems
• Disk formation and jet inclination effects in Common Envelopes
• A massive helium star with a sufficiently strong magnetic field to form a magnetar
• Binary Central Stars of Planetary Nebulae Identified With Kepler/K2
• Properties of the post in-spiral common envelope ejecta II: dust formation
• Common envelopes in massive stars II: The distinct roles of hydrogen and helium recombination
• How Drag Force Evolves in Global Common Envelope Simulations
• Convection and Spin-Up During Common Envelope Evolution: The Formation of Short-Period Double White Dwarfs
• Common Envelope Evolution on the Asymptotic Giant Branch: Unbinding within a Decade?
• Constraints on the contributions to the observed binary black hole population from individual evolutionary pathways in isolated binary evolution
• Evolution and final fate of massive post-common-envelope binaries
• Convection Reconciles the Difference in Efficiencies Between Low-Mass and High-Mass Common Envelopes
• Common envelope binary interaction simulations between a thermally-pulsating AGB star and a low mass companion
• Post-dynamical inspiral phase of common envelope evolution: Binary orbit evolution and angular momentum transport
• Observational Constraints on the Common Envelope Phase
• Exploring the evolution of gravitational-wave emitters with efficient emulation: Constraining the origins of binary black holes using normalising flows
• The post-common-envelope binary central star of the planetary nebula Ou 5: a doubly-eclipsing post-red-giant-branch system
• Type IIb supernova progenitors by fatal common envelope evolution
• The first catalog of candidate white dwarf-main sequence binaries in open star clusters: A new window into common envelope evolution
• Jet parameters for a diverse sample of jet-launching post-AGB binaries
• The ionised and molecular mass of post-common-envelope planetary nebulae. The missing mass problem
• Tracing the evolution of short-period binaries with super-synchronous fast rotators
• Gravitational wave emission from dynamical stellar interactions
• A population synthesis study of the Gaia 100 pc unresolved white dwarf-main sequence binary population
• The final orbital separation in common envelope evolution
• The common envelope origins of the fast jet in the planetary nebula M 3-38
• Anomalously low-mass core-He-burning star in NGC 6819 as a post-common-envelope phase product
• Statistics of Magrathea exoplanets beyond the Main Sequence. Simulating the long-term evolution of circumbinary giant planets with TRES
• Population synthesis of hot subdwarf B stars with COMPAS: on the observed Galactic population
• An optimal envelope ejection efficiency for merging neutron stars
• Gravitational Wave Strain and Orbital Dynamics of Binary Pulsars from LIGO-Virgo to LISA
• Second-generation planet formation after tidal disruption from common envelope evolution
• The post-common-envelope binary central star of the planetary nebula PN G283.7-05.1: A possible post-red-giant-branch planetary nebula central star
• The Energy Sharing Timescale in an Analytic Framework for Common Envelope Hydrodynamics
• Using Binary Population Synthesis to Calculate the Yields of Low- and Intermediate-Mass Binary Populations at Low Metallicity
• Light Curve Models of Convective Common Envelopes