Deciphering the atmosphere of HAT-P-12b: solving discrepant results

Abstract

Two independent investigations of the atmosphere of the hot Jupiter HAT-P-12b by two different groups resulted in discrepant solutions. Using broad-band photometry from the ground, one study found a flat and featureless transmission spectrum which was interpreted as a gray absorption by dense cloud coverage. The second study made use of the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) observations and found Rayleigh scattering at optical wavelengths caused by haze. The main purpose of this work is to find the source of this inconsistency and provide feedback to prevent similar discrepancies in future analyses of other exoplanetary atmospheres. We studied the observed discrepancy via two methods. With further broad-band observations in the optical wavelength regions, we strengthened the previous measurements in precision and with a homogeneous reanalysis of the published data, we managed to assess the systematic errors and the independent analyses of the two different groups. Repeating the analysis steps of both works, we found that deviating values for the orbital parameters are the reason for the aforementioned discrepancy. Our work showed a degeneracy of the planetary spectral slope with these parameters. In a homogeneous reanalysis of all data, the two literature data sets and the new observations converge to a consistent transmission spectrum, showing a low-amplitude spectral slope and a tentative detection of potassium absorption.

Accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (29)

• The effect of red noise on planetary transit detection
• The Transit Light Source Effect: False Spectral Features and Incorrect Densities for M-dwarf Transiting Planets
• Homogeneous studies of transiting extrasolar planets. I. Light curve analyses
• The Transit Light Curve Project. IX. Evidence for a Smaller Radius of the Exoplanet XO-3b
• HST hot-Jupiter transmission spectral survey: detection of potassium in WASP-31b along with a cloud deck and Rayleigh scattering
• HAT-P-26b: A Neptune-Mass Exoplanet with a Well Constrained Heavy Element Abundance
• The Complete transmission spectrum of WASP-39b with a precise water constraint
• An absolute sodium abundance for a cloud-free 'hot Saturn' exoplanet
• HAT-P-12b: A Low-Density Sub-Saturn Mass Planet Transiting a Metal-Poor K Dwarf
• The effect of stellar limb darkening values on the accuracy of the planet radii derived from photometric transit observations
• HST hot-Jupiter transmission spectral survey: Haze in the atmosphere of WASP-6b
• Impact of occultations of stellar active regions on transmission spectra: Can occultation of a plage mimic the signature of a blue sky?
• A method for the direct determination of the surface gravities of transiting extrasolar planets
• VLT FORS2 comparative transmission spectroscopy: Detection of Na in the atmosphere of WASP-39b from the ground
• Water, High-Altitude Condensates, and Possible Methane Depletion in the Atmosphere of the Warm Super-Neptune WASP-107b
• Highlights in the Study of Exoplanet Atmospheres
• The GAPS Programme with HARPS-N at TNG XVI: Measurement of the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect of the transiting planetary systems HAT-P-3, HAT-P-12, HAT-P-22, WASP-39 and WASP-60
• VLT/FORS2 comparative transmission spectroscopy II: confirmation of a cloud-deck and Rayleigh scattering in WASP-31b, but no potassium?
• Warm Ice Giant GJ 3470b. II Revised Planetary and Stellar Parameters from Optical to Near-infrared Transit Photometry
• GJ1214: Rotation period, starspots, and uncertainty on the optical slope of the transmission spectrum
• Investigating the physical properties of transiting hot Jupiters with the 1.5-m Kuiper Telescope
• LRG-BEASTS III: Ground-based transmission spectrum of the gas giant orbiting the cool dwarf WASP-80
• $\text{PyTranSpot}$ - A tool for multiband light curve modeling of planetary transits and stellar spots
• Broad-band spectrophotometry of HAT-P-32 b: Search for a scattering signature in the planetary spectrum
• Probing the atmosphere of a sub-Jovian planet orbiting a cool dwarf
• The GTC exoplanet transit spectroscopy survey VIII. Flat transmission spectrum for the warm gas giant WASP-80
• Near-UV transit photometry of HAT-P-32 b with the LBT: Silicate aerosols in the planetary atmosphere
• No variations in transit times for Qatar-1 b
• Transmission spectroscopy of the hot Jupiter TrES-3 b: Disproof of an overly large Rayleigh-like feature

Cited by in corpus (44)

• TESS Transit Timing of Hundreds of Hot Jupiters
• The GTC exoplanet transit spectroscopy survey IX. Detection of Haze, Na, K, and Li in the super-Neptune WASP-127b
• ExoClock Project III: 450 new exoplanet ephemerides from ground and space observations
• ARES I: WASP-76 b, A Tale of Two HST Spectra
• Hubble WFC3 Spectroscopy of the Habitable-zone Super-Earth LHS 1140 b
• Sodium and Potassium Signatures of Volcanic Satellites Orbiting Close-in Gas Giant Exoplanets
• ExoClock project II: A large-scale integrated study with 180 updated exoplanet ephemerides
• On The Compatibility of Ground-based and Space-based Data: WASP-96 b, An Example
• The Hubble PanCET program: Transit and Eclipse Spectroscopy of the Strongly Irradiated Giant Exoplanet WASP-76b
• Low albedos of hot to ultra-hot Jupiters in the optical to near-infrared transition regime
• The GTC exoplanet transit spectroscopy survey XI. Possible detection of Rayleigh scattering in the atmosphere of the Saturn-mass planet WASP-69b
• KELT-11 b: Abundances of water and constraints on carbon-bearing molecules from the Hubble transmission spectrum
• Optical to near-infrared transmission spectrum of the warm sub-Saturn HAT-P-12b
• Cleaning our Hazy Lens: Exploring Trends in Transmission Spectra of Warm Exoplanets
• High-Resolution Transit Spectroscopy of Warm Saturns
• HST/STIS transmission spectrum of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 b confirms the presence of sodium in its atmosphere
• Probing the atmosphere of WASP-69 b with low- and high-resolution transmission spectroscopy
• LBT transmission spectroscopy of HAT-P-12b: confirmation of a cloudy atmosphere with no significant alkali features
• Physical properties and transmission spectrum of the WASP-74 planetary system from multi-band photometry
• WASP-117 b: an eccentric hot-Saturn as a future complex chemistry laboratory
• The Hubble PanCET Program: A Metal-rich Atmosphere for the Inflated Hot Jupiter HAT-P-41b
• BOWIE-ALIGN: JWST reveals hints of planetesimal accretion and complex sulphur chemistry in the atmosphere of the misaligned hot Jupiter WASP-15b
• Storms or Systematics? The changing secondary eclipse depth of WASP-12b
• An enhanced slope in the transmission spectrum of the hot Jupiter WASP-104b
• Evidence for TiO in the atmosphere of the hot Jupiter HAT-P-65 b
• A large range of haziness conditions in hot-Jupiter atmospheres
• Ground-based optical transmission spectrum of the hot Jupiter HAT-P-1b
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs. Diagnostic capabilities of strong K I lines for photosphere and chromosphere
• Role of the impact parameter in exoplanet transmission spectroscopy
• Detection of TiO and VO in the atmosphere of WASP-121b and Evidence for its temporal variation
• HST/STIS capability for Love number measurement of WASP-121b
• Evidence for stellar contamination in the transmission spectra of HAT-P-12b
• Terminus: A Versatile Simulator for Space-based Telescopes
• Tentative detection of titanium oxide in the atmosphere of WASP-69 b with a 4m ground-based telescope
• Non-Sinusoidal Transit Timing Variations for the Exoplanet HAT-P-12b
• Detection capability of ground-based meter-sized telescopes for shallow exoplanet transits
• Thermal Emission from the hot Jupiter WASP-103b in J and Ks Bands
• A Population Analysis of 20 Exoplanets Observed from the Optical to the Near-infrared Wavelengths with HST: Evidence for Widespread Stellar Contamination
• Comparing transit spectroscopy pipelines at the catalogue level: evidence for systematic differences
• A re-analysis of equilibrium chemistry in five hot Jupiters
• Detection of CO${}_2$, CO, and H${}_2$O in the atmosphere of the warm sub-Saturn HAT-P-12b
• A Two-limb Explanation for the Optical-to-infrared Transmission Spectrum of the Hot Jupiter HAT-P-32Ab
• Information content of JWST transmission spectroscopy of the exoplanet HAT-P-12b from the optical to the mid-infrared
• Transit Timing Variations of the Sub-Saturn Exoplanet HAT-P-12b