No evidence for modifications of gravity from galaxy motions on cosmological scales

Abstract

The recent discovery of gravitational waves marks the culmination of a sequence of successful tests of the general theory of relativity (GR) since its formulation in 1915. Yet these tests remain confined to the scale of stellar systems or the strong gravity regime. A departure from GR on larger, cosmological scales has been advocated by the proponents of modified gravity theories as an alternative to the Cosmological Constant to account for the observed cosmic expansion history. While indistinguishable in these terms by construction, such models on the other hand yield distinct values for the linear growth rate of density perturbations and, as a consequence, for the associated galaxy peculiar velocity field. Measurements of the resulting anisotropy of galaxy clustering, when spectroscopic redshifts are used to derive distances, have thus been proposed as a powerful probe of the validity of GR on cosmological scales. However, despite significant effort in modelling such redshift space distortions, systematic errors remain comparable to current statistical uncertainties. Here, we present the results of a different forward-modelling approach, which fully exploits the sensitivity of the galaxy velocity field to modifications of GR. We use state-of-the-art, high-resolution N-body simulations of a standard GR and a compelling f(R) model, one of GR's simplest variants, to build simulated catalogues of stellar-mass-selected galaxies through a robust match to the Sloan Digital Sky Survey observations. We find that, well within the uncertainty of this technique, f(R) fails to reproduce the observed redshift-space clustering on scales 1-10 Mpc/h. Instead, the standard LCDM GR model agrees impressively well with the data. This result provides a strong confirmation, on cosmological scales, of the robustness of Einstein's general theory of relativity.

35 Pages, 8 figures. Published in Nature Astronomy. This is the submitted version according to the journal policy. Full article available here (https://rdcu.be/7DiG)

References in corpus (10)

• GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• Models of f(R) Cosmic Acceleration that Evade Solar-System Tests
• K-corrections and filter transformations in the ultraviolet, optical, and near infrared
• An Ordinary Short Gamma-Ray Burst with Extraordinary Implications: Fermi-GBM Detection of GRB 170817A
• Galaxy Groups in the SDSS DR4: I. The Catalogue and Basic Properties
• A test of the nature of cosmic acceleration using galaxy redshift distortions
• The Importance of Satellite Quenching for the Build-Up of the Red Sequence of Present Day Galaxies
• Cluster Constraints on f(R) Gravity
• A 2.5% measurement of the growth rate from small-scale redshift space clustering of SDSS-III CMASS galaxies

Cited by in corpus (32)

• Large-scale dark matter simulations
• On the road to percent accuracy: nonlinear reaction of the matter power spectrum to dark energy and modified gravity
• Constraints on the interacting vacuum -- geodesic CDM scenario
• Finite-time Cosmological Singularities and the Possible Fate of the Universe
• Testing the theory of gravity with DESI: estimators, predictions and simulation requirements
• Five-percent measurements of the growth rate from simulation-based modelling of redshift-space clustering in BOSS LOWZ
• Realistic simulations of galaxy formation in f(R) modified gravity
• Designing Horndeski and the effective fluid approach
• Large-scale redshift space distortions in modified gravity theories
• The impact of modified gravity on the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect
• Generalized SU(2) Proca theory reconstructed and beyond
• Einstein Yang-Mills Higgs dark energy revisited
• Anisotropic Einstein Yang-Mills Higgs Dark Energy
• An accurate method to determine the systematics due to the peculiar velocities of galaxies in measuring the Hubble constant from gravitational wave standard sirens
• Redshift space power spectrum beyond Einstein-de Sitter kernels
• Constraints on field flows of quintessence dark energy
• Anisotropic solid dark energy
• Anisotropic $k$-essence
• A general framework to test gravity using galaxy clusters III: Observable-mass scaling relations in $f(R)$ gravity
• Cosmological Probes of Structure Growth and Tests of Gravity
• Probing gravity with redshift-space distortions: effects of tracer bias and sample selection
• A study on Cubic Galileon Gravity Using N-body Simulations
• Screening maps of the local Universe I -- Methodology
• Cosmological constraints with the Effective Fluid approach for Modified Gravity
• A general framework to test gravity using galaxy clusters VI: Realistic galaxy formation simulations to study clusters in modified gravity
• Towards an accurate model of small-scale redshift-space distortions in modified gravity
• A general framework to test gravity using galaxy clusters V: A self-consistent pipeline for unbiased constraints of $f(R)$ gravity
• w=1/3 to w=-1 evolution in a Robertson-Walker space-time with constant scalar curvature
• Measuring the growth of structure by matching dark matter haloes to galaxies with VIPERS and SDSS
• Modelling the tightest relation between galaxy properties and dark matter halo properties from hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation
• The connection between halo concentrations and assembly histories: a probe of gravity?
• Fullshape power spectrum for the Symmetron modified gravity model