Resilience and efficiency in transportation networks

Abstract

Urban transportation systems are vulnerable to congestion, accidents, weather, special events, and other costly delays. Whereas typical policy responses prioritize reduction of delays under normal conditions to improve the efficiency of urban road systems, analytic support for investments that improve resilience (defined as system recovery from additional disruptions) is still scarce. In this effort, we represent paved roads as a transportation network by mapping intersections to nodes and road segments between the intersections to links. We built road networks for 40 of the urban areas defined by the U.S. Census Bureau. We developed and calibrated a model to evaluate traffic delays using link loads. The loads may be regarded as traffic-based centrality measures, estimating the number of individuals using corresponding road segments. Efficiency was estimated as the average annual delay per peak-period auto commuter, and modeled results were found to be close to observed data, with the notable exception of New York City. Resilience was estimated as the change in efficiency resulting from roadway disruptions and was found to vary between cities, with increased delays due to a 5% random loss of road linkages ranging from 9.5% in Los Angeles to 56.0% in San Francisco. The results demonstrate that many urban road systems that operate inefficiently under normal conditions are nevertheless resilient to disruption, whereas some more efficient cities are more fragile. The implication is that resilience, not just efficiency, should be considered explicitly in roadway project selection and justify investment opportunities related to disaster and other disruptions.

Supplementary Information is available from the Science Advances website

References in corpus (5)

• Understanding individual human mobility patterns
• Efficient routing on complex networks
• Operational resilience: concepts, design and analysis
• Spatially localized attacks on interdependent networks: the existence of a finite critical attack size
• Multiple Tipping Points and Optimal Repairing in Interacting Networks

Cited by in corpus (25)

• Infrastructure Resilience Curves: Performance Measures and Summary Metrics
• Network resilience
• Scale-free Resilience of Real Traffic Jams
• Measuring urban road network resilience to extreme events: an application for urban floods
• Resilience management during large-scale epidemic outbreaks
• Local impacts on road networks and access to critical locations during extreme floods
• A Network Percolation-based Contagion Model of Flood Propagation and Recession in Urban Road Networks
• Non-Markovian recovery makes complex networks more resilient against large-scale failures
• Beyond Robustness: A Taxonomy of Approaches towards Resilient Multi-Robot Systems
• Discontinuous transition to loop formation in optimal supply networks
• A framework for modeling interdependencies among households, businesses, and infrastructure systems; and their response to disruptions
• On the resilience of cellular networks: how can national roaming help?
• Do we practice what we preach? The dissonance between resilience understanding and measurement
• Highway Traffic Control via Smart e-Mobility -- Part I: Theory
• Exploring the relationship between the spatial distribution of roads and universal pattern of travel-route efficiency in urban road networks
• Response functions as a new concept to study local dynamics in traffic networks
• A link model approach to identify congestion hotspots
• Vulnerable Connectivity Caused by Local Communities in Spatial Networks
• Clustering Time-Evolving Networks Using the Spatio-Temporal Graph Laplacian
• Assessing the Robustness and Resilience of U.S. Strategic Highways: A Network Science Perspective
• Generalized network recovery based on topology and optimization for real-world systems
• From Symbols to Embeddings: A Tale of Two Representations in Computational Social Science
• Quantifying Urban Road Network Vulnerability and Resilience to Attacks
• Identifying early-warning indicators of tipping points in networked systems against sequential attacks
• Identification and prioritization of urban traffic bottlenecks