Derivation and precision of mean field electrodynamics with mesoscale fluctuations
arXiv:1710.04064 · doi:10.1017/S0022377818000375
Abstract
Mean field electrodynamics (MFE) facilitates practical modeling of secular, large scale properties of astrophysical or laboratory systems with fluctuations.Practitioners commonly assume wide scale separation between mean and fluctuating quantities, to justify equality of ensemble and spatial or temporal averages.Often however, real systems do not exhibit such scale separation. This raises two questions: (I) what are the appropriate generalized equations of MFE in the presence of mesoscale fluctuations? (II) how precise are theoretical predictions from MFE? We address both by first deriving the equations of MFE for different types of averaging, along with mesoscale correction terms that depend on the ratio of averaging scale to variation scale of the mean. We then show that even if these terms are small, predictions of MFE can still have a significant precision error. This error has an intrinsic contribution from the dynamo input parameters and a filtering contribution from differences in the way observations and theory are projected through the measurement kernel.Minimizing the sum of these contributions can produce an optimal scale of averaging that makes the theory maximally precise.The precision error is important to quantify when comparing to observations because it quantifies the resolution of predictive power. We exemplify these principles for galactic dynamos, comment on broader implications, and identify possibilities for further work.
arXiv comment35 pages, 10 figures. Published in Journal of Plasma Physics; Mar. 21 2019: Typos of a sign in (3.6) and indices of in the paragraphs containing (B7)-(B9) corrected
References in corpus (30)
- Astrophysical magnetic fields and nonlinear dynamo theory
- Magnetic Fields in Spiral Galaxies
- A New Dynamical Mean-Field Dynamo Theory and Closure Approach
- Localness of energy cascade in hydrodynamic turbulence, I. Smooth coarse-graining
- Scale-Locality of Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
- Galactic dynamos supported by magnetic helicity fluxes
- Scale dependence of alpha effect and turbulent diffusivity
- Magnetic helicity density and its flux in weakly inhomogeneous turbulence
- Minimal tau approximation and simulations of the alpha effect
- The supernova-regulated ISM. II. The mean magnetic field
- Solar Grand Minima and random fluctuations in dynamo parameters
- Scaling and correlation analysis of galactic images
- Memory effects in turbulent transport
- Galactic spiral patterns and dynamo action I: A new twist on magnetic arms
- Mean--field electrodynamics: Critical analysis of various analytical approaches to the mean electromotive force
- Magnetic Fields in a Sample of Nearby Spiral Galaxies
- Modeling spatio-temporal nonlocality in mean-field dynamos
- Magnetic Helicity and Large Scale Magnetic Fields: A Primer
- Non-linear galactic dynamos: A toolbox
- Mean-field dynamos in random Arnold-Beltrami-Childress and Roberts flows
- Magnetic helicity flux in the presence of shear
- Mean-field dynamo in a turbulence with shear and kinetic helicity fluctuations
- Large scale dynamo action precedes turbulence in shearing box simulations of the magnetorotational instability
- An analytical dynamo solution for large-scale magnetic fields of galaxies
- The critical role of magnetic helicity in astrophysical large-scale dynamos
- Motivation and challenge to capture both large scale and local transport in next generation accretion theory
- Mean magnetic field generation in sheared rotators
- Statistical tests of galactic dynamo theory
- Some consequences of shear on galactic dynamos with helicity fluxes
- Quantifying the Imprecision of Accretion Theory and Implications for Multi-Epoch Observations of Protoplanetary Discs
Cited by in corpus (10)
- Galactic Dynamos
- Turbulent processes and mean-field dynamo
- Non-linear Galactic Dynamos and the Magnetic Rädler Effect
- On the shear-current effect: toward understanding why theories and simulations have mutually and separately conflicted
- Why the observed spin evolution of older-than-solar like stars might not require a dynamo mode change
- Generalized quenching of large-scale magnetic dynamos in anisotropic flows
- Galactic magnetic fields II. Applying the model to nearby galaxies
- Influence of inhomogeneous stochasticity on the falsifiability of mean-field theories and examples from accretion disc modeling
- Calculating turbulent transport tensors by averaging single plume dynamics and application to dynamos
- Synthesizing Observations and Theory to Understand Galactic Magnetic Fields: Progress and Challenges