Galaxy Cluster Mass Reconstruction Project: III. The impact of dynamical substructure on cluster mass estimates

Abstract

With the advent of wide-field cosmological surveys, we are approaching samples of hundreds of thousands of galaxy clusters. While such large numbers will help reduce statistical uncertainties, the control of systematics in cluster masses becomes ever more crucial. Here we examine the effects of an important source of systematic uncertainty in galaxy-based cluster mass estimation techniques: the presence of significant dynamical substructure. Dynamical substructure manifests as dynamically distinct subgroups in phase-space, indicating an 'unrelaxed' state. This issue affects around a quarter of clusters in a generally selected sample. We employ a set of mock clusters whose masses have been measured homogeneously with commonly-used galaxy-based mass estimation techniques (kinematic, richness, caustic, radial methods). We use these to study how the relation between observationally estimated and true cluster mass depends on the presence of substructure, as identified by various popular diagnostics. We find that the scatter for an ensemble of clusters does not increase dramatically for clusters with dynamical substructure. However, we find a systematic bias for all methods, such that clusters with significant substructure have higher measured masses than their relaxed counterparts. This bias depends on cluster mass: the most massive clusters are largely unaffected by the presence of significant substructure, but masses are significantly overestimated for lower mass clusters, by $\sim 10\%$ at $10^{14}$ and $\ge 20\%$ for $\le 10^{13.5}$. The use of cluster samples with different levels of substructure can, therefore, bias certain cosmological parameters up to a level comparable to the typical uncertainties in current cosmological studies.

arXiv comment14 pages, 8 figures, 3 tables. Submitted to MNRAS

References in corpus (59)

• emcee: The MCMC Hammer
• Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
• Toward a halo mass function for precision cosmology: the limits of universality
• The Rockstar Phase-Space Temporal Halo Finder and the Velocity Offsets of Cluster Cores
• Cosmological Parameters from Observations of Galaxy Clusters
• Wide-Field InfrarRed Survey Telescope-Astrophysics Focused Telescope Assets WFIRST-AFTA 2015 Report
• Differential Galaxy Evolution in Cluster and Field Galaxies at z=0.3
• Halos and galaxies in the standard cosmological model: results from the Bolshoi simulation
• Cosmology and fundamental physics with the Euclid satellite
• Tracing cosmic evolution with clusters of galaxies
• The Morphology-Density Relation in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Planck 2015 results. XXIV. Cosmology from Sunyaev-Zeldovich cluster counts
• Mass and Environment as Drivers of Galaxy Evolution II: The quenching of satellite galaxies as the origin of environmental effects
• Haloes gone MAD: The Halo-Finder Comparison Project
• The Morphology - Density Relation in z ~ 1 Clusters
• Structure and Dynamics of the Coma Cluster
• How special are Brightest Group and Cluster Galaxies?
• Weighing the Giants IV: Cosmology and Neutrino Mass
• The first and second data releases of the Kilo-Degree Survey
• Semi-Analytic Galaxy Evolution (SAGE): Model Calibration and Basic Results
• Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Clusters in the 2500 square-degree SPT-SZ Survey
• Cosmological Constraints from Sunyaev-Zel'dovich-Selected Clusters with X-ray Observations in the First 178 Square Degrees of the South Pole Telescope Survey
• Flux- and volume-limited groups/clusters for the SDSS galaxies: catalogues and mass estimation
• On the efficiency and reliability of cluster mass estimates based on member galaxies
• MAMPOSSt: Modelling Anisotropy and Mass Profiles of Observed Spherical Systems. I. Gaussian 3D velocities
• The X-ray cluster survey with eROSITA: forecasts for cosmology, cluster physics and primordial non-Gaussianity
• Optical and X-ray clusters as tracers of the supercluster-void network. I Superclusters of Abell and X-ray clusters
• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Cosmology from Galaxy Clusters Detected via the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect
• Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Clustering and the Mass-to-Number Ratio of Galaxy Clusters
• Toward Unbiased Galaxy Cluster Masses from Line of Sight Velocity Dispersions
• Substructure in Clusters and Central Galaxy Peculiar Velocities
• Cluster Galaxy Dynamics and the Effects of Large Scale Environment
• A Comparison between Semi-Analytic Model Predictions for the CANDELS Survey
• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Dynamical Masses and Scaling Relations for a Sample of Massive Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Selected Galaxy Clusters
• Statistical Tools for Classifying Galaxy Group Dynamics
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: The cluster redshift survey, target selection and cluster properties
• Galaxy Cluster Mass Reconstruction Project: II. Quantifying scatter and bias using contrasting mock catalogues
• Galaxy Cluster Mass Reconstruction Project: I. Methods and first results on galaxy-based techniques
• Substructures in WINGS clusters
• Searching for cluster substructure using APM and ROSAT data
• Multimodality in galaxy clusters from SDSS DR8: substructure and velocity distribution
• Hierarchical Evolution in Poor Groups of Galaxies
• Substructure in the cold front cluster Abell 3667
• Substructure in the Most Massive GEEC Groups: Field-like Populations in Dynamically Active Groups
• Substructure Analysis of Selected Low Richness 2dFGRS Clusters of Galaxies
• The Theoretical Astrophysical Observatory: Cloud-Based Mock Galaxy Catalogues
• NoSOCS in SDSS. I. Sample Definition and Comparison of Mass Estimates
• Evidence of pre-processing and a dependence on dynamical state for low-mass satellite galaxies
• The mass and anisotropy profiles of galaxy clusters from the projected phase space density: testing the method on simulated data
• Structures in Galaxy Clusters
• Velocity Anisotropy and Shape Bias in the Caustic Technique
• A Study of Catalogued Nearby Galaxy Clusters in the SDSS-DR4. II. Cluster Substructure
• The Mass Function of Nearby Galaxy Clusters
• X-ray Galaxy Clusters in NoSOCS: Substructure and the Correlation of Optical and X-ray Properties
• Investigating the Relation between Galaxy Properties and the Gaussianity of the Velocity Distribution of Groups and Clusters
• Galaxy subgroups in galaxy clusters
• In the whirlpool's coils: tracing substructure from combined optical/X-ray data in the galaxy cluster A1300
• An Examination of the Optical Substructure of Galaxy Clusters Hosting Radio Sources
• Comparison of hydrostatic and dynamical masses of distant X-ray luminous galaxy clusters

Cited by in corpus (28)

• Quenched fractions in the IllustrisTNG simulations: comparison with observations and other theoretical models
• A Robust and Efficient Deep Learning Method for Dynamical Mass Measurements of Galaxy Clusters
• CCCP and MENeaCS: (updated) weak-lensing masses for 100 galaxy clusters
• Cosmological Constraint on ${\Omega }_m$ and ${\sigma }_8$ from Cluster Abundances using the $GalWCat19$ Optical-Spectroscopic SDSS Catalog
• Combining FOF and halo-based algorithms for the identification of galaxy groups
• Dynamical mass inference of galaxy clusters with neural flows
• Galaxy Cluster Mass Reconstruction Project - IV. Understanding the effects of imperfect membership on cluster mass estimation
• Bayesian group finder based on marked point processes. Method and feasibility study using the 2MRS data set
• Simulation-based inference of dynamical galaxy cluster masses with 3D convolutional neural networks
• The Dynamical Mass of the Coma Cluster from Deep Learning
• Supercluster A2142 and collapse in action - infalling and merging groups and galaxy transformations
• Approximate Bayesian Uncertainties on Deep Learning Dynamical Mass Estimates of Galaxy Clusters
• Infalling groups and galaxy transformations in the cluster A2142
• The Fornax Cluster VLT Spectroscopic Survey III -- Kinematical characterisation of globular clusters across the Fornax galaxy cluster
• GalWeight Application: A publicly-available catalog of dynamical parameters of 1,800 galaxy clusters from SDSS-DR13, ($GalWCat19$)
• A Detailed Study of the Most Relaxed SPT-Selected Galaxy Clusters: Cool Core and Central Galaxy Properties
• What to expect from dynamical modelling of cluster haloes I. The information content of different dynamical tracers
• An empirical measurement of the Halo Mass Function from the combination of GAMA DR4, SDSS DR12, and REFLEX II data
• The Cluster-EAGLE project: a comparison of dynamical mass estimators using simulated clusters
• Benchmarks and Explanations for Deep Learning Estimates of X-ray Galaxy Cluster Masses
• Detecting clusters and groups of galaxies populating the local Universe in large optical spectroscopic surveys
• Dynamical analysis of clusters of galaxies from cosmological simulations
• Classification and Evolution of Galaxies According to the Dynamical State of Host Clusters and Galaxy Luminosities
• X-ray cluster cosmology
• "Observing" Unrelaxed Clusters in Dark Matter Simulations
• BASILISK II. Improved Constraints on the Galaxy-Halo Connection from Satellite Kinematics in SDSS
• Estimating the Masses of Supercluster-Scale Filaments from Redshift Dispersions
• Spectroscopic galaxy redshifts in the Peanut cluster -- a massive nearly head-on cluster merger shortly after pericenter passage