Recovering galaxy cluster gas density profiles with XMM-Newton and Chandra

Abstract

We examine the reconstruction of galaxy cluster radial density profiles obtained from Chandra and XMM X-ray observations, using high quality data for a sample of twelve objects covering a range of morphologies and redshifts. By comparing the results obtained from the two observatories and by varying key aspects of the analysis procedure, we examine the impact of instrumental effects and of differences in the methodology used in the recovery of the density profiles. We find that the final density profile shape is particularly robust. We adapt the photon weighting vignetting correction method developed for XMM for use with Chandra data, and confirm that the resulting Chandra profiles are consistent with those corrected a posteriori for vignetting effects. Profiles obtained from direct deprojection and those derived using parametric models are consistent at the 1% level. At radii larger than $\sim$6", the agreement between Chandra and XMM is better than 1%, confirming an excellent understanding of the XMM PSF. We find no significant energy dependence. The impact of the well-known offset between Chandra and XMM gas temperature determinations on the density profiles is found to be negligible. However, we find an overall normalisation offset in density profiles of the order of $\sim$2.5%, which is linked to absolute flux cross-calibration issues. As a final result, the weighted ratios of Chandra to XMM gas masses computed at R2500 and R500 are r=1.03$\pm$0.01 and r=1.03$\pm$0.03, respectively. Our study confirms that the radial density profiles are robustly recovered, and that any differences between Chandra and XMM can be constrained to the $\sim$ 2.5% level, regardless of the exact data analysis details. These encouraging results open the way for the true combination of X-ray observations of galaxy clusters, fully leveraging the high resolution of Chandra and the high throughput of XMM.

Accepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics

References in corpus (10)

• A Catalog of Galaxy Clusters Observed by XMM-Newton
• Cosmology and Astrophysics from Relaxed Galaxy Clusters II: Cosmological Constraints
• Temperature profiles of a representative sample of nearby X-ray galaxy clusters
• XMM-Newton and Chandra Cross Calibration Using HIFLUGCS Galaxy Clusters: Systematic Temperature Differences and Cosmological Impact
• Measuring the non-thermal pressure in early type galaxy atmospheres: A comparison of X-ray and optical potential profiles in M87 and NGC1399
• CLASH-X: A Comparison of Lensing and X-ray Techniques for Measuring the Mass Profiles of Galaxy Clusters
• LoCuSS: Hydrostatic Mass Measurements of the High-$L_X$ Cluster Sample -- Cross-calibration of Chandra and XMM-Newton
• Chandra ACIS-I particle background: an analytical model
• An improved deprojection and PSF-deconvolution technique for galaxy-cluster X-ray surface-brightness profiles
• Resolving galaxy cluster gas properties at z~1 with XMM-Newton and Chandra

Cited by in corpus (13)

• The galaxy cluster mass scale and its impact on cosmological constraints from the cluster population
• Evolution of the Thermodynamic Properties of Clusters of Galaxies out to Redshift of 1.8
• Chandra Observations of the Planck ESZ Sample: A Re-Examination of Masses and Mass Proxies
• A MeerKAT-meets-LOFAR study of Abell 1413: a moderately disturbed non-cool-core cluster hosting a $\sim 500$ kpc 'mini'-halo
• The merging galaxy cluster Abell 3266 at low radio frequencies
• CHEX-MATE: A non-parametric deep learning technique to deproject and deconvolve galaxy cluster X-ray temperature profiles
• The hydrostatic-to-lensing mass bias from resolved X-ray and optical-IR data
• The XXL Survey: XLVIII; X-ray follow-up of distant XXL clusters: Masses, scaling relations and AGN contamination
• Comparison of hydrostatic and lensing cluster mass estimates:a pilot study in MACS J0647.7+7015
• SpectrAx: Spectral Search of Axion-Like Particles Using Multi-Band Observations of Galaxy Clusters from SKA, SO, CMB-S4 and eROSITA
• Turbulence Induced Non-Gaussian Spectral Distortion in the Microwave Sky from Photon-Axion Conversion in Galaxy Clusters
• Spherical bias on the 3D reconstruction of the ICM density profile in galaxy clusters
• Low-frequency integrated radio spectra of diffuse, steep-spectrum sources in galaxy clusters: palaeontology with the MWA and ASKAP