Diverging, but negligible power at Carnot efficiency: theory and experiment

Abstract

We discuss the possibility of reaching the Carnot efficiency by heat engines (HEs) out of quasi-static conditions at nonzero power output. We focus on several models widely used to describe the performance of actual HEs. These models comprise quantum thermoelectric devices, linear irreversible HEs, minimally nonlinear irreversible HEs, HEs working in the regime of low dissipation, over-damped stochastic HEs and an under-damped stochastic HE. Although some of these HEs can reach the Carnot efficiency at nonzero and even diverging power, the magnitude of this power is always negligible compared to the maximum power attainable in these systems. We provide conditions for attaining the Carnot efficiency in the individual models and explain practical aspects connected with reaching the Carnot efficiency at large power output. Furthermore, we show how our findings can be tested in practice using a standard Brownian HE realizable with available micromanipulation techniques.

10 pages, 6 figures

References in corpus (15)

• Efficiency at maximum power: An analytically solvable model for stochastic heat engines
• The unlikely Carnot efficiency
• Generic Properties of Stochastic Entropy Production
• Finding the quantum thermoelectric with maximal efficiency and minimal entropy production at given power output
• Efficiency statistics at all times: Carnot limit at finite power
• Adiabatic processes realized with a trapped Brownian particle
• Erasure without work in an asymmetric, double-well potential
• Exactly solvable model of stochastic heat engine: Optimization of power, its fluctuations and efficiency
• Two simple models of classical heat pumps
• Bound on Thermoelectric Power in a Magnetic Field within Linear Response
• Work and power fluctuations in a critical heat engine
• Efficiency versus Speed in Quantum Heat Engines: Rigorous Constraint from Lieb-Robinson Bound
• Heat engines at optimal power: Low-dissipation versus endoreversible model
• Engines with ideal efficiency and nonzero power for sublinear transport laws
• Stationary engines in and beyond the linear response regime at the Carnot efficiency

Cited by in corpus (32)

• Current fluctuations and transport efficiency for general Langevin systems
• Cycling tames power fluctuations near optimum efficiency
• Multidimensional thermodynamic uncertainty relations
• Thermodynamic Geometry of Microscopic Heat Engines
• Active Brownian Heat Engines
• Universal constraint for efficiency and power of a low-dissipation heat engine
• Driving rapidly while remaining in control: classical shortcuts from Hamiltonian to stochastic dynamics
• Phase transition in protocols minimizing work fluctuations
• Many-body quantum thermal machines
• Experimental validation of the $1/\tau$ -scaling entropy generation in finite-time thermodynamics with dry air
• Optimal operating protocol to achieve efficiency at maximum power of heat engines
• Underdamped Active Brownian Heat Engine
• Achieve Higher Efficiency at Maximum Power with Finite-time Quantum Otto Cycle
• Optimizing Thermodynamic Cycles with Two Finite-Sized Reservoirs
• Effect of finite-size heat source's heat capacity on the efficiency of heat engine
• A Brownian cyclic engine operating in a viscoelastic active suspension
• Optimal energy conversion through anti-adiabatic driving breaking time-reversal symmetry
• Quantum jump approach to microscopic heat engines
• Exactly solvable model of a passive Brownian heat engine and its comparison with active engines
• Optimal finite-time heat engines under constrained control
• Maximum efficiency of low-dissipation refrigerators at arbitrary cooling power
• Achieving Carnot efficiency in a finite-power Brownian Carnot cycle with arbitrary temperature difference
• Carnot efficiency and zero-entropy-production rate do not guarantee reversibility of a process
• Compatibility of Carnot efficiency with finite power in an underdamped Brownian Carnot cycle in small temperature-difference regime
• Maximum efficiency of absorption refrigerators at arbitrary cooling power
• Maximum Power of Coupled-Qubit Otto Engines
• Maximum efficiency of low-dissipation heat pumps at given heating load
• Efficiency at the maximum power of the power law dissipative Carnot-like Heat engines with non-adiabatic dissipation
• Efficiency and power of minimally nonlinear irreversible heat engines with broken time-reversal symmetry
• Power-Efficiency Constraint for Chemical Motors
• Optimizing low-dissipation Carnot-like thermal devices with heat leak
• Geometric Bounds on the Power of Adiabatic Thermal Machines