On the ambiguity in the notion of transverse traceless modes of gravitational waves

Abstract

Somewhat surprisingly, in many of the widely used monographs and review articles the term Transverse-Traceless modes of linearized gravitational waves is used to denote two entirely different notions. These treatments generally begin with a decomposition of the metric perturbation that is local in the momentum space (and hence non-local in physical space), and denote the resulting transverse traceless modes by $h_{ab}^{\TT}$. However, while discussing gravitational waves emitted by an isolated system --typically in a later section-- the relevant modes are extracted using a `projection operator' that is local in physical space. These modes are also called transverse-traceless and again labeled $h_{ab}^{\TT}$, implying that this is just a reformulation of the previous notion. But the two notions are conceptually distinct and the difference persists even in the asymptotic region. We show that this confusion arises already in Maxwell theory that is often discussed as a prelude to the gravitational case. Finally, we discuss why the distinction has nonetheless remained largely unnoticed, and also point out that there are some important physical effects where only one of the notions gives the correct answer.

36 pages. The detailed of the Letter arXiv:1707.07729; some references and minor clarifications added

References in corpus (2)

• Asymptotic symmetries and subleading soft graviton theorem
• On the use of projection operators in electrodynamics

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Bridging Carrollian and Celestial Holography
• Angular momentum of zero-frequency gravitons
• Gravity entanglement, quantum reference systems, degrees of freedom
• Numerical-relativity simulations of the quasi-circular inspiral and merger of non-spinning, charged black holes: methods and comparison with approximate approaches
• Light-ray operators, detectors and gravitational event shapes
• On a basic conceptual confusion in gravitational radiation theory
• Power radiated by a binary system in a de Sitter Universe
• Gravitational wave memory and the wave equation
• Angular momentum at null infinity in Einstein-Maxwell theory
• Lagrangian theory of structure formation in relativistic cosmology. IV. Lagrangian approach to gravitational waves
• A gravitationally induced decoherence model using Ashtekar variables
• Gravitational wave cosmology I: high frequency approximation
• Radiative Asymptotic Symmetries of 3D Einstein-Maxwell Theory
• Fluxes and angular momentum
• The classical dynamics of gauge theories in the deep infrared
• An introduction to gravitational waves through electrodynamics: a quadrupole comparison
• Non canonical polarizations of Gravitational Waves
• Chiral anomalies induced by gravitational waves
• Gravitational wave polarization modes and the kinematical tensors in general relativity and beyond