Hipsters on Networks: How a Small Group of Individuals Can Lead to an Anti-Establishment Majority

Abstract

The spread of opinions, memes, diseases, and "alternative facts" in a population depends both on the details of the spreading process and on the structure of the social and communication networks on which they spread. In this paper, we explore how \textit{anti-establishment} nodes (e.g., \textit{hipsters}) influence the spreading dynamics of two competing products. We consider a model in which spreading follows a deterministic rule for updating node states (which describe which product has been adopted) in which an adjustable fraction $p_{\mathrm{Hip}}$ of the nodes in a network are hipsters, who choose to adopt the product that they believe is the less popular of the two. The remaining nodes are conformists, who choose which product to adopt by considering which products their immediate neighbors have adopted. We simulate our model on both synthetic and real networks, and we show that the hipsters have a major effect on the final fraction of people who adopt each product: even when only one of the two products exists at the beginning of the simulations, a very small fraction of hipsters in a network can still cause the other product to eventually become the more popular one. To account for this behavior, we construct an approximation for the steady-state adoption fraction on $k$-regular trees in the limit of few hipsters. Additionally, our simulations demonstrate that a time delay $\tau$ in the knowledge of the product distribution in a population, as compared to immediate knowledge of product adoption among nearest neighbors, can have a large effect on the final distribution of product adoptions. Our simple model and analysis may help shed light on the road to success for anti-establishment choices in elections, as such success can arise rather generically in our model from a small number of anti-establishment individuals and ordinary processes of social influence on normal individuals.

arXiv commentExtensively revised, with much new analysis and numerics The abstract on arXiv is a shortened version of the full abstract because of space limits

References in corpus (30)

• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• Epidemic processes in complex networks
• Social Structure of Facebook Networks
• Universal behavior in a generalized model of contagion
• Disinformation and Social Bot Operations in the Run Up to the 2017 French Presidential Election
• A generalized model of social and biological contagion
• Cascade Dynamics of Multiplex Propagation
• Evidence of Complex Contagion of Information in Social Media: An Experiment Using Twitter Bots
• Contrarian Deterministic Effect: the "Hung Elections Scenario"
• The role of inflexible minorities in the breaking of democratic opinion dynamics
• Binary-state dynamics on complex networks: pair approximation and beyond
• Analytical computation of the epidemic threshold on temporal networks
• Topological data analysis of contagion maps for examining spreading processes on networks
• Phase transitions in the q-voter model with two types of stochastic driving
• The unreasonable effectiveness of tree-based theory for networks with clustering
• A Simple Generative Model of Collective Online Behaviour
• Dynamical Systems on Networks: A Tutorial
• Multi-Stage Complex Contagions
• The limitations of discrete-time approaches to continuous-time contagion dynamics
• The effects of network structure, competition and memory time on social spreading phenomena
• Pair approximation for the q-voter model with independence on complex networks
• How effective is advertising in duopoly markets?
• Synergy in spreading processes: from exploitative to explorative foraging strategies
• The noisy voter model under the influence of contrarians
• The influence of contrarians in the dynamics of opinion formation
• Influence of Luddism on innovation diffusion
• Adoption of Innovations with Contrarians and Repentant Agents
• Complex Contagions with Timers
• Dynamical influence processes on networks: General theory and applications to social contagion
• Locally self-organized quasi-critical percolation in a multiple disease model

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Social physics
• Tipping points in opinion dynamics: a universal formula in five dimensions
• Critical mass effect in evolutionary games triggered by zealots
• Polarization in the three-state $q$-voter model with anticonformity and bounded confidence
• Fitting In and Breaking Up: A Nonlinear Version of Coevolving Voter Models
• Will Trump win again in the 2020 election? An answer from a sociophysics model
• Descendant distributions for the impact of mutant contagion on networks
• The threshold model with anticonformity under random sequential updating
• Impact of individual actions on the collective response of social systems
• The dual problems of coordination and anti-coordination on random bipartite graphs
• Modeling diffusion in networks with communities: a multitype branching process approach
• How a minority can win: Undemocratic outcomes in a simple model of voter turnout