Evidence of Complex Contagion of Information in Social Media: An Experiment Using Twitter Bots
arXiv:1703.06027 · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0184148
Abstract
It has recently become possible to study the dynamics of information diffusion in techno-social systems at scale, due to the emergence of online platforms, such as Twitter, with millions of users. One question that systematically recurs is whether information spreads according to simple or complex dynamics: does each exposure to a piece of information have an independent probability of a user adopting it (simple contagion), or does this probability depend instead on the number of sources of exposure, increasing above some threshold (complex contagion)? Most studies to date are observational and, therefore, unable to disentangle the effects of confounding factors such as social reinforcement, homophily, limited attention, or network community structure. Here we describe a novel controlled experiment that we performed on Twitter using `social bots' deployed to carry out coordinated attempts at spreading information. We propose two Bayesian statistical models describing simple and complex contagion dynamics, and test the competing hypotheses. We provide experimental evidence that the complex contagion model describes the observed information diffusion behavior more accurately than simple contagion. Future applications of our results include more effective defenses against malicious propaganda campaigns on social media, improved marketing and advertisement strategies, and design of effective network intervention techniques.
10 pages + 4 pages of supplementary information. 4+1 figures
References in corpus (2)
Cited by in corpus (61)
- Simplicial models of social contagion
- Deep Neural Networks for Bot Detection
- Disinformation and Social Bot Operations in the Run Up to the 2017 French Presidential Election
- Arming the public with artificial intelligence to counter social bots
- Analyzing the Digital Traces of Political Manipulation: The 2016 Russian Interference Twitter Campaign
- Cascading Failures in Complex Networks
- Simplicial contagion in temporal higher-order networks
- Exposure to Social Engagement Metrics Increases Vulnerability to Misinformation
- Group interactions modulate critical mass dynamics in social convention
- Competing contagion processes: Complex contagion triggered by simple contagion
- Interacting contagions are indistinguishable from social reinforcement
- Opinion Dynamics of Online Social Network Users: A Micro-Level Analysis
- The growing amplification of social media: Measuring temporal and social contagion dynamics for over 150 languages on Twitter for 2009-2020
- Information flow reveals prediction limits in online social activity
- Measuring social spam and the effect of bots on information diffusion in social media
- A network-based microfoundation of Granovetter's threshold model for social tipping
- Distinguishing simple and complex contagion processes on networks
- Master equation analysis of mesoscopic localization in contagion dynamics on higher-order networks
- Hipsters on Networks: How a Small Group of Individuals Can Lead to an Anti-Establishment Majority
- Network Modularity Controls the Speed of Information Diffusion
- Social contagion on higher-order structures
- A multi-type branching process method for modelling complex contagion on clustered networks
- Social Complex Contagion in Music Listenership: A Natural Experiment with 1.3 Million Participants
- Quantifying the Vulnerabilities of the Online Public Square to Adversarial Manipulation Tactics
- Insights into bootstrap percolation: Its equivalence with k-core percolation and the giant component
- Nonlinear bias toward complex contagion in uncertain transmission settings
- Modeling the amplification of epidemic spread by individuals exposed to misinformation on social media
- Double transition of information spreading in a two-layered network
- Better Safe Than Sorry: An Adversarial Approach to Improve Social Bot Detection
- Aging in binary-state models: The Threshold model for Complex Contagion
- Anticipation-induced social tipping -- Can the environment be stabilised by social dynamics?
- Complex Contagions with Timers
- How Social Rewiring Preferences Bridge Polarized Communities
- Competition and dual users in complex contagion processes
- Influence Maximization for Fixed Heterogeneous Thresholds
- Perils and Challenges of Social Media and Election Manipulation Analysis: The 2018 US Midterms
- Geolocated Social Media Posts are Happier: Understanding the Characteristics of Check-in Posts on Twitter
- Threshold cascade dynamics on coevolving networks
- Multilayer modeling of adoption dynamics in energy demand management
- Descendant distributions for the impact of mutant contagion on networks
- Detecting Social Media Manipulation in Low-Resource Languages
- Reciprocity, Homophily, and Social Network Effects in Pictorial Communication: A Case Study of Bitmoji Stickers
- Complex social contagion induces bistability on multiplex networks
- Social network structure and the spread of complex contagions from a population genetics perspective
- Higher-order null models as a lens for social systems
- The Atlas for the Aspiring Network Scientist
- On the dual nature of adoption processes in complex networks
- Infectivity Enhances Prediction of Viral Cascades in Twitter
- Coevolutionary Dynamics of Group Interactions: Coevolving Nonlinear Voter Models
- Collective behaviour of social bots is encoded in their temporal Twitter activity
- Red Bots Do It Better: Comparative Analysis of Social Bot Partisan Behavior
- Public interest in science or bots? Selective amplification of scientific articles on Twitter
- Characterizing the 2016 Russian IRA Influence Campaign
- Social Diffusion Sources Can Escape Detection
- Information Access Equality on Network Generative Models
- Long ties accelerate noisy threshold-based contagions
- Conductance and Influence-Capital: Modeling Online Social Influence
- From Market Saturation to Social Reinforcement: Understanding the Impact of Non-Linearity in Information Diffusion Models
- An evidence-accumulating drift-diffusion model of competing information spread on networks
- Modeling Multistability and Hysteresis in Urban Congestion Spreading
- Competing spreading dynamics in simplicial complex