Homophily and Contagion Are Generically Confounded in Observational Social Network Studies
arXiv:1004.4704 · doi:10.1177/0049124111404820
Abstract
We consider processes on social networks that can potentially involve three factors: homophily, or the formation of social ties due to matching individual traits; social contagion, also known as social influence; and the causal effect of an individual's covariates on their behavior or other measurable responses. We show that, generically, all of these are confounded with each other. Distinguishing them from one another requires strong assumptions on the parametrization of the social process or on the adequacy of the covariates used (or both). In particular we demonstrate, with simple examples, that asymmetries in regression coefficients cannot identify causal effects, and that very simple models of imitation (a form of social contagion) can produce substantial correlations between an individual's enduring traits and their choices, even when there is no intrinsic affinity between them. We also suggest some possible constructive responses to these results.
27 pages, 9 figures. V2: Revised in response to referees. V3: Ditto
References in corpus (5)
Cited by in corpus (93)
- Epidemic processes in complex networks
- Measuring Emotional Contagion in Social Media
- Virality Prediction and Community Structure in Social Networks
- Measuring large-scale social networks with high resolution
- Attributed Network Embedding for Learning in a Dynamic Environment
- Evidence of Complex Contagion of Information in Social Media: An Experiment Using Twitter Bots
- Happiness is assortative in online social networks
- Social Influence in Social Advertising: Evidence from Field Experiments
- The Role of Social Networks in Information Diffusion
- The "Unfriending" Problem: The Consequences of Homophily in Friendship Retention for Causal Estimates of Social Influence
- A Simple Generative Model of Collective Online Behaviour
- Gender Disparities in Science? Dropout, Productivity, Collaborations and Success of Male and Female Computer Scientists
- Dynamical Systems on Networks: A Tutorial
- Multi-Stage Complex Contagions
- Inf-VAE: A Variational Autoencoder Framework to Integrate Homophily and Influence in Diffusion Prediction
- The Spread of Evidence-Poor Medicine via Flawed Social-Network Analysis
- Suicide ideation of individuals in online social networks
- Complex Contagion of Campaign Donations
- Automatic Detection of Influential Actors in Disinformation Networks
- Local cascades induced global contagion: How heterogeneous thresholds, exogenous effects, and unconcerned behaviour govern online adoption spreading
- Information flow reveals prediction limits in online social activity
- Modelling influence and opinion evolution in online collective behaviour
- Estimators of Binary Spatial Autoregressive Models: A Monte Carlo Study
- Trust in the CODA model: Opinion Dynamics and the reliability of other agents
- Semantic homophily in online communication: evidence from Twitter
- Beyond Contagion: Reality Mining Reveals Complex Patterns of Social Influence
- Disentangling homophily, community structure and triadic closure in networks
- Social Contagion Theory: Examining Dynamic Social Networks and Human Behavior
- Tackling the subsampling problem to infer collective properties from limited data
- Analysis of a heterogeneous social network of humans and cultural objects
- Information Diffusion and External Influence in Networks
- How Gamification Affects Software Developers: Cautionary Evidence from a Natural Experiment on GitHub
- Estimating Causal Peer Influence in Homophilous Social Networks by Inferring Latent Locations
- A Survey on Causal Inference
- Bias and high-dimensional adjustment in observational studies of peer effects
- Reasoning about Independence in Probabilistic Models of Relational Data
- Using Embeddings to Correct for Unobserved Confounding in Networks
- Collaboration and topic switches in science
- Graph Condensation for Graph Neural Networks
- Is Gun Violence Contagious?
- A Comparative Study of Social Network Classifiers for Predicting Churn in the Telecommunication Industry
- Causal Inference Under Interference And Network Uncertainty
- Can Human-Like Bots Control Collective Mood: Agent-Based Simulations of Online Chats
- Topical alignment in online social systems
- A Sequence of Relaxations Constraining Hidden Variable Models
- Influence Estimation on Social Media Networks Using Causal Inference
- Modeling Dynamical Influence in Human Interaction Patterns
- Using Ego-Clusters to Measure Network Effects at LinkedIn
- Models, Methods and Network Topology: Experimental Design for the Study of Interference
- Beautiful and damned. Combined effect of content quality and social ties on user engagement
- Causal Inference in the Presence of Interference in Sponsored Search Advertising
- Identification of Causal Diffusion Effects Under Structural Stationarity
- Cheating in online gaming spreads through observation and victimization
- How Do We Find Early Adopters Who Will Guide a Resource Constrained Network Towards a Desired Distribution of Behaviors?
- Prediction models for network-linked data
- From words to connections: Word use similarity as an honest signal conducive to employees' digital communication
- Spillover Effects in Cluster Randomized Trials with Noncompliance
- Statistical Tests for Contagion in Observational Social Network Studies
- VAINE: Visualization and AI for Natural Experiments
- Aperiodic dynamics in a deterministic model of attitude formation in social groups
- Influencing Busy People in a Social Network
- Portrait of an Online Shopper: Understanding and Predicting Consumer Behavior
- How does homophily shape the topology of a dynamic network?
- Searching for consistent associations with a multi-environment knockoff filter
- Shadow networks: Discovering hidden nodes with models of information flow
- Effects of homophily and heterophily on preferred-degree networks: mean-field analysis and overwhelming transition
- Causal Relational Learning
- Randomized Graph Cluster Randomization
- Linear regression and its inference on noisy network-linked data
- Evidence of Herding and Stubbornness in Jury Deliberations
- Simulating systematic bias in attributed social networks and its effect on rankings of minority nodes
- Disentangling sources of influence in online social networks
- Social Discrete Choice Models
- Inference of a universal social scale and segregation measures using social connectivity kernels
- Partially Linear Additive Gaussian Graphical Models
- ALAAMEE: Open-source software for fitting autologistic actor attribute models
- Lifted Representation of Relational Causal Models Revisited: Implications for Reasoning and Structure Learning
- Social Fragmentation Transitions in Large-Scale Parameter Sweep Simulations of Adaptive Social Networks
- The Role of Peer Influence in Churn in Wireless Networks
- Using Proximity to Predict Activity in Social Networks
- Reinforcement Learning and Nonparametric Detection of Game-Theoretic Equilibrium Play in Social Networks
- Graph-Based Methods for Discrete Choice
- The Social Contagion Hypothesis: Comment on "Social Contagion Theory: Examining Dynamic Social Networks and Human Behavior"
- Social inequality and cultural factors impact the awareness and reaction during the cryptic transmission period of pandemic
- Regression-based Negative Control of Homophily in Dyadic Peer Effect Analysis
- Social Media Brand Engagement as a Proxy for E-commerce Activities: A Case Study of Sina Weibo and JD
- Detecting contagious spreading of urban innovations on the global city network
- Contrasting Multiple Social Network Autocorrelations for Binary Outcomes, With Applications To Technology Adoption
- High-dimensional Gaussian graphical model for network-linked data
- Heterogeneous Treatment Effects in Social Networks
- Graph Enhanced High Dimensional Kernel Regression
- Estimating Social Influence Using Latent Space Adjusted Approach in R
- Predicting Trends in Social Networks via Dynamic Activeness Model