Comparing Conditions for Macrorealism: Leggett-Garg Inequalities vs No-Signaling in Time
arXiv:1704.01485 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.96.012121
Abstract
We consider two different types of conditions which were proposed to test macrorealism in the context of a system described by a single dichotomic variable Q. This is the view that a macroscopic system evolving in time possesses definite properties which can be determined without disturbing the future or past state. The Leggett-Garg (LG) inequalities, the most commonly-studied test, are only necessary conditions for macrorealism, but building on earlier work it is shown that when the four three-time LG inequalities are augmented with a certain set of two-time inequalities also of the LG form, Fine's theorem applies and these augmented conditions are then both necessary and sufficient. A comparison is carried out with a very different set of necessary and sufficient conditions for macrorealism, namely the no-signaling in time (NSIT) conditions proposed by Brukner, Clemente, Kofler and others, which ensure that all probabilities for Q at one and two times are independent of whether earlier or intermediate measurements are made in a given run, and do not require (but imply) the LG inequalities. We argue that tests based on the LG inequalities have the form of very weak classicality conditions and can be satisfied in the face of moderate interference effects, but those based on NSIT conditions have the form of much stronger coherence witness conditions, satisfied only for zero interference. The two tests differ in their implementation of non-invasive measurability so are testing different notions of macrorealism: the augmented LG tests are indirect, entailing a combination of the results of different experiments with only compatible quantities measured in each experimental run, in close analogy with Bell tests, and are primarily tests for macrorealism per se; by contrast the NSIT tests entail sequential measurements of incompatible quantities and are primarily tests for non-invasiveness
arXiv comment28 pages. Revised in response to referee comments
References in corpus (43)
- Models of Wave-function Collapse, Underlying Theories, and Experimental Tests
- Classical Equations for Quantum Systems
- Leggett-Garg Inequalities
- Experimental violation of a Bell's inequality in time with weak measurement
- Nonperturbative theory of weak pre- and post-selected measurements
- Witnessing Quantum Coherence: from solid-state to biological systems
- Violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality with weak measurements of photons
- A simple model of quantum trajectories
- Violation of a Leggett-Garg inequality with ideal non-invasive measurements
- Consistent Histories and Quantum Reasoning
- Experimental Violation of Two-Party Leggett-Garg Inequalities with Semi-weak Measurements
- Condition for macroscopic realism beyond the Leggett-Garg inequalities
- Choice of Consistent Family, and Quantum Incompatibility
- Ideal negative measurements in quantum walks disprove theories based on classical trajectories
- Partial-measurement back-action and non-classical weak values in a superconducting circuit
- Opening up the Quantum Three-Box Problem with Undetectable Measurements
- Violation of a temporal Bell inequality for single spins in solid by over 50 standard deviations
- A strict experimental test of macroscopic realism in a superconducting flux qubit
- Quantum correlations in the temporal CHSH scenario
- No Fine theorem for macrorealism: Limitations of the Leggett-Garg inequality
- Compatibility and noncontextuality for sequential measurements
- Violation of Leggett-Garg inequalities in quantum measurements with variable resolution and back-action
- Addressing the clumsiness loophole in a Leggett-Garg test of macrorealism
- Necessary and sufficient conditions for macroscopic realism from quantum mechanics
- The Leggett-Garg Inequalities and No-Signalling in Time: A Quasi-Probability Approach
- Experimental detection of quantum coherent evolution through the violation of Leggett-Garg-type inequalities
- Experimental violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality under decoherence
- Consistent Quantum Counterfactuals
- Violation of Entropic Leggett-Garg Inequality in Nuclear Spins
- Maximum violations of the quantum-witness equality
- EPR, Bell, and Quantum Locality
- Wigner's form of the Leggett-Garg inequality, No-Signalling in Time, and Unsharp Measurements
- Leggett--Garg inequality violations with a large ensemble of qubits
- Experimental violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality in a 3-level system
- The New Quantum Logic
- Using weak values to experimentally determine "negative probabilities" in a two-photon state with Bell correlations
- Optimal experimental demonstration of error-tolerant quantum witnesses
- Dynamics of a qubit as a classical stochastic process with time-correlated noise: minimal measurement invasiveness
- Two Proofs of Fine's Theorem
- Negative Probabilities, Fine's Theorem and Linear Positivity
- A Stronger Theorem Against Macro-realism
- Leggett-Garg Correlation Functions from Non-Invasive Velocity Measurement Continuous in Time
- Deccoherent Histories and Measurement of Temporal Correlation Functions for Leggett-Garg Inequalities
Cited by in corpus (35)
- Macroscopic quantum states: measures, fragility and implementations
- Coherence and non-classicality of quantum Markov processes
- Sequential modular position and momentum measurements of a trapped ion mechanical oscillator
- Hierarchy in temporal quantum correlations
- Interference experiment, anomalous weak value and Leggett-Garg test of macrorealism
- Probing various formulations of macrorealism for unsharp quantum measurements
- Exploration of an augmented set of Leggett-Garg inequalities using a noninvasive continuous-in-time velocity measurement
- Detecting violations of macrorealism when the original Leggett-Garg inequalities are satisfied
- Leggett-Garg tests for macrorealism: interference experiments and the simple harmonic oscillator
- Loophole free interferometric test of macrorealism using heralded single photons
- Leggett-Garg tests of macrorealism: checks for non-invasiveness and generalizations to higher-order correlators
- A quasi-probability for the arrival time problem with links to backflow and the Leggett-Garg inequalities
- Subtleties of witnessing quantum coherence in non-isolated systems
- Quantum violation of variants of LGIs upto algebraic maximum for qubit system
- Fine's Theorem for Leggett-Garg tests with an arbitrary number of measurement times
- Conditions for Macrorealism for Systems Described by Many-Valued Variables
- Experimental Control of the Degree of Non-Classicality via Quantum Coherence
- Influence of equilibrium and nonequilibrium environments on macroscopic realism through the Leggett-Garg inequalities
- Leggett-Garg tests for macrorealism in the quantum harmonic oscillator and more general bound systems
- Leggett-Garg violations for continuous variable systems with gaussian states
- Mass-Independent Scheme to Test the Quantumness of a Massive Object
- Wigner Inequalities for Test of Hypothesis of Realism and Concepts of Macroscopic and Local Realism
- Violating the Leggett-Garg inequalities with classical light
- Violation of the two-time Leggett-Garg inequalities for a harmonic oscillator
- Tests of macrorealism in meson oscillation physics
- Lüders bounds of Leggett-Garg inequalities, - symmetric evolution and arrow-of-time
- Hierarchy and robustness of multilevel two-time temporal quantum correlations
- Leggett-Garg inequalities for multitime processes
- Probability vector representation of the Schrödinger equation and Leggett-Garg-type experiments
- Hidden nonmacrorealism: reviving the Leggett-Garg inequality with stochastic operations
- Quantum Non-Demolition Measurements and Leggett-Garg inequality
- Spatial Leggett-Garg inequalities
- Assessing the dynamical assumptions in Tsirelson inequality tests of non-classicality in harmonic oscillators
- Shared randomness allows violation of macroscopic realism using a single measurement
- Classical model of quantum interferometry tests of macrorealism