The isolation of Luminous Blue Variables: On subdividing the sample

Abstract

A debate has arisen concerning the fundamental nature of LBVs) and their role in stellar evolution. While Smith and Tombleson proposed that their isolated environments indicate that LBVs must be largely the product of binary evolution, Humphreys et al. have recently expressed the view that the traditional single-star view still holds if one appropriately selects a subsample of LBVs. This paper finds the claim of Humphreys et al. to be quantitatively unjustified. A statistical test of "candidate" as opposed to "confirmed" LBVs shows no significant difference ($<$1$\sigma$) between their environments. Even if the sample is further subdivided as proposed, the three most luminous LBVs are spatially dispersed similar to late O-type dwarfs, which have much longer lifetimes than expected for classical LBVs. Lower-luminosity LBVs have a distribution associated with red supergiants (RSGs), but these RSGs are dominated by stars of 10-15 M${}_{\odot }$ initial mass, with much longer lifetimes than expected for those lower-luminosity LBVs. If one's view is restricted to the highest-luminosity LBVs, then the appropriate comparison is with early O-type stars that are their presumed progenitors, when this is done, it is clear that even the high-luminosity LBVs are more dispersed than expected. Humphreys et al. also suggest that velocities of LBVs support the single-star view, being inconsistent with runaways. A quantitative analysis of the radial velocity distribution of LBVS in M31 and M33 contradicts this, modest runway speeds expected from mass gainers in binary evolution are consistent with the observed velocities, although the data lack the precision to discriminate.

arXiv comment9 pages, 3 figs. Accepted/in press

References in corpus (20)

• Binary interaction dominates the evolution of massive stars
• Stellar Multiplicity
• Mass Loss: Its Effect on the Evolution and Fate of High-Mass Stars
• Pre-Supernova Evolution of Massive Single and Binary Stars
• Southern Massive Stars at High Angular Resolution: Observational Campaign and Companion Detection
• On the role of continuum-driven eruptions in the evolution of very massive stars and Population III stars
• The incidence of stellar mergers and mass gainers among massive stars
• Luminous Blue Variable eruptions and related transients: Diversity of progenitors and outburst properties
• Runaway stars as progenitors of supernovae and gamma-ray bursts
• Long-Baseline Interferometric Multiplicity Survey of the Sco-Cen OB Association
• Red supergiants as potential Type IIn supernova progenitors: Spatially resolved 4.6 micron CO emission around VY CMa and Betelgeuse
• The Missing Luminous Blue Variables and the Bistability Jump
• Luminous Blue Variables are Antisocial: Their Isolation Implies that they are Kicked Mass Gainers in Binary Evolution
• The Eddington factor as the key to understand the winds of the most massive stars. Evidence for a Gamma-dependence of Wolf-Rayet type mass loss
• On the role of the WNH phase in the evolution of very massive stars: Enabling the LBV instability with feedback
• The Yellow and Red Supergiants of M33
• Yellow Supergiants in the Andromeda Galaxy (M31)
• On the Social Traits of Luminous Blue Variables
• Two step ejection of massive stars and the issue of their formation in isolation
• Luminous blue variables: An imaging perspective on their binarity and near environment

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Massive runaways and walkaway stars
• A new mass-loss rate prescription for red supergiants
• The diverse lives of progenitors of hydrogen-rich core-collapse supernovae: the role of binary interaction
• On the Gaia DR2 distances for Galactic Luminous Blue Variables
• The possible detection of a binary companion to a Type Ibn supernova progenitor
• Modelling Luminous-Blue-Variable Isolation
• Multiplicity of Galactic Luminous Blue Variable stars
• Shedding Light on the Isolation of Luminous Blue Variables
• Massive stars dying alone: The extremely remote environment of SN 2009ip
• The 2018 Census of Luminous Blue Variables
• Extreme isolation of WN3/O3 stars and implications for their evolutionary origin as the elusive stripped binaries
• A new and unusual LBV-like outburst from a Wolf-Rayet star in the outskirts of M33
• The isolation of Luminous Blue Variables resembles aging B-type supergiants, not the most massive unevolved stars
• Gaia TGAS search for Large Magellanic Cloud runaway supergiant stars:Candidate hypervelocity star discovery, and the nature of R71
• A Tale of Two Impostors: SN2002kg and SN1954J in NGC 2403
• A New Luminous blue variable in the outskirt of the Andromeda Galaxy
• A deep near-infrared spectroscopic survey of the Scutum-Crux arm for Wolf-Rayet stars
• Search for LBVs in the Local Volume galaxies: study of two stars in NGC 1156
• Luminous Blue Variables
• Kinematics of Luminous Blue Variables in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• An Unusual Transient in the Extremely Metal-Poor Galaxy SDSS J094332.35+332657.6 (Leoncino Dwarf)
• A warm molecular ring in AG Car: composing the mass-loss puzzle
• How long can LBVs sleep? A long-term photometric vaiability and spectral study of the Galactic candidate luminous blue variable MN112
• LBV phenomenon and binarity: The environment of HR Car
• On the spatial distribution of luminous blue variables in the M33 galaxy
• Kinematics of Wolf-Rayet Stars in the LMC: Clues to Subtype Origins