Multiple Mode Torsional Oscillator Studies and Evidence for Supersolidity in Bulk 4He
arXiv:1511.03401 · doi:10.1073/pnas.1605738113
Abstract
The discovery by Kim and Chan (KC) of an anomalous decrease in the period of torsional oscillators (TO) containing samples of solid He at temperatures below 0.2 K was initially interpreted as a superfluid-like decoupling of a fraction of the solid moment of inertia from the TO. These experiments appeared to confirm the thirty-year-old theoretical prediction by Chester, Andreev, and Leggett of the existence of a low-temperature Bose-condensed supersolid phase in solid He. The initial results of KC lead to a flurry of experimental and theoretical activity and their results for bulk He samples were soon confirmed in a number of laboratories. The early excitement in this field, however, has been tempered by the realization that an anomaly in the shear modulus of solid helium He may explain most if not all of the period shifts observed in the early TO experiments. In principle, it is possible to distinguish experimentally between shear modulus induced period shifts and period shifts resulting from other physical mechanisms through the use of multiple frequency torsional oscillators. In this paper we shall discuss our recent results on bulk solid He with double and triple mode TOs, using both open cylindrical cells and annular cells. In these experiments, we have observed a small frequency independent contribution to the period shift signal such as might be expected in the presence of a supersolid phase. Since the interplay between the elastic properties of the solid and the mechanics of TOs can be subtle and depends on the specific design of the TO, we shall discuss in detail the mechanics of the TOs employed in our measurements applying both analytic and finite element methods (FEM) for the analysis.
arXiv comment19 pages, 18 figures
References in corpus (24)
- Low Temperature Shear Modulus Changes in Solid 4-He and Connection to Supersolidity
- Absence of supersolidity in solid helium in porous Vycor glass
- Oscillation Frequency Dependence of Non-Classical Rotation Inertia of Solid He
- Superfluidity of Grain Boundaries in Solid Helium-4
- Observation of Unusual Mass Transport in Solid hcp 4He
- The fate of vacancy-induced supersolidity in 4He
- Observation of non-classical rotational inertia in bulk solid 4He
- Annealing Effect for Supersolid Fraction in He
- The giant plasticity of a quantum crystal
- Local stress and superfluid properties of solid Helium-4
- A Gross-Pitaevskii Treatment for Supersolid He
- Bose-Einstein Quantum Statistics and the Ground State of Solid 4He
- Non-linear Elastic Response in Solid Helium: critical velocity or strain
- Upper limit of supersoldity in solid helium
- Critical dislocation speed in helium-4 crystals
- Interpreting Torsional Oscillator Measurements: Effect of Shear Modulus and Supersolidity
- The Anomalous Behavior of Solid He in Porous Vycor Glass
- Effects of He Impurity on Solid He Studied by Compound Torsional Oscillator
- Theory of Supersolidity
- Mass Superflux in Solid Helium: the Role of He Impurities
- Frequency-dependent Study of Solid Helium-4 Contained in a Rigid Double-torus Torsional Oscillator
- The glassy response of double torsion oscillators in solid Helium-4
- In Pursuit of the Elusive Supersolid
- Frequency Dependence of the Supersolid Signature in Polycrystalline 4He