StarBench: The D-type expansion of an HII region
arXiv:1507.05621 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stv1659
Abstract
StarBench is a project focused on benchmarking and validating different star-formation and stellar feedback codes. In this first StarBench paper we perform a comparison study of the D-type expansion of an HII region. The aim of this work is to understand the differences observed between the twelve participating numerical codes against the various analytical expressions examining the D-type phase of HII region expansion. To do this, we propose two well-defined tests which are tackled by 1D and 3D grid- and SPH- based codes. The first test examines the `early phase' D-type scenario during which the mechanical pressure driving the expansion is significantly larger than the thermal pressure of the neutral medium. The second test examines the `late phase' D-type scenario during which the system relaxes to pressure equilibrium with the external medium. Although they are mutually in excellent agreement, all twelve participating codes follow a modified expansion law that deviates significantly from the classical Spitzer solution in both scenarios. We present a semi-empirical formula combining the two different solutions appropriate to both early and late phases that agrees with high-resolution simulations to . This formula provides a much better benchmark solution for code validation than the Spitzer solution. The present comparison has validated the participating codes and through this project we provide a dataset for calibrating the treatment of ionizing radiation hydrodynamics codes.
arXiv comment20 pages, 12 Figures, 4 Tables. Accepted for publication in MNRAS. Comments are welcome. Participation in future StarBench tests is also welcome
References in corpus (57)
- HEALPix -- a Framework for High Resolution Discretization, and Fast Analysis of Data Distributed on the Sphere
- Cosmological Hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement: a new high resolution code called RAMSES
- PLUTO: a Numerical Code for Computational Astrophysics
- Astrophysics Source Code Library
- SPLASH: An interactive visualisation tool for Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics simulations
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- A High Order Godunov Scheme with Constrained Transport and Adaptive Mesh Refinement for Astrophysical MHD
- Modelling discontinuities and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities in SPH
- The SILCC (SImulating the LifeCycle of molecular Clouds) project: I. Chemical evolution of the supernova-driven ISM
- A PDR-Code Comparison Study
- RAMSES-RT: Radiation hydrodynamics in the cosmological context
- On the Role of Massive Stars in the Support and Destruction of Giant Molecular Clouds
- Simulating the formation of molecular clouds. I. Slow formation by gravitational collapse from static initial conditions
- Massive stars in massive clusters II: Disruption of bound clusters by photoionization
- Simulating the formation of molecular clouds. II. Rapid formation from turbulent initial conditions
- Circumventing the radiation pressure barrier in the formation of massive stars via disk accretion
- Multi--dimensional Cosmological Radiative Transfer with a Variable Eddington Tensor Formalism
- H II regions: Witnesses to massive star formation
- Dispersal of molecular clouds by ionising radiation
- C^2-Ray: A new method for photon-conserving transport of ionizing radiation
- Cosmological Radiative Transfer Codes Comparison Project I: The Static Density Field Tests
- The Interplay of Magnetic Fields, Fragmentation and Ionization Feedback in High-Mass Star Formation
- Three-dimensional simulation of massive star formation in the disk accretion scenario
- On the formation of H-alpha line emission around classical T Tauri stars
- Enzo+Moray: Radiation Hydrodynamics Adaptive Mesh Refinement Simulations with Adaptive Ray Tracing
- Dynamical Expansion of Ionization and Dissociation Front around a Massive Star. II. On the Generality of Triggered Star Formation
- Driving Turbulence and Triggering Star Formation by Ionizing Radiation
- Radiation-magnetohydrodynamic simulations of HII regions and their associated PDRs in turbulent molecular clouds
- Ionisation-induced star formation I: The collect and collapse model
- Magnetohydronamic Evolution of HII Regions in Molecular Clouds: Simulation Methodology, Tests, and Uniform Media
- Radiation driven implosion and triggered star formation
- Dynamical HII Region Evolution in Turbulent Molecular Clouds
- Cosmological Radiative Transfer Comparison Project II: The Radiation-Hydrodynamic Tests
- Fast and accurate frequency-dependent radiation transport for hydrodynamics simulations in massive star formation
- Radiation Driven Implosion of Molecular Cloud Cores
- Radiation-magnetohydrodynamic simulations of the photoionisation of magnetised globules
- Molecular Cloud Evolution V. Cloud Destruction by Stellar Feedback
- Clumps and triggered star formation in ionised molecular clouds
- SEREN - A new SPH code for star and planet formation simulations
- Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics simulations of expanding HII regions. I. Numerical methods and tests
- Radiation hydrodynamics of triggered star formation: the effect of the diffuse radiation field
- Episodic accretion, protostellar radiative feedback, and their role in low-mass star formation
- Dynamical Models for the Formation of Elephant Trunks in H II Regions
- 3D simulations of globules and pillars formation around HII regions: turbulence and shock curvature
- On the simultaneous evolution of massive protostars and their host cores
- On the stability of radiation-pressure-dominated cavities
- Protostellar Outflows and Radiative Feedback from Massive Stars
- Effects of Magnetic Fields on Photoionised Pillars and Globules
- Fervent: Chemistry-coupled, ionising and non-ionising radiative feedback in magnetohydrodynamical simulations
- Radiation-hydrodynamical simulations of massive star formation using Monte Carlo radiative transfer: I. Algorithms and numerical methods
- Comparing simulations of ionisation triggered star formation and observations in RCW 120
- 3D simulations of pillars formation around HII regions: the importance of shock curvature
- The reliability of approximate radiation transport methods for irradiated disk studies
- On the effects of optically thick gas (disks) around massive stars
- Three-dimensional molecular line transfer: A simulated star-forming region
- Turbulence in simulated HII regions
- Accuracy and Efficiency of Raytracing Photoionisation Algorithms
Cited by in corpus (77)
- Variable interstellar radiation fields in simulated dwarf galaxies: supernovae versus photoelectric heating
- First hydrodynamics simulations of radiation forces and photoionization feedback in massive star formation
- The GRIFFIN project -- Formation of star clusters with individual massive stars in a simulated dwarf galaxy starburst
- SILCC VI -- Multi-phase ISM structure, stellar clustering, and outflows with supernovae, stellar winds, ionising radiation and cosmic rays
- The relative impact of photoionizing radiation and stellar winds on different environments
- Episodic accretion: the interplay of infall and disc instabilities
- Isolating signatures of major cloud-cloud collisions II: The lifetimes of broad bridge features
- Efficient early stellar feedback can suppress galactic outflows by reducing supernova clustering
- Photoionisation Feedback in a Self-Gravitating, Magnetised, Turbulent Cloud
- Which feedback mechanisms dominate in the high-pressure environment of the Central Molecular Zone?
- The first multi-dimensional view of mass loss from externally FUV irradiated protoplanetary discs
- Impact of Lyman alpha pressure on metal-poor dwarf galaxies
- Prevalent externally-driven protoplanetary disc dispersal as a function of the galactic environment
- Modeling UV Radiation Feedback from Massive Stars: I. Implementation of Adaptive Ray Tracing Method and Tests
- The Geometry and Dynamical Role of Stellar Wind Bubbles in Photoionised HII Regions
- SILCC-ZOOM: The early impact of ionizing radiation on forming molecular clouds
- Grand challenges in protoplanetary disc modelling
- Simulating radiative feedback and star cluster formation in GMCs: I. Dependence on gravitational boundedness
- Impact of galactic shear and stellar feedback on star formation
- Radiation-hydrodynamical simulations of massive star formation using Monte Carlo radiative transfer II. The formation of a 25 solar-mass star
- Detecting stellar-wind bubbles through infrared arcs in HII regions
- Starbursts in low-mass haloes at Cosmic Dawn. I. The critical halo mass for star formation
- When H II Regions are Complicated: Considering Perturbations from Winds, Radiation Pressure, and Other Effects
- The challenge of simulating the star cluster population of dwarf galaxies with resolved interstellar medium
- Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
- SIRIUS Project. III. Star-by-star simulations of star cluster formation using a direct N-body integrator with stellar feedback
- A population of hypercompact HII regions identified from young HII regions
- Photochemical-dynamical models of externally FUV irradiated protoplanetary discs
- On the turbulence driving mode of expanding HII regions
- How radiation affects superbubbles: Through momentum injection in early phase and photo-heating thereafter
- Makemake + Sedna: A Continuum Radiation Transport and Photoionization Framework for Astrophysical Newtonian Fluid Dynamics
- Quantifying the effects of spatial resolution and noise on galaxy metallicity gradients
- Large-scale CO J=1-0 observations of the giant molecular cloud associated with the infrared ring N35 with the Nobeyama 45-m telescope
- Photoionising feedback in spiral arm molecular clouds
- The PDR structure and kinematics around the compact HII regions S235A and S235C with [CII], [13CII], [OI] and HCO+ line profiles
- Tree-based solvers for adaptive mesh refinement code FLASH -- II: radiation transport module TreeRay
- Radiative transfer of ionizing radiation through gas and dust: stellar source case
- Molecular envelope around the HII region RCW 120
- The classical D-type expansion of spherical H II regions
- The origin of the [CII]-deficit in a simulated dwarf galaxies starburst
- SPRAI: Coupling of radiative feedback and primordial chemistry in moving mesh hydrodynamics
- CO observations of the molecular gas in the galactic HII region Sh2-48; Evidence for cloud-cloud collision as a trigger of high-mass star formation
- Hydrodynamical models of cometary HII regions
- Observing gas and dust in simulations of star formation with Monte Carlo radiation transport on Voronoi meshes
- RCW 120: A possible case of hit and run, elucidated by multi temperature dust mapping
- Dust cleansing of star-forming gas I: Did radiation from bright stars affect the chemical composition of the Sun and of M67?
- Radiation transport methods in star formation simulations
- Rapid radiative clearing of protoplanetary discs
- The extremely sharp transition between molecular and ionized gas in the Horsehead nebula
- Unveiling molecular clouds toward bipolar HII region G8.14+0.23
- PION: Simulating bow shocks and circumstellar nebulae
- Simulating ionization feedback from young massive stars: impact of numerical resolution
- Factories of CO-dark gas: molecular clouds with limited star formation efficiencies by FUV feedback
- Connecting stellar and galactic scales: Energetic feedback from stellar wind bubbles to supernova remnants
- A high-performance and portable asymptotic preserving radiation hydrodynamics code with the M1 model
- Uncovering distinct environments in an extended physical system around the W33 complex
- Radiation feedback in dusty clouds
- Illuminating a tadpole's metamorphosis III: quantifying past and present environmental impact
- Tree-based solvers for adaptive mesh refinement code FLASH -- III: a novel scheme for radiation pressure on dust and gas and radiative transfer from diffuse sources
- CMacIonize 2.0: a novel task-based approach to Monte Carlo radiation transfer
- Photoionization feedback in turbulent molecular clouds
- Modelling of ionising feedback with Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics and Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer on a Voronoi grid
- A Discontinuous Galerkin Solver in the FLASH Multi-Physics Framework
- Radiation hydrodynamic simulations of massive star formation via gravitationally trapped HII regions - Spherically symmetric ionised accretion flows
- Ionising feedback from an O star formed in a shock-compressed layer
- How D-type HII region expansion depends on numerical resolution
- Expanding shells around young clusters -- S 171/Be 59
- 3D structure of HII regions in the star-forming complex S254-S258
- Synthetic observations of protostellar multiple systems
- The origin and evolution of the [CII] deficit in HII regions and star-forming molecular clouds
- DAWN. I. Simulating the formation and early evolution of stellar clusters with Phantom N-Body
- A multi-ion non-equilibrium solver for ionised astrophysical plasmas with arbitrary elemental abundances
- Evidence of triggered star formation in the Pillars of Creation from JWST observations
- Investigating the physical conditions in extended system hosting mid-infrared bubble N14
- Radiative transfer of 21-cm line through ionised cavities in an expanding universe
- Star formation toward the H~II region IRAS 10427-6032
- A complete survey of filaments in Cygnus X