Enriching gender in PER: A binary past and a complex future

Abstract

In this article, we draw on previous reports from physics, science education, and women's studies to propose a more nuanced treatment of gender in physics education research (PER). A growing body of PER examines gender differences in participation, performance, and attitudes toward physics. We have three critiques of this work: (1) it does not question whether the achievements of men are the most appropriate standard, (2) individual experiences and student identities are undervalued, and (3) the binary model of gender is not questioned. Driven by these critiques, we propose a conception of gender that is more up-to-date with other fields and discuss gender-as-performance as an extended example. We also discuss work on the intersection of identities [e.g., gender with race and ethnicity, socioeconomic status, lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) status], much of which has been conducted outside of physics. Within PER, some studies examine the intersection of gender and race, and identify the lack of a single identity as a key challenge of "belonging" in physics. Acknowledging this complexity enables us to further critique what we term a binary gender deficit model. This framework, which is implicit in much of the gender-based PER, casts gender as a fixed binary trait and suggests that women are deficient in characteristics necessary to succeed. Alternative models of gender allow a greater range and fluidity of gender identities, and highlight deficiencies in data that exclude women's experiences. We suggest new investigations that diverge from this expanded gender framework in PER.

27 pages, accepted to Phys. Rev. Special Topics - PER

Cited by in corpus (15)

• Gender Fairness within the Force Concept Inventory
• Hermione and the Secretary: How gendered task division in introductory physics labs can disrupt equitable learning
• A longitudinal analysis of students' motivational characteristics in introductory physics courses: Gender differences
• Do evidence-based active-engagement courses reduce the gender gap in introductory physics?
• Multi-Dimensional Item Response Theory and the Force Concept Inventory
• Using Machine Learning to Identify the Most At-Risk Students in Physics Classes
• Research-based assessment of students' beliefs about experimental physics: When is gender a factor?
• Modeling student pathways in a physics bachelor's degree program
• Beyond teaching methods: highlighting physics faculty's strengths and agency
• Investigating institutional influence on graduate program admissions by modelling physics GRE cut-off scores
• Gender Equity in Physics Labs: A Review
• Bioscience Students in Physics Courses With Higher Test Anxiety Have Lower Grades on High-Stakes Assessments, and Women Report More Test Anxiety Than Men
• Positive attitudinal shifts and a narrowing gender gap: Do expertlike attitudes correlate to higher learning gains for women in the physics classroom?
• The Physics GRE does not help applicants "stand out"
• Analyzing admissions metrics as predictors of graduate GPA and whether graduate GPA mediates PhD completion