Defining and identifying Sleeping Beauties in science

Abstract

A Sleeping Beauty (SB) in science refers to a paper whose importance is not recognized for several years after publication. Its citation history exhibits a long hibernation period followed by a sudden spike of popularity. Previous studies suggest a relative scarcity of SBs. The reliability of this conclusion is, however, heavily dependent on identification methods based on arbitrary threshold parameters for sleeping time and number of citations, applied to small or monodisciplinary bibliographic datasets. Here we present a systematic, large-scale, and multidisciplinary analysis of the SB phenomenon in science. We introduce a parameter-free measure that quantifies the extent to which a specific paper can be considered an SB. We apply our method to 22 million scientific papers published in all disciplines of natural and social sciences over a time span longer than a century. Our results reveal that the SB phenomenon is not exceptional. There is a continuous spectrum of delayed recognition where both the hibernation period and the awakening intensity are taken into account. Although many cases of SBs can be identified by looking at monodisciplinary bibliographic data, the SB phenomenon becomes much more apparent with the analysis of multidisciplinary datasets, where we can observe many examples of papers achieving delayed yet exceptional importance in disciplines different from those where they were originally published. Our analysis emphasizes a complex feature of citation dynamics that so far has received little attention, and also provides empirical evidence against the use of short-term citation metrics in the quantification of scientific impact.

40 pages, Supporting Information included, top examples listed at http://qke.github.io/projects/beauty/beauty.html

References in corpus (5)

• Power-law distributions in empirical data
• Cooperative Game Theory Approaches for Network Partitioning
• Universality of citation distributions: towards an objective measure of scientific impact
• Principles of scientific research team formation and evolution
• National Scientific Facilities and Their Science Impact on Non-Biomedical Research

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Quantifying patterns of research interest evolution
• Identification of milestone papers through time-balanced network centrality
• Growing complex network of citations of scientific papers -- measurements and modeling
• Measuring the Diversity of Facebook Reactions to Research
• Communities of attention networks: introducing qualitative and conversational perspectives for altmetrics
• Weak ties strengthen anger contagion in social media
• A SIR epidemic model for citation dynamics
• Search for Evergreens in Science: A Functional Data Analysis
• Utilizing Citation Network Structure to Predict Citation Counts: A Deep Learning Approach
• An Overview on Evaluating and Predicting Scholarly Article Impact
• Measure the Impact of Institution and Paper via Institution-citation Network