The dangers of being trigger--happy
arXiv:1502.05865 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stv396
Abstract
We examine the evidence offered for triggered star formation against the backdrop provided by recent numerical simulations of feedback from massive stars at or below giant molecular cloud sizescales. We compile a catalogue of sixty--seven observational papers, mostly published over the last decade, and examine the signposts most commonly used to infer the presence of triggered star formation. We then determine how well these signposts perform in a recent suite of hydrodynamic simulations of star formation including feedback from O--type stars performed by Dale et al (2012a, b, 2013a, b, 2014). We find that none of the observational markers improve the chances of correctly identifying a given star as triggered by more than factors of two at most. This limits the fidelity of these techniques in interpreting star formation histories. We therefore urge caution in interpreting observations of star formation near feedback--driven structures in terms of triggering.
arXiv comment16 pages, 6 figures, accepted by MNRAS
References in corpus (95)
- Star Formation in the Milky Way and Nearby Galaxies
- The Spitzer c2d Legacy Results: Star Formation Rates and Efficiencies; Evolution and Lifetimes
- Modelling Accretion in Protobinary Systems
- Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of Collapse and Fragmentation in Massive Protostellar Cores
- On the Role of Massive Stars in the Support and Destruction of Giant Molecular Clouds
- Massive stars in massive clusters II: Disruption of bound clusters by photoionization
- Before the first supernova: combined effects of HII regions and winds on molecular clouds
- Global Star Formation Rates in Disk Galaxies and Circumnuclear Starbursts from Cloud Collisions
- H II regions: Witnesses to massive star formation
- Triggered massive-star formation on the borders of Galactic HII regions. I. A search for `collect and collapse' candidates
- The Interplay of Magnetic Fields, Fragmentation and Ionization Feedback in High-Mass Star Formation
- Cluster Formation in Protostellar Outflow-Driven Turbulence
- Photoionising feedback in star cluster formation
- Triggered star formation on the borders of the Galactic HII region RCW 120
- Triggered massive-star formation on the borders of Galactic HII regions. II. Evidence for the collect and collapse process around RCW 79
- Molecular clouds towards RCW 49 and Westerlund 2; Evidence for cluster formation triggered by cloud-cloud collision
- Star formation around RCW 120, the perfect bubble
- Molecular Clouds Toward the Super Star Cluster NGC3603; Possible Evidence for a Cloud-Cloud Collision in Triggering the Cluster Formation
- Clustered and Triggered Star Formation in W5: Observations with Spitzer
- Ionizing feedback from massive stars in massive clusters III: Disruption of partially unbound clouds
- Ionisation-induced star formation I: The collect and collapse model
- Radiation driven implosion and triggered star formation
- Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of the Formation of Orion-Like Star Clusters I. Implications for the Origin of the Initial Mass Function
- Ionizing feedback from massive stars in massive clusters: Fake bubbles and untriggered star formation
- Star Cluster Formation in Turbulent, Magnetized Dense Clumps with Radiative and Outflow Feedback
- Detailed Numerical Simulations on the Formation of Pillars around HII-regions
- Star formation triggered by the Galactic HII region RCW 120: First results from the Herschel Space Observatory
- X-ray Study of Triggered Star Formation and Protostars in IC 1396N
- The Milky Way Project: A statistical study of massive star formation associated with infrared bubbles
- Hierarchical Triggering of Star Formation by Superbubbles in W3/W4
- Triggered massive-star formation at the border of the HII region Sh 104
- Temperature and Density Distribution in the Molecular Gas Toward Westerlund 2: Further Evidence for Physical Association
- Molecular clouds in the Trifid nebula M20; Possible evidence for a cloud-cloud collision in triggering the formation of the first generation stars
- Triggered massive-star formation on the borders of Galactic HII regions. IV- Star formation at the periphery of Sh2-212
- iVINE - Ionization in the parallel tree/SPH code VINE: First results on the observed age-spread around O-stars
- Clumps and triggered star formation in ionised molecular clouds
- Ionisation-induced star formation II: External irradiation of a turbulent molecular cloud
- Star formation triggered by HII regions in our Galaxy: First results for N49 from the Herschel infrared survey of the Galactic plane
- Radiation hydrodynamics of triggered star formation: the effect of the diffuse radiation field
- Hydrodynamics of photoionized columns in the Eagle Nebula, M 16
- 3D simulations of globules and pillars formation around HII regions: turbulence and shock curvature
- Millimeter- and Submillimeter-Wave Observations of the OMC-2/3 Region. II. Observational Evidence for Outflow-Triggered Star Formation in the OMC-2 FIR 3/4 Region
- Triggered Star Formation in the Orion Bright-Rimmed Clouds
- Deep wide-field near-infrared survey of the Carina Nebula
- Ionization--induced star formation IV: Triggering in bound clusters
- Dynamical Expansion of Ionization and Dissociation Front around a Massive Star. I. A Mode of Triggered Star Formation
- Triggered Star Formation by Massive Stars
- Searching for signs of triggered star formation toward IC 1848
- Ionization--induced star formation V: Triggering in partially unbound clusters
- Triggered Star Formation and Evolution of T-Tauri stars in and around Bright-Rimmed Clouds
- Opening the Treasure Chest: A Newborn Star Cluster Emerges from its Dust Pillar in Carina
- Observational study of sites of triggered star formation: CO and mid-infrared observations
- The Elephant Trunk Nebula and the Trumpler 37 cluster: Contribution of triggered star formation to the total population of an HII region
- Young Stellar Objects and Triggered Star Formation in the Vulpecula OB Association
- Sequential Star Formation in RCW 34: A Spectroscopic Census of the Stellar Content of High-mass Star-forming Regions
- A new algorithm for modelling photoionising radiation in smoothed particle hydrodynamics
- Star formation in bright-rimmed clouds and cluster associated with W5 E H{\sc ii} region
- The molecular complex associated with the Galactic HII region Sh2-90: a possible site of triggered star formation
- Triggered Star Formation and Dust around Mid-Infrared-Identified Bubbles
- Massive-Star Forming Infrared Loop around the Crab-like Supernova Remnant G54.1+0.3: Post Main-Sequence Triggered Star Formation?
- Herschel far-infrared observations of the Carina Nebula complex II: The embedded young stellar and protostellar population
- A feedback-driven bubble G24.136+00.436: a possible site of triggered star formation
- 3D simulations of pillars formation around HII regions: the importance of shock curvature
- Triggered massive-star formation on the borders of Galactic HII regions. III. Star formation at the periphery of Sh2-219
- NGC 346 in The Small Magellanic Cloud. IV. Triggered Star Formation in the HII Region N66
- Triggered star formation and Young Stellar Population in Bright-Rimmed Cloud SFO 38
- Sequential star formation at the periphery of the HII regions Sh 217 and Sh 219
- Triggered star formation surrounding Wolf-Rayet star HD 211853
- The supergiant shell with triggered star formation in Irr galaxy IC 2574: neutral and ionized gas kinematics
- Spitzer Observations of the HII Region NGC 2467: An Analysis of Triggered Star Formation
- The fragmentation of expanding shells II: Thickness matters
- Sequential Formation of Low-Mass Stars in the BRC 14 Region
- Spitzer/IRAC view of Sh 2-284: Searching for evidence of triggered star formation in an isolated region in the outer Milky Way
- Young stellar clusters in the Rosette molecular cloud. Arguments against triggered star formation
- W49A: A starburst triggered by expanding shells
- A tale of two cores: Triggered massive star formation in the bright-rimmed cloud SFO 75
- Triggered star formation around mid-infrared bubbles in G8.14+0.23 H II region
- Triggered/sequential star formation? A multi-phase ISM study around the prominent IRDC G18.93-0.03
- The stellar population and complex structure of the bright-rimmed cloud IC 1396N
- Gravitational Fragmentation of Expanding Shells. I. Linear Analysis
- Pre-main-sequence stars in the young open cluster NGC 1893: II. Evidence for triggered massive star formation
- Molecular Clouds in Supershells: A Case Study of Three Objects in the Walls of GSH 287+04-17 and GSH 277+00+36
- The HII region G35.673-00.847: another case of triggered star formation?
- Gravitational instability of expanding shells: Solution with nonlinear terms
- Evidence of triggered star formation in G327.3-0.6. Dust-continuum mapping of an infrared dark cloud with P-ArTéMiS
- Multi-wavelength study of triggered star formation around mid-infrared bubble N14
- Testing diagnostics of triggered star formation
- Assessing molecular line diagnostics of triggered star formation using synthetic observations
- Gravitational Fragmentation of Expanding Shells. II. Three-dimensional Simulations
- SOAR-OSIRIS observations of the Sh 2-307 HII region: Triggered star formation beyond the solar circle
- The open cluster NGC6823 and possible triggered star formation associated with SNR G59.5+0.1
- Triggered star formation in a molecular shell created by a SNR?
- The fragmentation of expanding shells III: Oligarchic accretion and the mass spectrum of fragments
- A mapping study of L1174 with 13CO J=2-1 and 12CO J=3-2: star formation triggered by a Herbig Ae/Be star
- Triggered massive and clustered stars formation by together H II regions G38.91-0.44 and G39.30-1.04
Cited by in corpus (78)
- The APOGEE-2 Survey of the Orion Star Forming Complex II: Six-dimensional structure
- The modelling of feedback in star formation simulations
- The Spatial Relation between Young Star Clusters and Molecular Clouds in M 51 with LEGUS
- Photoionisation Feedback in a Self-Gravitating, Magnetised, Turbulent Cloud
- Interpreting the Star Formation Efficiency of Molecular Clouds with Ionising Feedback
- Simulating Star Clusters Across Cosmic Time: I. Initial Mass Function, Star Formation Rates and Efficiencies
- Bipolar HII regions - Morphology and star formation in their vicinity - I - G319.8800.79 and G010.3200.15
- ALMA reveals sequential high-mass star formation in the G9.62+0.19 complex
- Isotopic enrichment of forming planetary systems from supernova pollution
- Modelling of the Effects of Stellar Feedback during Star Cluster Formation Using a Hybrid Gas and N-Body Method
- Star formation towards the Galactic HII region RCW120
- Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
- The stellar contents and star formation in the NGC 7538 region
- The Local Volume HI Survey: star formation properties
- Star formation in W3 - AFGL333: Young stellar content, properties and roles of external feedback
- Bursting Bubbles: Feedback from Clustered SNe and the Trade-off Between Turbulence and Outflows
- New insights in the HII region G18.88-0.49: hub-filament system and accreting filaments
- Spatial distribution of star formation related to ionized regions throughout the inner Galactic plane
- Planck cold clumps in the Orionis complex: I. Discovery of an extremely young Class 0 protostellar object and a proto-brown dwarf candidate in a bright rimmed clump PGCC G192.32-11.88
- Multi-scale analysis of the Monoceros OB 1 star-forming region: II. Colliding filaments in the Monoceros OB1 molecular cloud
- On the relative importance of different microphysics on the D-type expansion of galactic HII regions
- The Massive Star-Forming Regions Omnibus X-Ray Catalog, Second Installment
- On the turbulence driving mode of expanding HII regions
- On the compressive nature of turbulence driven by ionising feedback in the pillars of the Carina Nebula
- Supernovae in the Orion: the missing link in the star forming history of the region
- The Massive Star-Forming Regions Omnibus X-Ray Catalog, Third Installment
- Herschel observations of the Galactic HII region RCW 79
- The Milky Way Project and ATLASGAL: The distribution and physical properties of cold clumps near infrared bubbles
- The Global Star-Formation Law by Supernova Feedback
- ALMA observations of RCW 120 Fragmentation at 0.01pc scale
- Supernova enrichment of planetary systems in low-mass star clusters
- Kinematic evidence for feedback-driven star formation in NGC 1893
- Quantifying the energy balance between the turbulent ionised gas and young stars
- The O- and B-Type Stellar Population in W3: Beyond the High-Density Layer
- Globules and Pillars in Cygnus X I. Herschel Far-infrared imaging of the Cyg OB2 environment
- Structural and Dynamical Analysis of 0.1pc Cores and Filaments in the 30~Doradus-10 Giant Molecular Cloud
- ATOMS: ALMA Three-millimeter Observations of Massive Star-forming regions -XIII. Ongoing triggered star formation within clump-fed scenario found in the massive ( ) clump
- Understanding formation of young, distributed low-mass stars and clusters in the W4 cloud complex
- Deep diving off the `Cosmic Cliffs': previously hidden outflows in NGC 3324 revealed by JWST
- Molecular Lines of 13 Galactic Infrared Bubble Regions
- Dynamical star forming history of Per OB2
- The cosmic DANCe of Perseus I: Membership, phase-space structure, mass, and energy distributions
- Planck Cold Clumps in the lambda Orionis Complex. III. A chemical probe of stellar feedback on cores in the lambda Orionis cloud
- AFGL 5180 and AFGL 6366S: sites of hub-filament systems at the opposite edges of a filamentary cloud
- The location, clustering, and propagation of massive star formation in giant molecular clouds
- Interaction Between HII Region and AFGL333-Ridge: Implications to the Star Formation Scenario
- Globules and pillars in Cygnus X III. Herschel and upGREAT/SOFIA far-infrared spectroscopy of the globule IRAS 20319+3958 inCygnus X
- CO observations toward the isolated mid-infrared bubble S44: External triggering of O-star formation by a cloud-cloud collision
- APEX CO observations towards the photodissociation region of RCW120
- Molecular environs and triggered star formation around the large Galactic infrared bubble N 24
- The Role of Magnetic Fields in Triggered Star Formation of RCW 120
- Sh 2-301: a blistered H II region undergoing star formation
- Isotopic enrichment of planetary systems from Asymptotic Giant Branch stars
- Illuminating a tadpole's metamorphosis III: quantifying past and present environmental impact
- Star formation conditions in a Planck Galactic Cold Clump, G108.84-00.81
- An APEX search for carbon emission from NGC 1977 proplyds
- Probing the physical conditions and star formation processes in the Galactic HII region S305
- The Cassiopeia Filament: A Blown Spur of the Local Arm
- Clustering of low mass stars around Herbig Be star IL Cep -- Evidence of "Rocket Effect" using Gaia EDR3 ?
- Multiwavelength study of the G345.5+1.5 region
- A Case Study of Triggered Star Formation in Cygnus X
- Star-forming regions at the periphery of the supershell surrounding the Cyg OB1 association. II. ISM kinematics and YSOs in the star cluster vdB 130 region
- Investigation of Rocket Effect in BRC 18 using Gaia EDR3
- High-resolution CARMA Observation of Molecular Gas in the North America and Pelican Nebulae
- Interaction between the Supernova Remnant W44 and the Infrared Dark Cloud G034.77-00.55: shock induced star formation?
- The JCMT Gould Belt Survey: radiative heating by OB stars
- Magnetic fields and young stellar objects in cometary cloud LDN 1616
- A revision of the vdB 130 cluster stellar content based on GAIA DR2 Data. Interstellar extinction toward the Cyg OB1 supershell
- Colliding interstellar bubbles in the direction of l=54°
- Investigation of Rocket Effect in Bright-Rimmed Clouds using Gaia EDR3
- The kinematics of young stellar population in the W5 region of the Cassiopeia OB6 association: implication on the formation process of stellar associations
- Probing gas kinematics and PDR structure around O-type stars in Sh 2-305 HII region
- SOFIA FIFI-LS spectroscopy of DR21 Main: energetics of the spatially-resolved outflow from a high-mass protostar
- MeerKAT and ALMA view of the AGAL045.804-0.356 clump
- The evolution of velocity dispersion in the Sco-Cen OB association
- Evidence of triggered star formation in the Pillars of Creation from JWST observations
- Comparing the spatial and kinematic distribution of gas and young stars around the shell-like structure in the CMa OB1 association
- Investigating star formation activity in the Sh 2-61 H II region