Galaxy Assembly Bias: A Significant Source of Systematic Error in the Galaxy-Halo Relationship
arXiv:1311.1818 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stu1383
Abstract
It is common practice for methods that use galaxy clustering to constrain the galaxy-halo relationship, such as the halo occupation distribution (HOD) and/or conditional luminosity function (CLF), to assume that halo mass alone suffices to determine a halo's resident galaxy population. Yet, the clustering strength of cold dark matter halos depends upon halo properties in addition to mass, such as formation time, an effect referred to as assembly bias. If galaxy characteristics are correlated with any of these auxiliary halo properties, the basic assumption of HOD/CLF methods is violated. We estimate the potential for assembly bias to induce systematic errors in inferred halo occupation statistics. We use halo abundance matching and age matching to construct fiducial mock galaxy catalogs that exhibit assembly bias as well as additional mock catalogs with identical HODs, but with assembly bias removed. We fit a parameterized HOD to the projected two-point clustering of mock galaxies in each catalog to assess the systematic errors induced by reasonable levels of assembly bias. In the absence of assembly bias, the inferred HODs generally describe the true underlying HODs well, validating the basic methodology. However, in all of the cases with assembly bias, the inferred HODs have systematic errors that are statistically significant. In most cases, these systematic errors cannot be identified using void statistics as auxiliary observables. We conclude that the galaxy-halo relationship inferred from galaxy clustering should be subject to a non-negligible systematic error induced by assembly bias. Our work suggests that efforts to model and/or constrain assembly bias should be high priorities as it is a threatening source of systematic error in galaxy evolution studies as well as the precision cosmology program.
arXiv comment28 pages, 15 figures including an appendix. v2 includes minor revisions based upon referee comments. Accepted for publication in the MNRAS. Title changed from original "Phantom Menace of Galaxy Clustering"
References in corpus (91)
- A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
- The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: Spectra and redshifts
- Toward a halo mass function for precision cosmology: the limits of universality
- An analytic model for the spatial clustering of dark matter haloes
- The Rockstar Phase-Space Temporal Halo Finder and the Velocity Offsets of Cluster Cores
- Concentrations of Dark Halos from their Assembly Histories
- The Large Scale Bias of Dark Matter Halos: Numerical Calibration and Model Tests
- Halos and galaxies in the standard cosmological model: results from the Bolshoi simulation
- The Dark Side of the Halo Occupation Distribution
- The Halo Occupation Distribution: Towards an Empirical Determination of the Relation Between Galaxies and Mass
- Theoretical Models of the Halo Occupation Distribution: Separating Central and Satellite Galaxies
- The Luminosity and Color Dependence of the Galaxy Correlation Function
- Galaxy Clustering in the Completed SDSS Redshift Survey: The Dependence on Color and Luminosity
- Modeling Luminosity-Dependent Galaxy Clustering Through Cosmic Time
- How do galaxies populate Dark Matter halos?
- Properties of Galaxy Groups in the SDSS: I.-- The Dependence of Colour, Star Formation, and Morphology on Halo Mass
- The age dependence of halo clustering
- Adaptive Refinement Tree - a new high-resolution N-body code for cosmological simulations
- Constraining Galaxy Formation and Cosmology with the Conditional Luminosity Function of Galaxies
- Gravitationally Consistent Halo Catalogs and Merger Trees for Precision Cosmology
- Linking halo mass to galaxy luminosity
- Galaxy Evolution from Halo Occupation Distribution Modeling of DEEP2 and SDSS Galaxy Clustering
- The Dependence of Halo Clustering on Halo Formation History, Concentration, and Occupation
- New constraints on the evolution of the stellar-to-dark matter connection: a combined analysis of galaxy-galaxy lensing, clustering, and stellar mass functions from z=0.2 to z=1
- Connecting Galaxies, Halos, and Star Formation Rates Across Cosmic Time
- Galaxy evolution in groups and clusters: star formation rates, red sequence fractions, and the persistent bimodality
- The Importance of Satellite Quenching for the Build-Up of the Red Sequence of Present Day Galaxies
- Halo Substructure And The Power Spectrum
- On the Mass-to-Light Ratio of Large Scale Structure
- The Connection between Galaxies and Dark Matter Structures in the Local Universe
- Assembly bias in the clustering of dark matter haloes
- The Physics of Galaxy Clustering I: A Model for Subhalo Populations
- The size - virial radius relation of galaxies
- Halo assembly bias and its effects on galaxy clustering
- Cosmological parameter constraints from galaxy-galaxy lensing and galaxy clustering with the SDSS DR7
- Towards a Concordant Model of Halo Occupation Statistics
- The Non-Parametric Model for Linking Galaxy Luminosity with Halo/Subhalo Mass
- Halo Assembly Bias in Hierarchical Structure Formation
- The Radial Distribution of Galaxies in LCDM clusters
- The Excursion Set Theory of Halo Mass Functions, Halo Clustering, and Halo Growth
- Cosmological Constraints from a Combination of Galaxy Clustering and Lensing -- I. Theoretical Framework
- Halo Occupation Distribution Modeling of Clustering of Luminous Red Galaxies
- The Dark Side of Galaxy Color
- Satellite Kinematics II: The Halo Mass-Luminosity Relation of Central Galaxies in SDSS
- Modeling Galaxy-Mass Correlations in Dissipationless Simulations
- Cosmological Constraints from a Combination of Galaxy Clustering and Lensing -- III. Application to SDSS Data
- The MultiDark Database: Release of the Bolshoi and MultiDark Cosmological Simulations
- What aspects of galaxy environment matter?
- On Halo Formation Times and Assembly Bias
- A Halo Model of Galaxy Colors and Clustering in the SDSS
- Galaxy Occupation Statistics of Dark Matter Haloes: Observational Results
- What determines satellite galaxy disruption?
- Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Clustering and the Mass-to-Number Ratio of Galaxy Clusters
- Evolution of the Stellar-to-Dark Matter Relation: Separating Star-Forming and Passive Galaxies from z=1 to 0
- Assembly bias and the dynamical structure of dark matter halos
- Mergers and Mass Accretion for Infalling Halos Both End Well Outside Cluster Virial Radii
- A theoretical framework for combining techniques that probe the link between galaxies and dark matter
- The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: the low redshift sample
- Void Statistics in Large Galaxy Redshift Surveys: Does Halo Occupation of Field Galaxies Depend on Environment?
- The Dark Side of Galaxy Color: evidence from new SDSS measurements of galaxy clustering and lensing
- The Halo Distribution of 2dF Galaxies
- zCOSMOS 20k: Satellite galaxies are the main drivers of environmental effects in the galaxy population at least to z~0.7
- The clustering of H-alpha emitters at z=2.23 from HiZELS
- SHAM Beyond Clustering: New Tests of Galaxy-Halo Abundance Matching with Galaxy Groups
- Galaxy Assembly Bias on the Red Sequence
- Observational Evidence for an Age Dependence of Halo Bias
- The Spatial Clustering of ROSAT All-Sky Survey AGNs II. Halo Occupation Distribution Modeling of the Cross Correlation Function
- Detection of galaxy assembly bias
- The stellar-subhalo mass relation of satellite galaxies
- Cosmological Constraints from a Combination of Galaxy Clustering & Lensing -- II. Fisher Matrix Analysis
- The distribution of ejected subhalos and its implication for halo assembly bias
- Very small-scale clustering of quasars from a complete quasar lens survey
- The clustering of SDSS galaxy groups: mass and color dependence
- Numerical resolution limits on subhalo abundance matching
- Testing Subhalo Abundance Matching in Cosmological Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Simulations
- A Cosmic Coincidence: The Power-Law Galaxy Correlation Function
- The nature of assembly bias - I. Clues from a LCDM cosmology
- The DEEP2 Galaxy Redshift Survey: The Evolution of Void Statistics from z~1 to z~0
- Constraining Satellite Galaxy Stellar Mass Loss and Predicting Intrahalo Light I: Framework and Results at Low Redshift
- Joint Analysis of Gravitational Lensing, Clustering and Abundance: Toward the Unification of Large-Scale Structure Analysis
- The nature of assembly bias - II. Halo spin
- Modeling the Very Small-Scale Clustering of Luminous Red Galaxies
- Cosmic Voids and Galaxy Bias in the Halo Occupation Framework
- Evolution of the Clustering of Photometrically Selected SDSS Galaxies
- Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Clustering and the Mass-to-Number Ratio of Galaxy Clusters: Marginalizing over the Physics of Galaxy Formation
- The VIMOS-VLT Deep Survey: Evolution in the Halo Occupation Number since z 1
- Relative clustering and the joint halo occupation distribution of red-sequence and blue-cloud galaxies in COMBO-17
- Linking haloes to galaxies: how many halo properties are needed?
- Are the halo occupation predictions consistent with large scale galaxy clustering?
- The Origin of Dark Matter Halo Profiles
- Halo Occupation Distribution of Massive Galaxies since z = 1
Cited by in corpus (179)
- First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: matter and galaxy clustering
- Large-Scale Galaxy Bias
- The Connection between Galaxies and their Dark Matter Halos
- Disruption of Dark Matter Substructure: Fact or Fiction?
- Dark Matter Substructure in Numerical Simulations: A Tale of Discreteness Noise, Runaway Instabilities, and Artificial Disruption
- Lensing is Low: Cosmology, Galaxy Formation, or New Physics?
- A 2.5% measurement of the growth rate from small-scale redshift space clustering of SDSS-III CMASS galaxies
- Understanding higher-order nonlocal halo bias at large scales by combining the power spectrum with the bispectrum
- Mapping stellar content to dark matter halos using galaxy clustering and galaxy-galaxy lensing in the SDSS DR7
- Introducing Decorated HODs: modeling assembly bias in the galaxy-halo connection
- Subhalo abundance matching and assembly bias in the EAGLE simulation
- The galaxy-halo connection from a joint lensing, clustering and abundance analysis in the CFHTLenS/VIPERS field
- The Weak Lensing Signal and the Clustering of BOSS Galaxies II: Astrophysical and Cosmological Constraints
- The origin of scatter in the stellar mass - halo mass relation of central galaxies in the EAGLE simulation
- The Aemulus Project I: Numerical Simulations for Precision Cosmology
- The Impact of Assembly Bias on the Galaxy Content of Dark Matter Halos
- Mapping stellar content to dark matter halos. II. Halo mass is the main driver of galaxy quenching
- The Concentration Dependence of the Galaxy-Halo Connection: Modeling Assembly Bias with Abundance Matching
- Beyond Assembly Bias: Exploring Secondary Halo Biases for Cluster-size Haloes
- Redshift-Space Clustering of SDSS Galaxies --- Luminosity Dependence, Halo Occupation Distribution, and Velocity Bias
- Evidence for a change in the dominant satellite galaxy quenching mechanism at z=1
- Halo assembly bias and the tidal anisotropy of the local halo environment
- Beyond Halo Mass: Galactic Conformity as a Smoking Gun of Central Galaxy Assembly Bias
- The impact of assembly bias on the halo occupation in hydrodynamical simulations
- On the Level of Cluster Assembly Bias in SDSS
- Accounting for baryonic effects in cosmic shear tomography: Determining a minimal set of nuisance parameters using PCA
- Modelling galaxy clustering: halo occupation distribution versus subhalo matching
- On Detecting Halo Assembly Bias with Galaxy Populations
- Assessing Colour-dependent Occupation Statistics Inferred from Galaxy Group Catalogues
- Revealing the galaxy-halo connection in IllustrisTNG
- The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: modeling of the luminosity and colour dependence in the Data Release 10
- Consistent lensing and clustering in a low- Universe with BOSS, DES Year 3, HSC Year 1 and KiDS-1000
- Constraints on Assembly Bias from Galaxy Clustering
- The GOGREEN Survey: A deep stellar mass function of cluster galaxies at 1.0<z<1.4 and the complex nature of satellite quenching
- Connecting massive galaxies to dark matter halos in BOSS - I. Is galaxy color a stochastic process in high-mass halos?
- Coming of Age in the Dark Sector: How Dark Matter Haloes grow their Gravitational Potential Wells
- Dissecting and Modelling Galaxy Assembly Bias
- Log-normal star formation histories in simulated and observed galaxies
- The tidal evolution of dark matter substructure -- II. The impact of artificial disruption on subhalo mass functions and radial profiles
- The Evolution of Assembly Bias
- Probing the galaxy-halo connection in UltraVISTA to
- Cosmic web anisotropy is the primary indicator of halo assembly bias
- Dissecting the Evolution of Dark Matter Subhaloes in the Bolshoi Simulation
- On the Physical Origin of Galactic Conformity
- The GOGREEN survey: The environmental dependence of the star-forming galaxy main sequence at
- Five-percent measurements of the growth rate from simulation-based modelling of redshift-space clustering in BOSS LOWZ
- Statistics of Dark Matter Substructure: III. Halo-to-Halo Variance
- Correlating galaxy colour and halo concentration: A tunable Halo Model of galactic conformity
- Evidence for galaxy assembly bias in BOSS CMASS redshift-space galaxy correlation function
- Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA): halo formation times and halo assembly bias on the cosmic web
- The Galaxy Clustering Crisis in Abundance Matching
- Large-scale assembly bias of dark matter halos
- Accurate and Efficient Halo-based Galaxy Clustering Modelling with Simulations
- Predicting Galaxy Star Formation Rates via the Co-evolution of Galaxies and Halos
- Emulating galaxy clustering and galaxy-galaxy lensing into the deeply nonlinear regime: methodology, information, and forecasts
- Constraining the HI-Halo Mass Relation From Galaxy Clustering
- The Scale-Dependence of Halo Assembly Bias
- Mapping stellar content to dark matter halos - III.Environmental dependence and conformity of galaxy colours
- Weak Lensing Reveals a Tight Connection Between Dark Matter Halo Mass and the Distribution of Stellar Mass in Massive Galaxies
- Caught in the cosmic web: Environmental effect on halo concentrations, shape, and spin
- A KiDS weak lensing analysis of assembly bias in GAMA galaxy groups
- Modeling Galactic Conformity with the Color-Halo Age Relation in the Illustris Simulation
- Exploring the squeezed three-point galaxy correlation function with generalized halo occupation distribution models
- The manifestation of secondary halo bias on the galaxy population from IllustrisTNG300
- Modelling The Redshift-Space Three-Point Correlation Function in SDSS-III
- Dark Matter Halo Models of Stellar Mass-Dependent Galaxy Clustering in PRIMUS+DEEP2 at 0.2<z<1.2
- The origin of the enhanced metallicity of satellite galaxies
- Stellar Property Statistics of Massive Halos from Cosmological Hydrodynamics Simulations: Common Kernel Shapes
- The Immitigable Nature of Assembly Bias: The Impact of Halo Definition on Assembly Bias
- The effects of assembly bias on cosmological inference from galaxy-galaxy lensing and galaxy clusters
- Baryons in the CosmicWeb of IllustrisTNG -- II: the Connection among Galaxies, Halos, their Formation Time and their Location in the Cosmic Web
- How Do Galaxies trace a large scale structure?: A case study around a massive protocluster at
- Illustrating galaxy-halo connection in the DESI era with IllustrisTNG
- New perspectives on the BOSS small-scale lensing discrepancy for the Planck CDM Cosmology
- Halo Histories vs. Galaxy Properties at z=0, I: The Quenching of Star Formation
- The Completed SDSS-IV Extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: N-body Mock Challenge for Galaxy Clustering Measurements
- Updated Results on the Galaxy-Halo Connection from Satellite Kinematics in SDSS
- Voronoi volume function: A new probe of cosmology and galaxy evolution
- Do model emission line galaxies live in filaments at z~1?
- Detection of anisotropic galaxy assembly bias in BOSS DR12
- Physical Correlations of the Scatter between Galaxy Mass, Stellar Content, and Halo Mass
- Quenching and morphological evolution due to circumgalactic gas expulsion in a simulated galaxy with a controlled assembly history
- A Statistical Semi-Empirical Model: Satellite galaxies in Groups and Clusters
- Constraints on from a full-scale and full-shape analysis of redshift-space clustering and galaxy-galaxy lensing in BOSS
- Cosmology with Stacked Cluster Weak Lensing and Cluster-Galaxy Cross-Correlations
- Testing the Accuracy of Halo Occupation Distribution Modelling using Hydrodynamic Simulations
- How are galaxies assigned to halos? Searching for assembly bias in the SDSS galaxy clustering
- The Conditional Colour-Magnitude Distribution: I. A Comprehensive Model of the Colour-Magnitude-Halo Mass Distribution of Present-Day Galaxies
- Accelerated galaxy growth and environmental quenching in a protocluster at z=3.24
- Probing Galaxy Assembly Bias in BOSS Galaxies Using Void Probabilities
- Void Galaxies Follow a Distinct Evolutionary Path in the Environmental COntext Catalog
- Galaxy assembly bias of central galaxies in the Illustris simulation
- Towards Accurate Modelling of Galaxy Clustering on Small Scales: Testing the Standard + Halo Model
- Extensions to the halo occupation distribution model for more accurate clustering predictions
- Cosmological Evidence Modelling: a new simulation-based approach to constrain cosmology on non-linear scales
- Deviations from tidal torque theory: evolution of the halo spin-filament alignment
- Dependence of Halo Bias and Kinematics on Assembly Variables
- The physical origins of low-mass spin bias
- How to Optimally Constrain Galaxy Assembly Bias: Supplement Projected Correlation Functions with Count-in-cells Statistics
- Brightest galaxies as halo centre tracers in SDSS DR7
- What determines large scale galaxy clustering: halo mass or local density?
- Revealing the cosmic web dependent halo bias
- The cosmological dependence of halo and galaxy assembly bias
- Halo assembly bias from Separate Universe simulations
- On the prospect of using the maximum circular velocity of halos to encapsulate assembly bias in the galaxy-halo connection
- The impact of baryonic physics on the abundance, clustering, and concentration of halos
- Can Assembly Bias Explain the Lensing Amplitude of the BOSS CMASS Sample in a Planck Cosmology?
- Probing galaxy assembly bias with LRG weak lensing observations
- Responses of Halo Occupation Distributions: a new ingredient in the halo model & the impact on galaxy bias
- The Galaxy-Halo Connection for as revealed by the \emph{Spitzer} Matching survey of the UltraVISTA ultra-deep Stripes
- Diffstar: A Fully Parametric Physical Model for Galaxy Assembly History
- Non-thermal radio supernova remnants of exiled Wolf-Rayet stars
- Evidence of Galaxy Assembly Bias in SDSS DR7 Galaxy Samples from Count Statistics
- Construct the emission line galaxy-host halo connection through auto and cross correlations
- Don't Forget the Forest for the Trees: The Stellar-Mass Halo-Mass Relation in Different Environments
- The Aemulus Project VI: Emulation of beyond-standard galaxy clustering statistics to improve cosmological constraints
- The Effects of Galaxy Assembly Bias on the Inference of Growth Rate from Redshift-Space Distortions
- Photometric Objects around Cosmic Webs (PAC) Delineated in a Spectroscopic Survey. I. Methods
- Multi-wavelength mock galaxy catalogs of the low-redshift Universe
- The galaxy correlation function as a constraint on galaxy formation physics
- A new method to measure galaxy bias by combining the density and weak lensing fields
- Maturing Satellite Kinematics into a Competitive Probe of the Galaxy-Halo Connection
- On the Clustering of Faint Red Galaxies
- Modeling Redshift-Space Clustering with Abundance Matching
- Connections between galaxy properties and halo formation time in the cosmic web
- The galaxy - halo connection in low mass halos
- The Effect of Assembly Bias on Redshift Space Distortions
- Using galaxy pairs to investigate the three-point correlation function in the squeezed limit
- Differentiable Predictions for Large Scale Structure with SHAMNet
- 2D k-th nearest neighbor statistics: a highly informative probe of galaxy clustering
- Late-formed halos prefer to host quiescent central galaxies. I. Observational results
- Impact of tidal environment on galaxy clustering in GAMA
- The Beyond-Halo Mass Effects of the Cosmic Web Environment on Galaxies
- Photometric Objects Around Cosmic Webs (PAC) Delineated in a Spectroscopic survey. II. Morphology, Color and Size Dependences of the Stellar-halo Mass Relation for Massive Galaxies
- Toward Accurate Modeling of Galaxy Clustering on Small Scales: Constraining the Galaxy-Halo Connection with Optimal Statistics
- Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA): Tracing galaxy environment using the marked correlation function
- BASILISK: Bayesian Hierarchical Inference of the Galaxy-Halo Connection using Satellite Kinematics--I. Method and Validation
- Using the Modified Nearest Neighbor Method to Correct Fiber-collision Effects on Galaxy Clustering
- Galaxy Halo Masses from Weak Gravitational Lensing
- A semi-analytic model of pairwise velocity distribution between dark matter halos
- On the origin of red spirals: Does assembly bias play a role?
- Using large galaxy surveys to distinguish z~0.5 quiescent galaxy models
- Global analysis of luminosity- and colour-dependent galaxy clustering in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- Toward Accurate Modeling of Galaxy Clustering on Small Scales: Halo Model Extensions and Lingering Tension
- A New Stellar Mass Proxy for Subhalo Abundance Matching
- Comparing Galaxy Clustering in Horizon-AGN Simulated Lightcone Mocks and VIDEO Observations
- Galaxy assembly bias in the stellar-to-halo mass relation for red central galaxies from SDSS
- Multi-wavelength consensus of large-scale linear bias
- Tests of Acoustic Scale Shifts in Halo-based Mock Galaxy Catalogues
- A sparse regression approach to modeling the relation between galaxy stellar masses and their host halos
- On the Constraints of Galaxy Assembly Bias in Velocity Space
- Evaluating the origins of the secondary bias based on the correlation of halo properties with the linear density field
- Unraveling emission line galaxy conformity at z~1 with DESI early data
- Scaling of the 1-halo terms with bias
- Modeling Strong Lenses from Wide-Field Ground-Based Observations in KiDS and GAMA
- How do uncertainties in galaxy formation physics impact field-level galaxy bias?
- Conditional Colour-Magnitude Distribution of Central Galaxies in Galaxy Formation Models
- An Improved and Physically-Motivated Scheme for Matching Galaxies with Dark Matter Halos
- The SRG/eROSITA All-Sky Survey: Exploring halo assembly bias with X-ray selected superclusters
- The Dependence of Dark Matter Halo Properties on the Morphology of Their Central Galaxies from Weak Lensing
- Scatter in the star formation rate-halo mass relation: secondary bias and its impact on line-intensity mapping
- Inferring Host Dark Matter Halo Masses of Individual Galaxies from Neighboring Galaxy Counts
- ACACIA: a new method to produce on-the-fly merger trees in the RAMSES code
- The Outskirt Stellar Mass of Low-Redshift Massive Galaxies is an Excellent Halo Mass Proxy in Illustris/IllustrisTNG Simulations
- A sparse regression approach for populating dark matter halos and subhalos with galaxies
- Assembly bias in quadratic bias parameters of dark matter halos from forward modeling
- SHAM-OT: Rapid Subhalo Abundance Matching with Optimal Transport
- A New Wavelet Scattering Transform-Based Statistic for Cosmological Analysis of Large-Scale Structure
- The invariance of group occupation across the cosmic web
- One Galaxy Sample to Rule Them All: Halo Occupation Distribution Modeling of DES Year 3 Source Galaxies
- On the Assembly Bias of Cool Core Clusters Traced by H Nebulae
- Predicting halo occupation and galaxy assembly bias with machine learning
- On the dependence of galaxy assembly bias on the selection criteria, number density, and redshift of galaxy samples
- Correlation between Outlying Halo Abundance and Host Halo Properties
- Imprints of tidal interactions on the stellar distribution of satellite galaxies: implications for dark matter deficient galaxies
- A Non-parametric Method for the Inference of Halo Occupation Distributions
- Testing subhalo abundance matching with galaxy kinematics
- Joint Optical-HI mock catalogues and prospects for upcoming HI surveys
- SDSS-IV MaNGA: How the stellar populations of passive central galaxies depend on stellar and halo mass