On Poincaré gauge theory of gravity, its equations of motion, and Gravity Probe B
arXiv:1304.2769 · doi:10.1016/j.physleta.2013.04.055
Abstract
Ever since E.Cartan in the 1920s enriched the geometric framework of general relativity (GR) by introducing a {\it torsion} of spacetime, the question arose whether one could find a measurement technique for detecting the presence of a torsion field. Mao et al.(2007) claimed that the rotating quartz balls in the gyroscopes of the Gravity Probe B experiment, falling freely on an orbit around the Earth, should "feel" the torsion. Similarly, March et al.(2011) argue with the precession of the Moon and the Mercury and extend later their considerations to the Lageos satellite.--- A consistent theory of gravity with torsion emerged during the early 1960's as gauge theory of the Poincaré group. This Poincaré gauge theory of gravity incorporates as simplest viable cases the Einstein-Cartan(-Sciama-Kibble) theory (EC), the teleparallel equivalent GR|| of GR, and GR itself. So far, PG and, in particular, the existence of torsion have {\it not} been experimentally confirmed. However, PG is to be considered as the standard theory of gravity with torsion because of its very convincing gauge structure.--- Since the early 1970s up to today, different groups have shown more or less independently that torsion couples only to the {\it elementary particle spin} and under no circumstances to the orbital angular momentum of test particles. This is established knowledge and we reconfirm this conclusion by discussing the energy-momentum law of PG, which has same form for all versions of PG. Therefore, we conclude that, unfortunately, the investigations of Mao et al. and March et al. do not yield any information on torsion.
arXiv comment7 pages of latex with 2 figures, title changed, minor corrections inserted, some references added
References in corpus (21)
- Unified cosmic history in modified gravity: from F(R) theory to Lorentz non-invariant models
- Metric-Affine Gauge Theory of Gravity: Field Equations, Noether Identities, World Spinors, and Breaking of Dilation Invariance
- Gravity Probe B: Final Results of a Space Experiment to Test General Relativity
- Extra force in modified theories of gravity
- Physical Aspects of the Space-Time Torsion
- The teleparallel equivalent of general relativity
- Covariant conservation of energy momentum in modified gravities
- Constraints on Torsion from Lorentz Violation
- Beyond Einstein-Cartan gravity: Quadratic torsion and curvature invariants with even and odd parity including all boundary terms
- Constraints on Space-Time Torsion from Hughes-Drever Experiments
- Searches for the role of spin and polarization in gravity
- Constraining Torsion with Gravity Probe B
- Covariant equations of motion for test bodies in gravitational theories with general nonminimal coupling
- Can Gravity Probe B usefully constrain torsion gravity theories?
- Conservation laws in gravitational theories with general nonminimal coupling
- Constraining spacetime torsion with the Moon and Mercury
- Probing non-Riemannian spacetime geometry
- Propagation equations for deformable test bodies with microstructure in extended theories of gravity
- Constraining spacetime torsion with LAGEOS
- Universality Principle for Orbital Angular Momentum and Spin in Gravity with Torsion
- Interaction of the 4-rotational gauge field with orbital momentum, gravidiamagnetic effect, and orbit experiment "Gravity Probe B"
Cited by in corpus (60)
- Friedmann-like universes with torsion
- Spin-torsion coupling and gravitational moments of Dirac fermions: theory and experimental bounds
- A First Experimental Limit on In-matter Torsion from Neutron Spin Rotation in Liquid He-4
- Equations of motion in gravity theories with nonminimal coupling: a loophole to detect torsion macroscopically?
- Big Bounce cosmology for Palatini gravity with a Nieh-Yan term
- The Raychaudhuri equation in spacetimes with torsion and non-metricity
- Revisiting the Stability of Quadratic Poincaré Gauge Gravity
- Observational Constraints in Metric-Affine Gravity
- Manifestations of the rotation and gravity of the Earth in high-energy physics experiments
- Prospects of detecting spacetime torsion
- Scalar modes in extended hybrid metric-Palatini gravity: weak field phenomenology
- Equations of motion in metric-affine gravity: A covariant unified framework
- Acceleration in Friedmann cosmology with torsion
- Constraining Spacetime Nonmetricity with Neutron Spin Rotation in Liquid He-4
- Cosmological inflation driven by a scalar torsion function
- Weitzenböck's Torsion, Fermi Coordinates and Adapted Frames
- Multipolar test body equations of motion in generalized gravity theories
- Why has spacetime torsion such negligible effect on our universe?
- Birkhoff's theorem for stable torsion theories
- Demystifying autoparallels in alternative gravity
- Raychaudhuri and optical equations for null geodesic congruences with torsion
- Late-time acceleration and inflation in a Poincaré gauge cosmological model
- Stability in quadratic torsion theories
- Invariant conserved currents in generalized gravity
- Covariant Equations of Motion of Extended Bodies with Arbitrary Mass and Spin Multipoles
- New symmetry properties of pointlike scalar and Dirac particles
- Gauge Theory of Gravity and Spacetime
- Singularities and n-dimensional black holes in torsion theories
- Cosmological signature change in Cartan Gravity with dynamical symmetry breaking
- Paths to gravitation via the gauging of parameterized field theories
- Spacetime, Spin and Gravity Probe B
- Conservation of energy-momentum of matter as the basis for the gauge theory of gravitation
- Dynamical suppression of spacetime torsion
- Fermion dynamics in torsion theories
- Quantization of Einstein-Cartan theory in the first order form
- Spinning and Spinning Deviation Equations for Special Types of Gauge Theories of Gravity
- Low-Redshift Constraints on Covariant Canonical Gauge Theory of Gravity
- A first-order approach to conformal gravity
- (3+1)-Formulation for Gravity with Torsion and Non-Metricity II: The Hypermomentum Equation
- Revisiting Friedmann-like cosmology with torsion: newest constraints from high-redshift observations
- Non-geodesic incompleteness in Poincaré gauge gravity
- Signature of Einstein-Cartan theory
- Deviation equation in Riemann-Cartan spacetime
- Cosmological Dark Matter Amplification through Dark Torsion
- Torsion or not torsion, that is the question
- Mimetic-Metric-Torsion with induced Axial mode and Phantom barrier crossing
- Cosmological Dark sector from a Mimetic-Metric-Torsion perspective
- Einstein-Cartan-Dirac equations in the Newman-Penrose formalism
- Gravity: a gauge theory perspective
- A possible correspondence between Ricci identities and Dirac equations in the Newman-Penrose formalism: towards an understanding of gravity induced collapse of the wave-function?
- Measuring the gravitational field in General Relativity: From deviation equations and the gravitational compass to relativistic clock gradiometry
- Search for manifestations of spin-torsion coupling
- Quantum hydrodynamics of spinning particles in electromagnetic and torsion fields
- Symmetries and conserved quantities with arbitrary torsion: A generalization of Killing's theorem
- On the real representations of the Poincare group
- The Role of Torsion in Trans-Planckian Physics
- A black hole solution of higher-dimensional Weyl-Yang-Kaluza-Klein theory
- Effects of curvature and gravity from flat spacetime
- New effective theories of gravitation and their phenomenological consequences
- Gauge gravitation theory in Riemann-Cartan space-time and the nonsingular Universe