Can Gravity Probe B usefully constrain torsion gravity theories?

Abstract

In most theories of gravity involving torsion, the source for torsion is the intrinsic spin of matter. Since the spins of fermions are normally randomly oriented in macroscopic bodies, the torsion generated is normally negligible. However, in a recent paper, Mao et al. point out that there is a class of theories in which the angular momentum of macroscopic spinning bodies generates a significant amount of torsion. They argue that by the principle of action equals reaction, one would expect the angular momentum of test bodies to couple to a background torsion field, and therefore the precession of the GPB gyroscopes should be affected in these theories by the torsion generated by the Earth. We show that in fact the principle of action equals reaction does not apply to these theories. We examine in detail a generalization of the Hayashi-Shirafuji theory suggested by Mao et al. called Einstein-Hayashi-Shirafuji theory. There are a variety of different versions of this theory, depending on the precise form of the coupling to matter chosen for the torsion. We show that for any coupling to matter that is compatible with the spin transport equation postulated by Mao et al., the theory has either ghosts or an ill-posed initial value formulation. These theoretical problems can be avoided by specializing the parameters of the theory and in addition choosing the standard minimal coupling to matter of the torsion tensor. This yields a consistent theory, but one in which the action equals reaction principle is violated, and in which the angular momentum of the gyroscopes does not couple to the Earth's torsion field. Thus, the Einstein-Hayashi-Shirafuji theory does not predict a detectable torsion signal for Gravity Probe B. There may be other torsion theories which do.

13 pages, a small change to the terminology

References in corpus (17)

• The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
• Physical Aspects of the Space-Time Torsion
• Metric-affine approach to teleparallel gravity
• Nonsymmetric Gravity Theories: Inconsistencies and a Cure
• Consequences of Propagating Torsion in Connection-Dynamic Theories of Gravity
• Metric-Affine Gauge Theory of Gravity I. Fundamental Structure and Field Equations
• Hamiltonian structure of the teleparallel formulation of GR
• Lessons of spin and torsion: Reply to ``Consistent coupling to Dirac fields in teleparallelism"
• Using Early Data to Illuminate the Pioneer Anomaly
• Gauge symmetries of the teleparallel theory of gravity
• Dirac spinor fields in the teleparallel gravity: comment on "Metric-affine approach to teleparallel gravity"
• Universality Principle for Orbital Angular Momentum and Spin in Gravity with Torsion
• On the teleparallel limit of Poincare gauge theory
• Autoparallels From a New Action Principle
• Torsion and Gravitation: A new view
• Tensor-Scalar Torsion
• One-parameter teleparallel limit of Poincare gravity

Cited by in corpus (45)

• Modified Gravity Theories on a Nutshell: Inflation, Bounce and Late-time Evolution
• Dark energy cosmology: the equivalent description via different theoretical models and cosmography tests
• Einstein's Other Gravity and the Acceleration of the Universe
• f(T) Gravity and local Lorentz invariance
• Equation of state for dark energy in $f(T)$ gravity
• Reconstruction of $f(T)$ gravity: Rip cosmology, finite-time future singularities and thermodynamics
• Growth factor in f(T) gravity
• Thermodynamics of cosmological horizons in $f(T)$ gravity
• Notes on $f(T)$ Theories
• Bouncing Loop Quantum Cosmology from $F(T)$ gravity
• Bounce inflation in $f(T)$ Cosmology: A unified inflaton-quintessence field
• Searches for the role of spin and polarization in gravity
• Constraining Torsion with Gravity Probe B
• Future singularities and Teleparallelism in Loop Quantum Cosmology
• Some aspects of generalized modified gravity models
• A spherically-symmetric charged-dS solution in f(T) gravity theories
• Einstein Static Universe in Exponential $f(T)$ Gravity
• On Poincaré gauge theory of gravity, its equations of motion, and Gravity Probe B
• Cosmographic reconstruction of $f(\mathcal{T})$ cosmology
• Interacting Dark Energy in f(T) cosmology : A Dynamical System analysis
• A First Experimental Limit on In-matter Torsion from Neutron Spin Rotation in Liquid He-4
• Constraining spacetime torsion with the Moon and Mercury
• Probing non-Riemannian spacetime geometry
• Non-singular models of universes in teleparallel theories
• Constraining spacetime torsion with LAGEOS
• Thermodynamic properties of modified gravity theories
• Parametrized Post-Newtonian Limit of Teleparallel Dark Energy Model
• On the Viability of the Intermediate Inflation Scenario with $F(T)$ Gravity
• Constraining Spacetime Nonmetricity with Neutron Spin Rotation in Liquid He-4
• Bounce Models within Teleparallel modified gravity
• On Reconstruction of Extended Teleparallel Gravity from the Cosmological Jerk Parameter
• Generation of large-scale magnetic fields from inflation in teleparallelism
• Phase Space description of Nonlocal Teleparallel Gravity
• Noether symmetry in a nonlocal f(T) Gravity
• Covariant Equations of Motion of Extended Bodies with Arbitrary Mass and Spin Multipoles
• Invariant conserved currents in generalized gravity
• Interacting Quintessence in a New Scalar-Torsion Gravity
• Spacetime, Spin and Gravity Probe B
• Constraining Torsion in Maximally symmetric (sub)spaces
• Effect of Torsion on Neutron Star Structure in Einstein-Cartan Gravity
• Signature of Einstein-Cartan theory
• Mimetic-Metric-Torsion with induced Axial mode and Phantom barrier crossing
• Cosmological Dark sector from a Mimetic-Metric-Torsion perspective
• Cosmological Issues in $F(T)$ Gravity Theory
• Interference effects and modified Born rule in the presence of torsion