On the Statistical Significance of the Bulk Flow Measured by the PLANCK Satellite
arXiv:1303.6614 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201321579
Abstract
A recent analysis of data collected by the Planck satellite detected a net dipole at the location of X-ray selected galaxy clusters, corresponding to a large-scale bulk flow extending at least to , the median redshift of the cluster sample. The amplitude of this flow, as measured with Planck, is consistent with earlier findings based on data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP). However, the uncertainty assigned to the dipole by the Planck team is much larger than that found in the WMAP studies, leading the authors of the Planck study to conclude that the observed bulk flow is not statistically significant. We here show that two of the three implementations of random sampling used in the error analysis of the Planck study lead to systematic overestimates in the uncertainty of the measured dipole. Random simulations of the sky do not take into account that the actual realization of the sky leads to filtered data that have a 12% lower root-mean-square dispersion than the average simulation. Using rotations around the Galactic pole (the Z axis), increases the uncertainty of the X and Y components of the dipole and artificially reduces the significance of the dipole detection from 98-99% to less than 90% confidence. When either effect is taken into account, the corrected errors agree with those obtained using random distributions of clusters on Planck data, and the resulting statistical significance of the dipole measured by Planck is consistent with that of the WMAP results.
arXiv commentA & A, in press
References in corpus (14)
- HEALPix -- a Framework for High Resolution Discretization, and Fast Analysis of Data Distributed on the Sphere
- The MCXC: a Meta-Catalogue of X-ray detected Clusters of galaxies
- A measurement of large-scale peculiar velocities of clusters of galaxies: results and cosmological implications
- A new measurement of the bulk flow of X-ray luminous clusters of galaxies
- A measurement of large-scale peculiar velocities of clusters of galaxies: technical details
- Measuring the dark flow with public X-ray cluster data
- Measuring the Galaxy Cluster Bulk Flow from WMAP data
- Measurement of the electron-pressure profile of galaxy clusters in Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) 3-year data
- Measuring cosmological bulk flows via the kinematic Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect in the upcoming cosmic microwave background maps
- First measurement of the bulk flow of nearby galaxies using the cosmic microwave background
- The Statistical Significance of the "Dark Flow"
- One Thousand and One Clusters: Measuring the Bulk Flow with the Planck ESZ and X-Ray Selected Galaxy Cluster Catalogs
- The error budget of the Dark Flow measurement
- Anomalous anisotropic cross-correlations between WMAP CMB maps and SDSS galaxy distribution and implications on the dark flow scenario
Cited by in corpus (17)
- Planck 2018 results. I. Overview and the cosmological legacy of Planck
- The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
- Is the Observable Universe Consistent with the Cosmological Principle?
- Measuring cosmic bulk flows with Type Ia Supernovae from the Nearby Supernova Factory
- Hubble flow variance and the cosmic rest frame
- Probing the Dark Flow signal in WMAP 9 yr and PLANCK cosmic microwave background maps
- Differential cosmic expansion and the Hubble flow anisotropy
- Anisotropy of the galaxy cluster X-ray luminosity-temperature relation
- The deceleration parameter in `tilted' Friedmann universes
- The peculiar Raychaudhuri equation
- Constraints on Pre-inflation Fluctuations in a Nearly Flat Open ΛCDM Cosmology
- Detectability of Cosmic Dark Flow in the Type Ia Supernova Redshift-Distance Relation
- Probing the rest-frame of the Universe with near-IR cosmic infrared background
- Modelling spatial variations of the speed of light
- Dark Energy or local acceleration?
- Constraints on the birth of the universe and origin of cosmic dark flow
- Expected redshift drift for tilted observers