Fixing the EW scale in supersymmetric models after the Higgs discovery
arXiv:1302.5262 · doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2013.07.024
Abstract
TeV-scale supersymmetry was originally introduced to solve the hierarchy problem and therefore fix the electroweak (EW) scale in the presence of quantum corrections. Numerical methods testing the SUSY models often report a good likelihood L (or chi^2=-2ln L) to fit the data {\it including} the EW scale itself (m_Z^0) with a {\it simultaneously} large fine-tuning i.e. a large variation of this scale under a small variation of the SUSY parameters. We argue that this is inconsistent and we identify the origin of this problem. Our claim is that the likelihood (or chi^2) to fit the data that is usually reported in such models does not account for the chi^2 cost of fixing the EW scale. When this constraint is implemented, the likelihood (or chi^2) receives a significant correction (delta_chi^2) that worsens the current data fits of SUSY models. We estimate this correction for the models: constrained MSSM (CMSSM), models with non-universal gaugino masses (NUGM) or higgs soft masses (NUHM1, NUHM2), the NMSSM and the general NMSSM (GNMSSM). For a higgs mass m_h\approx 126 GeV, one finds that in these models (delta_chi^2)/ndf> 1.5 (approx 1 for GNMSSM), which violates the usual condition of a good fit (total chi^2/ndf approx 1) already before fitting observables other than the EW scale itself (ndf=number of degrees of freedom). This has (negative) implications for SUSY models and it is suggested that future data fits properly account for this effect, if one remains true to the original goal of SUSY. Since the expression of delta_chi^2 that emerges from our calculation depends on a familiar measure of fine-tuning, one concludes that EW fine-tuning is an intrinsic part of the likelihood to fit the data that includes the EW scale (m_Z^0).
arXiv comment18 pages; (v4: added text in Conclusions)
References in corpus (48)
- Observation of a new particle in the search for the Standard Model Higgs boson with the ATLAS detector at the LHC
- Observation of a new boson at a mass of 125 GeV with the CMS experiment at the LHC
- Towards High-Precision Predictions for the MSSM Higgs Sector
- SOFTSUSY: a program for calculating supersymmetric spectra
- Higgs boson mass and new physics
- Conformal Symmetry and the Standard Model
- From Linear SUSY to Constrained Superfields
- Quantum scale invariance, cosmological constant and hierarchy problem
- The Higgs Mass Bound in Gauge Extensions of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model
- MSSM Higgs Physics at Higher Orders
- Constrained MSSM favoring new territories: The impact of new LHC limits and a 125 GeV Higgs boson
- Effective Action, Conformal Anomaly and the Issue of Quadratic Divergences
- Fitting the Phenomenological MSSM
- The fine-tuning of the generalised NMSSM
- Naturalness Priors and Fits to the Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model
- Natural Priors, CMSSM Fits and LHC Weather Forecasts
- Constrained Supersymmetry after two years of LHC data: a global view with Fittino
- Naturalness bounds on gauge mediated soft terms
- Naturalness and Focus Points with Non-Universal Gaugino Masses
- The Supersymmetric Parameter Space in Light of B-physics Observables and Electroweak Precision Data
- The generalised NMSSM at one loop: fine tuning and phenomenology
- Updated global fits of the cMSSM including the latest LHC SUSY and Higgs searches and XENON100 data
- Fine tuning as an indication of physics beyond the MSSM
- Bayesian approach and Naturalness in MSSM analyses for the LHC
- The Constrained NMSSM with a 126 GeV Higgs boson: A global analysis
- Non-linear MSSM
- Global fits of the cMSSM including the first LHC and XENON100 data
- MSSM with Dimension-five Operators (MSSM_5)
- MSSM Higgs with dimension-six operators
- Testing SUSY at the LHC: Electroweak and Dark matter fine tuning at two-loop order
- Quantified naturalness from Bayesian statistics
- Should we still believe in constrained supersymmetry?
- The fine-tuning cost of the likelihood in SUSY models
- Supersymmetric Higgs Bosons and Beyond
- Tuning supersymmetric models at the LHC: A comparative analysis at two-loop level
- Beyond the MSSM Higgs with d=6 effective operators
- MSSM Forecast for the LHC
- The MSSM Higgs Sector with a Dynamical Goldstino Supermultiplet
- On non-universal Goldstino couplings to matter
- Testing SUSY
- Goldstino and sgoldstino in microscopic models and the constrained superfields formalism
- BMSSM Higgs Bosons at the Tevatron and the LHC
- Low-scale SUSY breaking and the (s)goldstino physics
- A review of naturalness and dark matter prediction for the Higgs mass in MSSM and beyond
- General NMSSM signatures at the LHC
- BMSSM Higgs Bosons at the 7 TeV LHC
- Naturalness of supersymmetric models
- Superevolution
Cited by in corpus (13)
- Non-universal gaugino masses and fine tuning implications for SUSY searches in the MSSM and the GNMSSM
- Implications of the Higgs discovery for the MSSM
- Generalized Soft Breaking Leverage for the MSSM
- Probing Non-holomorphic MSSM via precision constraints, dark matter and LHC data
- Stop on Top: SUSY Parameter Regions, Fine-Tuning Constraints
- Quantum implications of a scale invariant regularisation
- Exploring Non-Holomorphic Soft Terms in the Framework of Gauge Mediated Supersymmetry Breaking
- Quasi Yukawa Unification and Fine-Tuning in U(1) Extended SSM
- Naturalness in low-scale SUSY models and "non-linear" MSSM
- Sbottoms as probes to MSSM with nonholomorphic soft interactions
- Dominant production of heavier Higgs bosons through vector boson fusion in NMSSM
- SUSY naturalness without prejudice
- Off-Shell Supersymmetry