Comparison of free energy estimators and their dependence on dissipated work

Abstract

The estimate of free energy changes based on Bennett's acceptance ratio method is examined in several limiting cases and compared with other estimates based on the Jarzynski equality and on the Crooks relation. While the absolute amount of dissipated work, defined as the surplus of average work over the free energy difference, limits the practical applicability of Jarzynski's and Crooks' methods, the reliability of Bennett's approach is restricted by the difference of the dissipated works in the forward and the backward process. We illustrate these points by considering a Gaussian chain and a hairpin chain which both are extended during the forward and accordingly compressed during the backward protocol. The reliability of the Crooks relation predominantly depends on the sample size; for the Jarzynski estimator the slowness of the work protocol is crucial, and the Bennett method is shown to give precise estimates irrespective of the pulling speed and sample size as long as the dissipated works are the same for the forward and the backward process as it is the case for Gaussian work distributions. With an increasing dissipated work difference the Bennett estimator also acquires a bias which increases roughly in proportion to this difference. A substantial simplification of the Bennett estimator is provided by the 1/2-formula which expresses the free energy difference by the algebraic average of the Jarzynski estimates for the forward and the backward processes. It agrees with the Bennett estimate in all cases when the Jarzynski and the Crooks estimates fail to give reliable results.

References in corpus (6)

• Rare events and the convergence of exponentially averaged work values
• Experimental Free Energy Surface Reconstruction From Single-Molecule Force Spectroscopy Using Jarzynski's Equality
• Comparison of free energy methods for molecular systems
• The length of time's arrow
• Improving free-energy estimates from unidirectional work measurements: theory and experiment
• Fluctuation, Dissipation and the Arrow of Time

Cited by in corpus (20)

• {\it Colloquium:} Statistical Mechanics and Thermodynamics at Strong Coupling: Quantum and Classical
• Direct measurement of nonequilibrium system entropy is consistent with Gibbs-Shannon form
• Convergence of large deviation estimators
• Steps minimize dissipation in rapidly driven stochastic systems
• Number of trials required to estimate a free-energy difference, using fluctuation relations
• Skewed Thermodynamic Geometry and Optimal Free Energy Estimation
• Stochastic thermodynamics of fluctuating density fields: Non-equilibrium free energy differences under coarse-graining
• Multidimensional minimum-work control of a 2D Ising model
• Lennard-Jones systems near solid walls: Computing interfacial free energies from molecular simulation methods
• Quantum Work Fluctuations in connection with Jarzynski Equality
• Comment on "Measurability of nonequilibrium thermodynamics in terms of the Hamiltonian of mean force"
• Merits and Qualms of Work Fluctuations in Classical Fluctuation Theorems
• Statistics of work performed by optical tweezers with general time-variation of their stiffness
• Convergence of the Integral Fluctuation Theorem estimator for nonequilibrium Markov systems
• Work, work fluctuations, and the work distribution in a thermal non-equilibrium steady state
• Nonequilibrium free energy estimation conditioned on measurement outcomes
• Connections between efficient control and spontaneous transitions in an Ising model
• Work probability distribution for a ferromagnet with long-ranged and short-ranged correlations
• Non-Uniform Convergence in Moment Expansions of Integral Work Relations
• Work fluctuation theorems and free energy from kinetic theory