If no information gain implies no disturbance, then any discrete physical theory is classical

Abstract

It has been suggested that nature could be discrete in the sense that the underlying state space of a physical system has only a finite number of pure states. For example, the Bloch ball of a single qubit could be discretized into small patches and only appear round to us due to experimental limitations. Here, we present a strong physical argument for the quantum theoretical property that every state space (even the smallest possible one, the qubit) has infinitely many pure states. We propose a simple physical postulate which dictates that in fact the only possible discrete theory is classical mechanics. More specifically, we postulate that no information gain implies no disturbance, or read in the contrapositive, that disturbance leads to some form of information gain. In a theory like quantum mechanics where we already know that the converse holds, i.e. information gain does imply disturbance, this can be understood as postulating an equivalence between disturbance and information gain. What is more, we show that non-classical discrete theories are still ruled out even if we relax the postulate to hold only approximately in the sense that no information gain only causes a small amount of disturbance. Finally, our postulate also rules out popular generalizations such as the PR-box that allows non-local correlations beyond the limits of quantum theory.

11+19 pages, 8+11 figures. Minor fix to the formulation of Lemma 2(b). No results changed

References in corpus (8)

• Coding Theorem and Strong Converse for Quantum Channels
• The uncertainty principle determines the non-locality of quantum mechanics
• A derivation of quantum theory from physical requirements
• Translation of Lueders' "Uber die Zustandsanderung durch den Messprozess"
• Discreteness and the origin of probability in quantum mechanics
• Ordered linear spaces and categories as frameworks for information-processing characterizations of quantum and classical theory
• One simple postulate implies that every polytopic state space is classical
• Teleportation in General Probabilistic Theories

Cited by in corpus (28)

• Generalized Probability Theories: What determines the structure of quantum theory?
• General probabilistic theories: An introduction
• Maximal incompatibility of locally classical behavior and global causal order in multi-party scenarios
• Quantum Correlations are Tightly Bound by the Exclusivity Principle
• Ultimate data hiding in quantum mechanics and beyond
• Understanding nature from experimental observations: a theory independent test for gravitational decoherence
• Toolbox for reconstructing quantum theory from rules on information acquisition
• Thermodynamics and the structure of quantum theory
• Ruling out higher-order interference from purity principles
• Dimension of physical systems, information processing, and thermodynamics
• Bridging the gap between general probabilistic theories and the device-independent framework for nonlocality and contextuality
• Incompatible quantum measurements admitting a local hidden variable model
• Perfect signaling among three parties violating predefined causal order
• Classical theories with entanglement
• Classicality without local discriminability: decoupling entanglement and complementarity
• Non-classical correlations in quantum mechanics and beyond
• Bounds on the power of proofs and advice in general physical theories
• No-free-information principle in general probabilistic theories
• Derivation of Quantum Theory from Feynman's Rules
• The principle of information symmetry constrains the state-space in any physical theory
• Information and disturbance in operational probabilistic theories
• Information-theoretic foundations of thermodynamics in general probabilistic theories
• Shut up and let me think. Or why you should work on the foundations of quantum mechanics as much as you please
• Hierarchical axioms for quantum mechanics
• Recommender systems inspired by the structure of quantum theory
• A Post-Quantum Associative Memory
• Complete extension: the non-signaling analog of quantum purification
• Intermediate determinism in general probabilistic theories