Ruling out higher-order interference from purity principles
arXiv:1704.05106 · doi:10.3390/e19060253
Abstract
As first noted by Rafael Sorkin, there is a limit to quantum interference. The interference pattern formed in a multi-slit experiment is a function of the interference patterns formed between pairs of slits, there are no genuinely new features resulting from considering three slits instead of two. Sorkin has introduced a hierarchy of mathematically conceivable higher-order interference behaviours, where classical theory lies at the first level of this hierarchy and quantum theory theory at the second. Informally, the order in this hierarchy corresponds to the number of slits on which the interference pattern has an irreducible dependence. Many authors have wondered why quantum interference is limited to the second level of this hierarchy. Does the existence of higher-order interference violate some natural physical principle that we believe should be fundamental? In the current work we show that such principles can be found which limit interference behaviour to second-order, or "quantum-like", interference, but that do not restrict us to the entire quantum formalism. We work within the operational framework of generalised probabilistic theories, and prove that any theory satisfying Causality, Purity Preservation, Pure Sharpness, and Purification---four principles that formalise the fundamental character of purity in nature---exhibits at most second-order interference. Hence these theories are, at least conceptually, very "close" to quantum theory. Along the way we show that systems in such theories correspond to Euclidean Jordan algebras. Hence, they are self-dual and, moreover, multi-slit experiments in such theories are described by pure projectors.
arXiv comment18+8 pages. Comments welcome. v2: Minor correction to Lemma 5.1, main results are unchanged
References in corpus (54)
- Informational derivation of Quantum Theory
- From Classical to Quantum Shannon Theory
- Quantum Theory From Five Reasonable Axioms
- Probabilistic theories with purification
- Quantum Mechanics as Quantum Measure Theory
- The resource theory of informational nonequilibrium in thermodynamics
- A derivation of quantum theory from physical requirements
- A generalized no-broadcasting theorem
- Ruling Out Multi-Order Interference in Quantum Mechanics
- Reversible transformations from pure to mixed states, and the unique measure of information
- Quantum from principles
- Introduction to the book "Quantum Theory: Informational Foundations and Foils"
- Quasi-quantization: classical statistical theories with an epistemic restriction
- The completeness of quantum theory for predicting measurement outcomes
- Quantum Picturalism
- Higher-order interference and single-system postulates characterizing quantum theory
- Reformulating and Reconstructing Quantum Theory
- The structure of reversible computation determines the self-duality of quantum theory
- Three Slit Experiments and the Structure of Quantum Theory
- Density cubes and higher-order interference theories
- Generalised phase kick-back: the structure of computational algorithms from physical principles
- On the superposition principle in interference experiments
- The Feynman problem and Fermionic entanglement: Fermionic theory versus qubit theory
- Obtaining tight bounds on higher-order interferences with a 5-path interferometer
- Entanglement and thermodynamics in general probabilistic theories
- Three path interference using nuclear magnetic resonance: a test of the consistency of Born's rule
- Higher-order interference in extensions of quantum theory
- Fermionic computation is non-local tomographic and violates monogamy of entanglement
- If no information gain implies no disturbance, then any discrete physical theory is classical
- Deriving Grover's lower bound from simple physical principles
- Computation in generalised probabilistic theories
- The computational landscape of general physical theories
- Thermodynamics and the structure of quantum theory
- Dilation of states and processes in operational-probabilistic theories
- Experimental Test of Born's Rule by Inspecting Third-Order Quantum Interference on a Single Spin in Solids
- Bridging the gap between general probabilistic theories and the device-independent framework for nonlocality and contextuality
- Terminality implies non-signalling
- Microcanonical thermodynamics in general physical theories
- Operational axioms for diagonalizing states
- Measurement sharpness cuts nonlocality and contextuality in every physical theory
- Entropy, majorization and thermodynamics in general probabilistic theories
- Unifying typical entanglement and coin tossing: on randomization in probabilistic theories
- Three-slit experiments and quantum nonlocality
- Conditional probability, three-slit experiments, and the Jordan algebra structure of quantum mechanics
- Leaks: quantum, classical, intermediate, and more
- Bounds on the power of proofs and advice in general physical theories
- Quantum Protocols within Spekkens' Toy Model
- Two Roads to Classicality
- Entanglement as an axiomatic foundation for statistical mechanics
- The Information Content of Systems in General Physical Theories
- Conservation of information and the foundations of quantum mechanics
- On the ongoing experiments looking for higher-order interference: What are they really testing?
- A no-go theorem for theories that decohere to quantum mechanics
- Process-theoretic characterisation of the Hermitian adjoint
Cited by in corpus (27)
- General probabilistic theories: An introduction
- A no-go theorem on the nature of the gravitational field beyond quantum theory
- Reconstructing quantum theory from diagrammatic postulates
- Microcanonical thermodynamics in general physical theories
- Accessible fragments of generalized probabilistic theories, cone equivalence, and applications to witnessing nonclassicality
- Quantum computation is the unique reversible circuit model for which bits are balls
- Simple proof of the impossibility of bit-commitment in generalised probabilistic theories using cone programming
- On defining the Hamiltonian beyond quantum theory
- Strongly symmetric spectral convex bodies are Jordan algebra state spaces
- Maximum Entropy and Sufficiency
- Divergence and Sufficiency for Convex Optimization
- Information-theoretic foundations of thermodynamics in general probabilistic theories
- Pseudo standard entanglement structure cannot be distinguished from standard entanglement structure
- How dynamics constrains probabilities in general probabilistic theories
- A simple and quantum-mechanically motivated characterization of the formally real Jordan algebras
- Interference as an information-theoretic game
- Device-independent certification of non-classical joint measurements via causal models
- An atomic test of higher-order interference
- A no-go theorem for theories that decohere to quantum mechanics
- Simulating all multipartite non-signalling channels via quasiprobabilistic mixtures of local channels in generalised probabilistic theories
- Paradoxical consequences of multipath coherence: perfect interaction-free measurements
- Density Hypercubes, Higher Order Interference and Hyper-Decoherence: a Categorical Approach
- Computation in a general physical setting
- Local tomography and the role of the complex numbers in quantum mechanics
- Complete extension: the non-signaling analog of quantum purification
- Quantum Theory from Principles, Quantum Software from Diagrams
- Information-theoretic derivation of energy, speed bounds, and quantum theory