Shut up and let me think. Or why you should work on the foundations of quantum mechanics as much as you please
arXiv:1308.5619
Abstract
If you have a restless intellect, it is very likely that you have played at some point with the idea of investigating the meaning and conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics. It is also probable (albeit not certain) that your intentions have been stopped on their tracks by an encounter with some version of the "Shut up and calculate" command. You may have heard that everything is already understood. That understanding is not your job. Or, if it is, it is either impossible or very difficult. Maybe somebody explained to you that physics is concerned with "hows" and not with "whys"; that whys are the business of "philosophy" ---you know, that dirty word. That what you call "understanding" is just being Newtonian; which of course you cannot ask quantum mechanics to be. Perhaps they also added some norms: The important thing a theory must do is predict; a theory must only talk about measurable quantities. It may also be the case that you almost asked "OK, and why is that?", but you finally bit your tongue. If you persisted in your intentions and the debate got a little heated up, it is even possible that it was suggested that you suffered of some type of moral or epistemic weakness that tend to disappear as you grow up. Maybe you received some job advice such as "Don't work in that if you ever want to own a house". I have certainly met all these objections in my short career, and I think that they are all just wrong. In this somewhat personal document, I try to defend that making sense of quantum mechanics is an exciting, challenging, important and open scientific endeavor. I do this by compulsively quoting Feynman (and others), and I provide some arguments that you might want to use the next time you confront the mentioned "opinions". By analogy with the anti-rationalistic Copenhagen command, all the arguments are subsumed in a standard answer to it: "Shut up and let me think"
arXiv commentAdded footnote in p. 2, two paragraphs at the end of sec. 2.1 and some names in the acknowledgements, corrected some typos, added a mention to collapse models
References in corpus (11)
- Models of Wave-function Collapse, Underlying Theories, and Experimental Tests
- Hidden Variables and the Two Theorems of John Bell
- On the reality of the quantum state
- Understanding quantum measurement from the solution of dynamical models
- Is a system's wave function in one-to-one correspondence with its elements of reality?
- Quantum discord cannot be shared
- On Quantum Theory
- Why Physics Needs Quantum Foundations
- If no information gain implies no disturbance, then any discrete physical theory is classical
- Why decoherence solves the measurement problem
- Measurement: still a problem in standard quantum theory