A Comparative Study of Local Galaxy Clusters: I. Derived X-ray Observables
arXiv:1204.6301 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stt2091
Abstract
We examine systematic differences in the derived X-ray properties of galaxy clusters as reported by three different groups: Vikhlinin et al. (2009a), Mantz et al. (2010b), and Planck Collaboration (2011b). The sample overlap between any two pairs of works ranges between 16 to 28 galaxy clusters in common. We find systematic differences in most reported properties, including the total cluster mass, M500. The most extreme case is an average 45% \pm 5% difference in cluster mass between the Planck Collaboration (2011b) and Mantz et al. (2010b), for clusters at z > 0.13 (averaged over 16 clusters). These mass differences induce differences in cluster observables defined within an R500 aperture. After accounting for aperture differences, we find very good agreement in gas mass estimates between the different groups. However, the soft-band X-ray luminosity, LX, core-excised spectroscopic temperature, TX, and gas thermal energy, YX = MgasTX display mean differences at the 5%-15% level. We also find that the low (z \leq 0.13) and high (z \geq 0.13) galaxy cluster samples in Planck Collaboration (2011b) appear to be systematically different: the YSZ/YX ratio for these two sub- samples is ln(YSZ/YX) = -0.06 \pm 0.04 and ln(YSZ/YX) = 0.08 \pm 0.04 for the low and high redshift sub-samples respectively.
arXiv commentfeedback welcome
References in corpus (48)
- Chandra sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters: mass, gas fraction, and mass-temperature relation
- The Mass Function of an X-Ray Flux-Limited Sample of Galaxy Clusters
- Chandra Cluster Cosmology Project III: Cosmological Parameter Constraints
- The universal galaxy cluster pressure profile from a representative sample of nearby systems (REXCESS) and the Y_SZ-M_500 relation
- Chandra Cluster Cosmology Project II: Samples and X-ray Data Reduction
- Effects of Galaxy Formation on Thermodynamics of the Intracluster Medium
- Galaxy cluster X-ray luminosity scaling relations from a representative local sample (REXCESS)
- The ROSAT-ESO Flux Limited X-ray (REFLEX) Galaxy Cluster Survey. V. The cluster catalogue
- Improved constraints on dark energy from Chandra X-ray observations of the largest relaxed galaxy clusters
- A MaxBCG Catalog of 13,823 Galaxy Clusters from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- The MCXC: a Meta-Catalogue of X-ray detected Clusters of galaxies
- Chandra temperature profiles for a sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters
- Comparing the temperatures of galaxy clusters from hydro-N-body simulations to Chandra and XMM-Newton observations
- Comparing the temperatures of galaxy clusters from hydro-N-body simulations to Chandra and XMM-Newton observations
- Planck Early Results VIII: The all-sky Early Sunyaev-Zeldovich cluster sample
- A moving cold front in the intergalactic medium of A3667
- The Observed Growth of Massive Galaxy Clusters I: Statistical Methods and Cosmological Constraints
- Weighing simulated galaxy clusters using lensing and X-ray
- The Observed Growth of Massive Galaxy Clusters II: X-ray Scaling Relations
- Catalog Extraction in SZ Cluster Surveys: a matched filter approach
- Temperature profiles of a representative sample of nearby X-ray galaxy clusters
- The structural and scaling properties of nearby galaxy clusters: I - The universal mass profile
- The X-ray brightest clusters of galaxies from the Massive Cluster Survey
- Planck Early Results XI: Calibration of the local galaxy cluster Sunyaev-Zeldovich scaling relations
- The mass profile of A1413 observed with XMM-Newton: implications for the M-T relation
- Robust Optical Richness Estimation with Reduced Scatter
- Four Measures of the Intracluster Medium Temperature and Their Relation to a Cluster's Dynamical State
- Massive Halos in Millennium Gas Simulations: Multivariate Scaling Relations
- CLASH: Precise New Constraints on the Mass Profile of Abell 2261
- The X-ray Cluster Normalization of the Matter Power Spectrum
- Predicting Single-Temperature Fit to Multi-Component Thermal Plasma Spectra
- Planck early results: Cluster Sunyaev-Zeldovich optical scaling relations
- Cross-calibration of the X-ray Instruments onboard the Chandra, INTEGRAL, RXTE, Suzaku, Swift, and XMM-Newton Observatories using G21.5-0.9
- Cross-calibrating X-ray detectors with clusters of galaxies: an IACHEC study
- X-ray mass proxies from hydrodynamic simulations of galaxy clusters (paper I)
- Baryon Content of Massive Galaxy Clusters at z=0-0.6
- The XMM Cluster Survey: X-ray analysis methodology
- Substructure in the cold front cluster Abell 3667
- Precision cosmology with a wide area XMM cluster survey
- Bandpass Dependence of X-ray Temperatures in Galaxy Clusters
- Subaru weak-lensing study of A2163: bimodal mass structure
- A2163: Merger events in the hottest Abell galaxy cluster I. Dynamical analysis from optical data
- The complex velocity distribution of galaxies in Abell 1689: implications for mass modelling
- SPITZER observations of Abell 1763. III. The infrared luminosity function in different supercluster environments
- A2163: Merger events in the hottest Abell galaxy cluster II. Subcluster accretion with galaxy-gas separation
- The Ysz--Yx Scaling Relation as Determined from Planck and Chandra
- Gas temperature profiles in galaxy clusters with Swift XRT: observations and capabilities to map near R200
- Comparison of XMM-Newton EPIC, Chandra ACIS-S3, ASCA SIS and GIS, and ROSAT PSPC Results for G21.5-0.9, 1E0102.2-7219, and MS1-54.4-0321
Cited by in corpus (41)
- Observational Probes of Cosmic Acceleration
- Planck 2013 results. XX. Cosmology from Sunyaev-Zeldovich cluster counts
- Planck 2015 results. XXIV. Cosmology from Sunyaev-Zeldovich cluster counts
- Robust Weak-lensing Mass Calibration of Planck Galaxy Clusters
- redMaPPer II: X-ray and SZ Performance Benchmarks for the SDSS Catalog
- Weighing the Giants V: Galaxy Cluster Scaling Relations
- Growth of Cosmic Structure: Probing Dark Energy Beyond Expansion
- The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Signs of neutrino mass in current cosmological datasets
- The XXL Survey. XIII. Baryon content of the bright cluster sample
- Neutrinos help reconcile Planck measurements with both Early and Local Universe
- redMaPPer III: A Detailed Comparison of the Planck 2013 and SDSS DR8 RedMaPPer Cluster Catalogs
- Comparing Masses in Literature (CoMaLit)-I. Bias and scatter in weak lensing and X-ray mass estimates of clusters
- The XXL Survey XXV. Cosmological analysis of the C1 cluster number counts
- CoMaLit III. Literature Catalogs of weak Lensing Clusters of galaxies (LC^2)
- A Model for Multi-property Galaxy Cluster Statistics
- Chemical Evolution on the Scale of Clusters of Galaxies: A Conundrum?
- Planck Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Cluster Mass Calibration using Hyper Suprime-Cam Weak Lensing
- Calibrating the Planck Cluster Mass Scale with CLASH
- The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Dynamical masses for 44 SZ-selected galaxy clusters over 755 square degrees
- Galaxy Cluster Scaling Relations between Bolocam Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect and Chandra X-ray Measurements
- The XXL Survey: XVII. X-ray and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Properties of the Redshift 2.0 Galaxy Cluster XLSSC 122
- Orientation Bias of Optically Selected Galaxy Clusters and Its Impact on Stacked Weak Lensing Analyses
- The 400d Galaxy Cluster Survey weak lensing programme: III: Evidence for consistent WL and X-ray masses at
- CoMaLit - II. The scaling relation between mass and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich signal for Planck selected galaxy clusters
- Hydrostatic and Caustic Mass Profiles of Galaxy Clusters
- The relation between mass and concentration in X-ray galaxy clusters at high redshift
- Rhapsody-G simulations: galaxy clusters as baryonic closed boxes and the covariance between hot gas and galaxies
- Constraining the Mass-Richness Relationship of redMaPPer Clusters with Angular Clustering
- Cosmological Constraints from the Large Scale Weak Lensing of SDSS MaxBCG Clusters
- Reconciling Planck cluster counts and cosmology? Chandra/XMM instrumental calibration and hydrostatic mass bias
- Linking a universal gas density profile to the core-excised X-ray luminosity in galaxy clusters up to z ~ 1.1
- Optical-SZE Scaling Relations for DES Optically Selected Clusters within the SPT-SZ Survey
- Measuring using X-ray and SZ effect observations of dynamically relaxed galaxy clusters
- Weak lensing calibration of mass bias in the REFLEX+BCS X-ray galaxy cluster catalogue
- Comparing different mass estimators for a large subsample of the {\it Planck}-ESZ clusters
- Calibrating the Planck Cluster Mass Scale with Cluster Velocity Dispersions
- AMI observations of ten CLASH galaxy clusters: SZ and X-ray data used together to determine cluster dynamical states
- Galaxy cluster scaling relations measured with APEX-SZ
- Constraining Radio Mode Feedback in Galaxy Clusters with the Cluster Radio AGN Properties to z1
- Beyond Mass: Detecting Secondary Halo Properties with Galaxy-Galaxy Lensing
- The scaling relation and its difference between cool-core and non-cool-core clusters