Error estimates for solid-state density-functional theory predictions: an overview by means of the ground-state elemental crystals

Abstract

Predictions of observable properties by density-functional theory calculations (DFT) are used increasingly often in experimental condensed-matter physics and materials engineering as data. These predictions are used to analyze recent measurements, or to plan future experiments. Increasingly more experimental scientists in these fields therefore face the natural question: what is the expected error for such an ab initio prediction? Information and experience about this question is scattered over two decades of literature. The present review aims to summarize and quantify this implicit knowledge. This leads to a practical protocol that allows any scientist - experimental or theoretical - to determine justifiable error estimates for many basic property predictions, without having to perform additional DFT calculations. A central role is played by a large and diverse test set of crystalline solids, containing all ground-state elemental crystals (except most lanthanides). For several properties of each crystal, the difference between DFT results and experimental values is assessed. We discuss trends in these deviations and review explanations suggested in the literature. A prerequisite for such an error analysis is that different implementations of the same first-principles formalism provide the same predictions. Therefore, the reproducibility of predictions across several mainstream methods and codes is discussed too. A quality factor Delta expresses the spread in predictions from two distinct DFT implementations by a single number. To compare the PAW method to the highly accurate APW+lo approach, a code assessment of VASP and GPAW with respect to WIEN2k yields Delta values of 1.9 and 3.3 meV/atom, respectively. These differences are an order of magnitude smaller than the typical difference with experiment, and therefore predictions by APW+lo and PAW are for practical purposes identical.

27 pages, 20 figures, supplementary material available (v5 contains updated supplementary material)

References in corpus (8)

• A Higher-Accuracy van der Waals Density Functional
• Effect of van der Waals interactions on the structural and elastic properties of black phosphorus
• Theoretical investigation on the transition metal borides with Ta3B4-type structure: a class of hard and refractory materials
• Proving the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof density functional designed for metallic bulk and surface systems
• New Superconducting and Semiconducting Fe-B Compounds Predicted with an Ab Initio Evolutionary Search
• A Periodic Genetic Algorithm with Real-Space Representation for Crystal Structure and Polymorph Prediction
• Van der Waals interactions in the ground state of Mg(BH4)2 from density functional theory
• An Improved Real--Space Genetic Algorithm for Crystal Structure and Polymorph Prediction

Cited by in corpus (68)

• CP2K: An Electronic Structure and Molecular Dynamics Software Package -- Quickstep: Efficient and Accurate Electronic Structure Calculations
• The PseudoDojo: Training and grading a 85 element optimized norm-conserving pseudopotential table
• Two-dimensional materials from high-throughput computational exfoliation of experimentally known compounds
• Optimization Algorithm for the Generation of ONCV Pseudopotentials
• DP-GEN: A concurrent learning platform for the generation of reliable deep learning based potential energy models
• A Performance and Cost Assessment of Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials
• Precision and efficiency in solid-state pseudopotential calculations
• Data-driven materials science: status, challenges and perspectives
• The GW compendium: A practical guide to theoretical photoemission spectroscopy
• Machine Learning Energies of 2 M Elpasolite (ABC${}_2$D${}_6$) Crystals
• First-principles Green's-function method for surface calculations: a pseudopotential localized basis set approach
• Generation of Projector Augmented-Wave atomic data: a 71 elements validated table in the XML format
• Achieving DFT accuracy with a machine-learning interatomic potential: thermomechanics and defects in bcc ferromagnetic iron
• Rungs 1 to 4 of DFT Jacob's ladder: extensive test on the lattice constant, bulk modulus, and cohesive energy of solids
• 103-Compound Band Structure Benchmark of Post-SCF Spin-Orbit Coupling Treatments in Density-Functional Theory
• Confining Metal-Halide Perovskites in Nanoporous Thin Films
• RESCU: a Real Space Electronic Structure Method
• A New Generation of Effective Core Potentials for Correlated Calculations
• A critical study of the elastic properties and stability of Heusler compounds: Cubic Co${}_{2}YZ$ compounds with $L{2}_1$ structure
• Nonlocal van der Waals functionals for solids: Choosing an appropriate one
• How to verify the precision of density-functional-theory implementations via reproducible and universal workflows
• Assessing the SCAN functional for itinerant electron ferromagnets
• Simulating Quantum Materials with Digital Quantum Computers
• The PSML format and library for norm-conserving pseudopotential data curation and interoperability
• A critical review of statistical calibration/prediction models handling data inconsistency and model inadequacy
• Magnetocrystalline anisotropy of FePt: a detailed view
• Computing the Self-Consistent Field in Kohn-Sham Density Functional Theory
• Thermoelastic properties of $\alpha$-iron from first-principles
• Optimization and Validation of a Deep Learning CuZr Atomistic Potential: Robust Applications for Crystalline and Amorphous Phases with near-DFT Accuracy
• Screening nature of the van der Waals density functional method: A review and analysis of the many-body physics foundation
• The parameters uncertainty inflation fallacy
• Understanding the difference in cohesive energies between alpha and beta tin in DFT calculations
• Cohesive properties of noble metals by van der Waals-corrected Density Functional Theory
• Microhartree Precision in Density-Functional-Theory Calculations
• The long road to calibrated prediction uncertainty in computational chemistry
• ADAQ: Automatic workflows for magneto-optical properties of point defects in semiconductors
• Photorealistic modelling of metals from first principles
• Quantification of uncertainty in first-principles predicted mechanical properties of solids: Application to solid ion conductors
• Impact of non-normal error distributions on the benchmarking and ranking of Quantum Machine Learning models
• Auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo calculations with multiple-projector pseudopotentials
• Highly accurate local basis sets for large-scale DFT calculations in CONQUEST
• Test set for materials science and engineering with user-friendly graphic tools for error analysis: Systematic benchmark of the numerical and intrinsic errors in state-of-the-art electronic-structure approximations
• Probabilistic performance estimators for computational chemistry methods: Systematic Improvement Probability and Ranking Probability Matrix. I. Theory
• Orbital-free approximations to the kinetic-energy density in exchange-correlation MGGA functionals: tests on solids
• Non-linear elastic effects in phase field crystal and amplitude equations: Comparison to ab initio simulations of bcc metals and graphene
• Influence of relativistic effects on the contact formation of transition metals
• Modeling 1D structures on semiconductor surfaces: Synergy of theory and experiment
• Prediction of Large Magnetic Moment Materials With Graph Neural Networks and Random Forests
• Machine-learning correction to density-functional crystal structure optimization
• Hydrogen delaying the formation of Guinier-Preston zones in aluminium alloys
• Reproducibility of Hybrid Density Functional Calculations for Equation-of-State Properties and Band Gaps
• A posteriori error estimation for the non-self-consistent Kohn-Sham equations
• Uncertainty of DFT calculated mechanical and structural properties of solids due to incompatibility of pseudopotentials and exchange-correlation functionals
• The Equation of State of MH-III: a possible deep CH${}_4$ reservoir in Titan, Super-Titan exoplanets and moons
• Insights on unconventional superconductivity in HfV${}_2$Ga${}_4$ and ScV${}_2$Ga${}_4$ from first principles electronic structure calculations
• Generating and grading 34 Optimized Norm-Conserving Vanderbilt Pseudopotentials for Actinides and Super Heavy Elements in the PseudoDojo
• Pseudopotential Bethe-Salpeter calculations for shallow-core x-ray absorption near-edge structures: excitonic effects in Al2O3
• Quantum Computation of Electronic Structure with Projector Augmented-Wave Method and Plane Wave Basis Set
• Na Site Doping a Pathway for Enhanced Thermoelectric Performance in $N{a}_{1-x}Co{O}_2$; The Case of Gd and Yb Dopants
• Evolutionary optimization of PAW data-sets for accurate high pressure simulations
• Modeling Chemical Exfoliation of Non-van der Waals Chromium Sulfides by Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials and Monte Carlo Simulations
• Density-gradient-free variable in exchange-correlation functionals for detecting inhomogeneities in the electron density
• Study of electronic and magnetic properties and related x-ray absorption spectroscopy of ultrathin Co films on BaTiO${}_3$
• Reliable Density Functional Theory Predictions of Bandgaps for Materials
• Praseodymium doping effect on the superconducting properties of FeSe${}_{0.5}$Te${}_{0.5}$ bulks under ambient and high-pressure growth conditions
• Pressure-induced transitions in FePS${}_3$: Structural, magnetic and electronic properties
• Physical nature of quasi-stable structures existing in antimony melt
• Analytical PAW Projector Functions for Reduced Bandwidth Requirements