How students blend conceptual and formal mathematical reasoning in solving physics problems

Abstract

Current conceptions of expert problem solving depict physical/conceptual reasoning and formal mathematical reasoning as separate steps: a good problem solver first translates a physical Current conceptions of quantitative problem-solving expertise in physics incorporate conceptual reasoning in two ways: for selecting relevant equations (before manipulating them), and for checking whether a given quantitative solution is reasonable (after manipulating the equations). We make the case that problem-solving expertise should include opportunistically blending conceptual and formal mathematical reasoning even while manipulating equations. We present analysis of interviews with two students, Alex and Pat. Interviewed students were asked to explain a particular equation and solve a problem using that equation. Alex used and described the equation as a computational tool. By contrast, Pat found a shortcut to solve the problem. His shortcut blended mathematical operations with conceptual reasoning about physical processes, reflecting a view - expressed earlier in his explanation of the equation - that equations can express an overarching conceptual meaning. Using case studies of Alex and Pat, we argue that this opportunistic blending of conceptual and formal mathematical reasoning (i) is a part of problem-solving expertise, (ii) can be described in terms of cognitive elements called symbolic forms (Sherin, 2001), and (iii) is a feasible instructional target.

Pre-reviewed draft, now published in Science Education

References in corpus (1)

• Reinventing College Physics for Biologists: Explicating an epistemological curriculum

Cited by in corpus (9)

• Language of physics, language of math: Disciplinary culture and dynamic epistemology
• Students' epistemological framing in quantum mechanics problem solving
• Mathematical Sensemaking as Seeking Coherence between Calculations and Concepts: Instruction and Assessments for Introductory Physics
• The role of pedagogical tools in active learning: a case for sense-making
• Cognitive Framework for Blended Mathematical Sensemaking in Science
• Positive attitudinal shifts and a narrowing gender gap: Do expertlike attitudes correlate to higher learning gains for women in the physics classroom?
• Investigating the Design-Science Connection in a multi-week Engineering Design (ED)-based introductory physics laboratory task
• How Physics Textbooks Embed Meaning in the Equals Sign
• What does it mean to think like a physicist? Insights from physics graduate students