Lensed arc statistics: comparison of Millennium-simulation galaxy clusters to Hubble Space Telescope observations of an X-ray selected sample
arXiv:1101.4653 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.19293.x
Abstract
It has been debated for a decade whether there is a large overabundance of strongly lensed arcs in galaxy clusters, compared to expectations from LambdaCDM cosmology. We perform ray tracing through the most massive halos of the Millennium simulation at several redshifts in their evolution, using the Hubble Ultra Deep Field as a source image, to produce realistic simulated lensed images. We compare the lensed arc statistics measured from the simulations to those of a sample of 45 X-ray selected clusters, observed with the Hubble Space Telescope, that we have analysed in Horesh et al. (2010). The observations and the simulations are matched in cluster masses, redshifts, observational effects, and the algorithmic arc detection and selection. At z=0.6 there are too few massive-enough clusters in the Millennium volume for a proper statistical comparison with the observations. At redshifts 0.3<z<0.5, however, we have large numbers of simulated and observed clusters, and the latter are an unbiased selection from a complete sample. For these redshifts, we find excellent agreement between the observed and simulated arc statistics, in terms of the mean number of arcs per cluster, the distribution of number of arcs per cluster, and the angular separation distribution. At z ~ 0.2 some conflict remains, with real clusters being ~3 times more efficient arc producers than their simulated counterparts. This may arise due to selection biases in the observed subsample at this redshift, to some mismatch in masses between the observed and simulated clusters, or to physical effects that arise at low redshift and enhance the lensing efficiency, but which are not represented by the simulations.
arXiv comment10 pages, 8 figures, Accepted by MNRAS
References in corpus (53)
- First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters
- Simulating the joint evolution of quasars, galaxies and their large-scale distribution
- The broken hierarchy of galaxy formation
- The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: Spectra and redshifts
- The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Power Spectra and WMAP-Derived Parameters
- Concentrations of Dark Halos from their Assembly Histories
- The Hubble Deep Field: Observations, Data Reduction, and Galaxy Photometry
- Clustering of Galaxies in a Hierarchical Universe: I. Methods and Results at z=0
- Response of dark matter halos to condensation of baryons: cosmological simulations and improved adiabatic contraction model
- The Hubble Ultra Deep Field
- Tracing cosmic evolution with clusters of galaxies
- On the shape of the light profiles of early-type galaxies
- Properties of the X-ray brightest Abell-type clusters of galaxies (XBACs) from ROSAT All-Sky Survey data --- I. The sample
- MACS: A quest for the most massive galaxy clusters in the universe
- Galaxies in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: I. Detection, Multiband Photometry, Photometric Redshifts, and Morphology
- Early-type galaxies in the SDSS. II. Correlations between observables
- A complete sample of twelve very X-ray luminous galaxy clusters at z>0.5
- The Surprisingly Steep Mass Profile of Abell 1689, from a Lensing Analysis of Subaru Images
- Characterizing the Cluster Lens Population
- Deep optical galaxy counts with the Keck Telescope
- Strong lensing optical depths in a \LambdaCDM universe
- The Incidence of Strong-Lensing Clusters in the Red-Sequence Cluster Survey
- Simultaneous Falsification of LCDM and Quintessence with Massive, Distant Clusters
- Giant Arc Statistics In Concordance With A Concordance LCDM Universe
- Arc Statistics in Triaxial Dark Matter Halos: Testing the Collisionless Cold Dark Matter Paradigm
- The impact of cluster mergers on arc statistics
- Strong lensing optical depths in a LCDM universe II: the influence of the stellar mass in galaxies
- Shape, spin and baryon fraction of clusters in the MareNostrum Universe
- Statistics of Giant Arcs in Galaxy Clusters
- Strong lensing in the MareNostrum Universe: biases in the cluster lens population
- Effects of cluster galaxies on arc statistics
- The impact of gas physics on strong cluster lensing
- cD galaxy contribution to the strong lensing cross sections of galaxy clusters
- A search for gravitational lensing in 38 X-ray selected clusters of galaxies
- Arc sensitivity to cluster ellipticity, asymmetries and substructures
- Arcfinder: An algorithm for the automatic detection of gravitational arcs
- On the Incidence of Strong Gravitational Lensing by Clusters in the Las Campanas Distant Cluster Survey
- Halo and Galaxy Formation Histories from the Millennium Simulation: Public release of a VO-oriented and SQL-queryable database for studying the evolution of galaxies in the LambdaCDM cosmogony
- Gravitational Shear, Flexion and Strong Lensing in Abell 1689
- Gravitational lensing in a concordance LCDM universe: The importance of secondary matter along the line of sight
- The impact of AGN feedback and baryonic cooling on galaxy clusters as gravitational lenses
- Is the Number of Giant Arcs in LCDM Consistent With Observations?
- Non-parametric Reconstruction of Abell 2218 from Combined Weak and Strong Lensing
- The Lensed Arc Production Efficiency of Galaxy Clusters: A Comparison of Matched Observed and Simulated Samples
- The Redshift Distribution of Giant Arcs in the Sloan Giant Arcs Survey
- Cluster strong lensing in the Millennium Simulation: The effect of galaxies and structures along the line-of-sight
- The Impact of Baryonic Cooling on Giant Arc Abundances
- Arc Statistics in Clusters: Galaxy Contribution
- Strong lensing statistics and the power spectrum normalisation
- The effect of baryon cooling on the statistics of giant arcs and multiple quasars
- Strong lensing in the MareNostrum Universe II: scaling relations and optical depths
- Impacts of Source Properties on Strong Lensing by Rich Galaxy Clusters
Cited by in corpus (22)
- Observational Probes of Cosmic Acceleration
- Ancient Light from Young Cosmic Cities: Physical and Observational Signatures of Galaxy Proto-Clusters
- Arc Statistics
- The Universal Einstein Radius Distribution from 10,000 SDSS Clusters
- Line-of-Sight Structure Toward Strong Lensing Galaxy Clusters
- The Accuracy of Weak Lensing Simulations
- A Neural Network Gravitational Arc Finder based on the Mediatrix filamentation Method
- The science of short exposures: Hubble SNAPshot observations of massive galaxy clusters
- How Baryonic Processes affect Strong Lensing properties of Simulated Galaxy Clusters
- RELICS: A Strong Lens Model for SPT-CLJ0615-5746, a z=0.972 Cluster
- The Detection and Statistics of Giant Arcs Behind CLASH Clusters
- Triaxiality, principal axis orientation and non-thermal pressure in Abell 383
- Predicting the number of giant arcs expected in the next generation wide-field surveys from space
- EasyCritics I: Efficient detection of strongly-lensing galaxy groups and clusters in wide-field surveys
- The importance of secondary halos for strong lensing in massive galaxy clusters across redshift
- The SOAR Gravitational Arc Survey - I: Survey overview and photometric catalogs
- Detection of Strongly Lensed Arcs in Galaxy Clusters with Transformers
- Gravitational lensing effects on sub-millimetre galaxy counts
- On the accuracy of the Perturbative Approach for Strong Lensing: Local Distortion for Pseudo-Elliptical Models
- Simulation-based marginal likelihood for cluster strong lensing cosmology
- The strongest gravitational lenses: IV. The order statistics of the largest Einstein radii with cluster mergers
- Analytic Solutions for Navarro--Frenk--White Lens Models for Low Characteristic Convergences