Accuracy and Limitations of Fitting and Stereoscopic Methods to Determine the Direction of Coronal Mass Ejections from Heliospheric Imagers Observations

Abstract

Using data from the Heliospheric Imagers (HIs) onboard STEREO, it is possible to derive the direction of propagation of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) in addition to their speed with a variety of methods. For CMEs observed by both STEREO spacecraft, it is possible to derive their direction using simultaneous observations from the twin spacecraft and also, using observations from only one spacecraft with fitting methods. This makes it possible to test and compare different analyses techniques. In this article, we propose a new fitting method based on observations from one spacecraft, which we compare to the commonly used fitting method of Sheeley et al. (1999). We also compare the results from these two fitting methods with those from two stereoscopic methods, focusing on 12 CMEs observed simultaneously by the two STEREO spacecraft in 2008 and 2009. We find evidence that the fitting method of Sheeley et al. (1999) can result in significant errors in the determination of the CME direction when the CME propagates outside of 60deg \pm 20 deg from the Sun-spacecraft line. We expect our new fitting method to be better adapted to the analysis of halo or limb CMEs with respect to the observing spacecraft. We also find some evidence that direct triangulation in the HI fields-of-view should only be applied to CMEs propagating approximatively towards Earth (\pm 20deg from the Sun-Earth line). Last, we address one of the possible sources of errors of fitting methods: the assumption of radial propagation. Using stereoscopic methods, we find that at least seven of the 12 studied CMEs had an heliospheric deflection of less than 20deg as they propagated in the HI fields-of-view, which, we believe, validates this approximation.

17 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables, accepted to Solar Physics

References in corpus (5)

• Three-Dimensional MHD Simulation of the 2003 October 28 Coronal Mass Ejection: Comparison with LASCO Coronagraph Observations
• Determining the azimuthal properties of coronal mass ejections from multi-spacecraft remote-sensing observations with stereo secchi
• Solar-Terrestrial Simulation in the STEREO Era: The January 24-25, 2007 Eruptions
• The Brightness of Density Structures at Large Solar Elongation Angles: What is Being Observed by STEREO/SECCHI?
• Reconstructing the 3-D Trajectories of CMEs in the Inner Heliosphere

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Strong coronal channelling and interplanetary evolution of a solar storm up to Earth and Mars
• Connecting speeds, directions and arrival times of 22 coronal mass ejections from the Sun to 1 AU
• Deflected propagation of a coronal mass ejection from the corona to interplanetary space
• Super-elastic Collision of Large-scale Magnetized Plasmoids in The Heliosphere
• Investigating plasma motion of magnetic clouds at 1 AU through a velocity-modified cylindrical force-free flux rope model
• In Situ Properties of Small and Large Flux Ropes in the Solar Wind
• Assessing the collision nature of coronal mass ejections in the inner heliosphere
• Effect of Solar Wind Drag on the Determination of the Properties of Coronal Mass Ejections from Heliospheric Images
• Observational Tracking of the 2D Structure of Coronal Mass Ejections Between the Sun and 1 AU
• Interplanetary and Geomagnetic Consequences of Interacting CMEs of 13-14 June 2012
• Propagation of Coronal Mass Ejections from the Sun to Earth
• Why are ELEvoHI CME arrival predictions different if based on STEREO-A or STEREO-B heliospheric imager observations?
• Drag-based CME modeling with heliospheric images incorporating frontal deformation: ELEvoHI 2.0
• Predicting the Time-of-Arrival of Coronal Mass Ejections at Earth From Heliospheric Imaging Observations
• Assessing the Constrained Harmonic Mean Method for Deriving the Kinematics of ICMEs with a Numerical Simulation
• Predicting CMEs using ELEvoHI with STEREO-HI beacon data
• Magnetic interaction analysis of multiple interplanetary coronal mass ejections leading to a historic geomagnetic storm in May 2024
• Earth-affecting Solar Transients: A Review of Progresses in Solar Cycle 24
• Heliospheric tracking of enhanced density structures of the 6 October 2010 CME