A Radio Census of Binary Supermassive Black Holes

Abstract

Using archival VLBI data for 3114 radio-luminous active galactic nuclei, we searched for binary supermassive black holes using a radio spectral index mapping technique which targets spatially resolved, double radio-emitting nuclei. Only one source was detected as a double nucleus. This result is compared with a cosmological merger rate model and interpreted in terms of (1) implications for post-merger timescales for centralisation of the two black holes, (2) implications for the possibility of "stalled" systems, and (3) the relationship of radio activity in nuclei to mergers. Our analysis suggests that the binary evolution of paired supermassive black holes (both of masses >= 1e8 Msun) spends less than 500 Myr in progression from the merging of galactic stellar cores to within the purported stalling radius for supermassive black hole pairs. The data show no evidence for an excess of stalled binary systems at small separations. We see circumstantial evidence that the relative state of radio emission between paired supermassive black holes is correlated within orbital separations of 2.5 kpc.

11 Pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (17)

• The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
• The stochastic gravitational-wave background from massive black hole binary systems: implications for observations with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• A Compact Supermassive Binary Black Hole System
• MOJAVE: Monitoring of Jets in AGN with VLBA Experiments. V. Multi-epoch VLBA Images
• Radio sources in the 6dFGS: Local luminosity functions at 1.4 GHz for star-forming galaxies and radio-loud AGN
• Upper bounds on the low-frequency stochastic gravitational wave background from pulsar timing observations: current limits and future prospects
• Gravitational waves from resolvable massive black hole binary systems and observations with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Ejection of Supermassive Black Holes from Galaxy Cores
• A Candidate Sub-Parsec Supermassive Binary Black Hole System
• The Sixth VLBA Calibrator Survey: VCS6
• The Fifth VLBA Calibrator Survey: VCS5
• The Millennium Galaxy Catalogue: The connection between close pairs and asymmetry; implications for the galaxy merger rate
• The Micro-Arcsecond Scintillation-Induced Variability (MASIV) Survey II: The First Four Epochs
• Quasar Clustering at $25\kpch$ from a Complete Sample of Binaries
• A Multi-epoch VLBI Survey of the Kinematics of Caltech-Jodrell Bank Flat-Spectrum Sources, Part II: Analysis of the Kinematics
• The peculiar optical spectrum of 4C+22.25: Imprint of a massive black hole binary?
• Nature of X-shaped sources

Cited by in corpus (91)

• The NANOGrav 15-year Data Set: Constraints on Supermassive Black Hole Binaries from the Gravitational Wave Background
• The Astrophysics of Nanohertz Gravitational Waves
• The Quest for Dual and Binary Supermassive Black Holes: A Multi-Messenger View
• Massive Black Hole Binary Mergers in Dynamical Galactic Environments
• Gravitational wave astronomy of single sources with a pulsar timing array
• Massive black hole binaries: dynamical evolution and observational signatures
• A close-pair binary in a distant triple supermassive black-hole system
• Electromagnetic Counterparts to Massive Black Hole Mergers
• Dynamical friction and the evolution of Supermassive Black hole Binaries: the final hundred-parsec problem
• Super-massive binary black holes and emission lines in active galactic nuclei
• Chandra X-ray and Hubble Space Telescope Imaging of Optically Selected kiloparsec-Scale Binary Active Galactic Nuclei I. Nature of the Nuclear Ionizing Sources
• A Kiloparsec-Scale Binary Active Galactic Nucleus Confirmed by the Expanded Very Large Array
• Constraining the Orbit of Supermassive Black Hole Binary 0402+379
• Constraining Sub-Parsec Binary Supermassive Black Holes in Quasars with Multi-Epoch Spectroscopy. II. The Population with Kinematically Offset Broad Balmer Emission Lines
• Depleted cores, multi-component fits, and structural parameter relations for luminous early-type galaxies
• Constraining Sub-Parsec Binary Supermassive Black Holes in Quasars with Multi-Epoch Spectroscopy. III. Candidates from Continued Radial Velocity Tests
• Broadband Observations of the Compton-thick Nucleus of NGC 3393
• On the origin of X-shaped radio galaxies
• Investigation of Dual Active Nuclei, Outflows, Shock-Heated Gas, and Young Star Clusters in Markarian 266
• Constraints On The Dynamical Environments Of Supermassive Black-hole Binaries Using Pulsar-timing Arrays
• Varstrometry for Off-nucleus and Dual sub-Kpc AGN (VODKA): Methodology and Initial Results with Gaia DR2
• Varstrometry for Off-nucleus and Dual sub-Kpc AGN (VODKA): Hubble Space Telescope Discovers Double Quasars
• Compact Symmetric Objects and Supermassive Binary Black Holes in the VLBA Imaging and Polarimetry Survey
• mJIVE-20: a survey for compact mJy radio objects with the Very Long Baseline Array
• Candidate Periodically Variable Quasars from the Dark Energy Survey and the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Overmassive black holes in the $M_{\mathrm{BH}}-\sigma$ diagram do not belong to over (dry) merged galaxies
• Searching for Binary Supermassive Black Holes via Variable Broad Emission Line Shifts: Low Binary Fraction
• Constraints on Black Hole/Host Galaxy Co-evolution and Binary Stalling Using Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Periodic structure in the Mpc-scale jet of PKS 0637-752
• UGC 4211: A Confirmed Dual Active Galactic Nucleus in the Local Universe at 230 pc Nuclear Separation
• Repeated Imaging of Massive Black Hole Binary Orbits with Millimeter Interferometry: measuring black hole masses and the Hubble constant
• Catching butterflies in the sky: Extended catalog of winged or X-shaped radio sources from the latest FIRST data release
• Multi-messenger approaches to binary supermassive black holes in the "continuous-wave" regime
• Constraints on the Nature of CID-42: Recoil Kick or Supermassive Black Hole Pair?
• A Second Look at 12 Candidate Dual AGNs using $\mathtt{BAYMAX}$
• Supermassive Black Hole Binaries: The Search Continues
• Very High Angular Resolution Science with the Square Kilometre Array
• Two in one? A possible dual radio-emitting nucleus in the quasar SDSS J1425+3231
• Evidence from the Very Long Baseline Array that J1502SE/SW are Double Hotspots, not a Supermassive Binary Black Hole
• VLBI studies of DAGN and SMBHB hosting galaxies
• The radio core of the Ultraluminous Infrared Galaxy F00183-7111: watching the birth of a quasar
• Spatially-Offset AGN Candidates in the CLASS Survey
• VLBI Imaging of the Double Peaked Emission Line Seyfert KISSR1494
• Subaru Adaptive-optics High-spatial-resolution Infrared K- and L'-band Imaging Search for Deeply Buried Dual AGNs in Merging Galaxies
• A Bayesian Analysis of SDSS J0914+0853, a Low-Mass Dual AGN Candidate
• Four dual AGN candidates observed with the VLBA
• Binary black holes in nuclei of extragalactic radio sources
• Blindly Detecting Merging Supermassive Black Holes with Radio Surveys
• A candidate supermassive binary black hole system in the brightest cluster galaxy of RBS 797
• The radio structure of 3C 316, a galaxy with double-peaked narrow optical emission lines
• The X-ray view of optically selected dual AGN
• SMILE: Search for MIlli-LEnses
• Blindly detecting orbital modulations of jets from merging supermassive black holes
• Likelihood for Detection of Sub-parsec Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Spectroscopic Surveys
• Spectral Energy Distributions of Candidate Periodically-Variable Quasars: Testing the Binary Black Hole Hypothesis
• A possible sub-kiloparsec dual AGN buried behind the galaxy curtain
• Variation of Broad Emission Lines from QSOs with Optical/UV Periodicity to Test the Interpretation of Supermassive Binary Black Holes
• The Role of AGN in Luminous Infrared Galaxies from the Multiwavelength Perspective
• The Search for Binary Supermassive Black Holes Amongst Quasars with Offset Broad Lines Using the Very Long Baseline Array
• Compact object mergers: Observations of supermassive binary black holes and stellar tidal disruption events
• The Detectability of Kiloparsec Scale Dual AGNs: The Impact of Galactic Structure and Black Hole Orbital Properties
• Multifrequency JVLA observations of the X-shaped radio galaxy in Abell 3670
• Binary Black Holes, Gas Sloshing, and Cold Fronts in the X-ray Halo Hosting 4C+37.11
• Detecting subparsec super-massive binary black holes: Long termmonitoring perspective
• Merging timescale for supermassive black hole binary in interacting galaxy NGC 6240
• ESPRESSO reveals a single but perturbed broad-line region in the supermassive black hole binary candidate PG 1302-102
• SPARCS-North Wide-field VLBI Survey: Exploring the resolved MicroJy extra-galactic radio source population with EVN+e-MERLIN
• VLBA 24 and 43 GHz observations of massive binary black hole candidate PKS 1155+251
• Central X-ray point-sources found to be abundant in low-mass, late-type galaxies predicted to contain an intermediate-mass black hole
• Chandra Observations of Abell 2261 Brightest Cluster Galaxy, a Candidate Host to a Recoiling Black Hole
• Tracing the Evolution of Ultraluminous Infrared Galaxies into Radio Galaxies with Low Frequency Radio Observations
• A fast test for the identification and confirmation of massive black hole binaries
• Active galactic nuclei cores in infrared-faint radio sources: Very long baseline interferometry observations using the Very Long Baseline Array
• Deep VLBI Observations Challenge Previous Evidence of a Binary Supermassive Black Hole Residing in the Seyfert Galaxy NGC 7674
• A Multi-wavelength Study of the Host Environment of SMBHB 4C+37.11
• Complex morphology and precession indicators of AGN jets in LoTSS DR2
• J1110+4817 -- a compact symmetric object candidate revisited
• Searching for clues of past binary supermassive black hole mergers in nuclear star clusters
• Unusual Hard X-ray Flares Caught in NICER Monitoring of the Binary Supermassive Black Hole Candidate AT2019cuk/Tick Tock/SDSS J1430+2303
• Milliarcsecond X-ray astrometry to resolve inner regions of AGN at $z>1$ using gravitational lensing
• Investigating the Candidate Displaced Active Galactic Nucleus in NGC 3115
• Strange Quasar Candidates with Abnormal Astrometric Characteristics from Gaia EDR3 and SDSS (SQUAB-II): Optical Identifications
• The Advanced X-ray Imaging Satellite
• Dim cores of radio-bright AGN jets: VLBI and Gaia astrometry pinpoint different parsec-scale features
• Variations of Broad Emission Lines from periodicity QSOs under the interpretation of supermassive binary black holes with misaligned circumbinary broad line regions
• A search for binary black hole candidates from the VLBI images of AGNs
• The Effect of Impact Parameters on the Formation of Massive Black Hole Binaries in Galactic Mergers
• Binary black hole signatures in polarized light curves
• How to detect super-massive binary black holes at parsec scales
• Astro2020 Science White Paper: Black Hole Growth in Mergers and Dual AGN
• The most massive galaxies with large depleted cores: structural parameter relations and black hole masses