Self-Consistent Analysis of OH-Zeeman Observations: Too Much Noise about Noise

Abstract

We had recently re-analyzed in a self-consistent way OH-Zeeman observations in four molecular-cloud envelopes and we had shown that, contrary to claims by Crutcher et al., there is no evidence that the mass-to-flux ratio decreases from the envelopes to the cores of these clouds. The key difference between our data analysis and the earlier one by Crutcher et al. is the relaxation of the overly restrictive assumption made by Crutcher et al, that the magnetic field strength is independent of position in each of the four envelopes. In a more recent paper, Crutcher et al. (1) claim that our analysis is not self-consistent, in that it misses a cosine factor, and (2) present new arguments to support their contention that the magnetic-field strength is indeed independent of position in each of the four envelopes. We show that the claim of the missing cosine factor is false, that the new arguments contain even more serious problems than the Crutcher et al. original data analysis, and we present new observational evidence, independent of the OH-Zeeman data, that suggests significant variations in the magnetic-field strength in the four cloud envelopes.

8 pages, 3 figures, MNRAS in press

References in corpus (1)

• The COMPLETE Survey of Star-Forming Regions: Phase I Data

Cited by in corpus (18)

• The Big Problems in Star Formation: the Star Formation Rate, Stellar Clustering, and the Initial Mass Function
• Partially Ionized Plasmas in Astrophysics
• Magnetization of cloud cores and envelopes and other observational consequences of reconnection diffusion
• Review of Zeeman Effect Observations of Regions of Star Formation
• An Early Transition to Magnetic Supercriticality in Star Formation
• Bimodal radio variability in OVRO-40m-monitored blazars
• Collapse of Turbulent Cores and Reconnection Diffusion
• Infrared and optical polarimetry around the low-mass star-forming region NGC 1333 IRAS 4A
• The Magnetic Field of L1544: I. Near-Infrared Polarimetry and the Non-Uniform Envelope
• Probing the Turbulence Dissipation Range and Magnetic Field Strengths in Molecular Clouds. II. Directly Probing the Ion-neutral Decoupling Scale
• Observational Diagnostics for Two-Fluid Turbulence in Molecular Clouds As Suggested by Simulations
• Three-dimensional magnetic fields of molecular clouds
• Statistical analysis of the mass-to-flux ratio in turbulent cores: effects of magnetic field reversals and dynamo amplification
• Effect of OH depletion on measurements of the mass-to-flux ratio in molecular cloud cores
• Reconciling inverse-Compton Doppler factors with variability Doppler factors in blazar jets
• GMC Collisions As Triggers of Star Formation. IV. The Role of Ambipolar Diffusion
• Magnetic Fields and Star Formation
• Magnetic Fields in Molecular Clouds -- Observation and Interpretation