Testing Molecular-Cloud Fragmentation Theories: Self-Consistent Analysis of OH Zeeman Observations

Abstract

The ambipolar-diffusion theory of star formation predicts the formation of fragments in molecular clouds with mass-to-flux ratios greater than that of the parent-cloud envelope. By contrast, scenarios of turbulence-induced fragmentation do not yield such a robust prediction. Based on this property, Crutcher et al. (2009) proposed an observational test that could potentially discriminate between fragmentation theories. However, the analysis applied to the data severely restricts the discriminative power of the test: the authors conclude that they can only constrain what they refer to as the "idealized" ambipolar-diffusion theory that assumes initially straight-parallel magnetic field lines in the parent cloud. We present an original, self-consistent analysis of the same data taking into account the nonuniformity of the magnetic field in the cloud envelopes, which is suggested by the data themselves, and we discuss important geometrical effects that must be accounted for in using this test. We show quantitatively that the quality of current data does not allow for a strong conclusion about any fragmentation theory. Given the discriminative potential of the test, we urge for more and better-quality data.

5 pages, 3 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS Letters

References in corpus (4)

• Magnetic Fields in Dark Cloud Cores: Arecibo OH Zeeman Observations
• Testing Magnetic Star Formation Theory
• Protostar Formation in Magnetic Molecular Clouds beyond Ion Detachment: II. Typical Axisymmetric Solution
• The Super-Alfvénic Model of Molecular Clouds: Predictions for Zeeman Splitting Measurements

Cited by in corpus (27)

• The Star Formation Rate of Turbulent Magnetized Clouds: Comparing Theory, Simulations, and Observations
• The Big Problems in Star Formation: the Star Formation Rate, Stellar Clustering, and the Initial Mass Function
• Dispersion of Magnetic Fields in Molecular Clouds. I
• Inefficient star formation through turbulence, magnetic fields and feedback
• Self-similar Fragmentation Regulated by Magnetic Fields in a Massive Star Forming Filament
• Magnetization of cloud cores and envelopes and other observational consequences of reconnection diffusion
• Review of Zeeman Effect Observations of Regions of Star Formation
• The Hall effect in star formation
• Dispersion of Magnetic Fields in Molecular Clouds. III
• An Early Transition to Magnetic Supercriticality in Star Formation
• Formation of collapsing cores in subcritical magnetic clouds: three-dimensional MHD simulations with ambipolar diffusion
• Self-Consistent Analysis of OH Zeeman Observations
• Magnetic fields at the onset of high-mass star formation
• Self-Consistent Analysis of OH-Zeeman Observations: Too Much Noise about Noise
• The Link between Magnetic-field Orientations and Star Formation Rates
• Evidence for Dynamically Important Magnetic Fields in Molecular Clouds
• Non-Equilibrium Chemistry of Dynamically Evolving Prestellar Cores: II. Ionization and Magnetic Field
• The role of turbulence, magnetic fields and feedback for star formation
• Induced Core Formation Time in Subcritical Magnetic Clouds by Large-Scale Trans-Alfvénic Flows
• Observational Diagnostics for Two-Fluid Turbulence in Molecular Clouds As Suggested by Simulations
• Magnetic fields in star-forming systems (II): examining dust polarization, the Zeeman effect, and the Faraday rotation measure as magnetic field tracers
• Statistical analysis of the mass-to-flux ratio in turbulent cores: effects of magnetic field reversals and dynamo amplification
• Effect of OH depletion on measurements of the mass-to-flux ratio in molecular cloud cores
• First clear detection of the CCS Zeeman splitting toward the pre-stellar core, Taurus Molecular Cloud-1
• Characterization of Turbulence from Submillimeter Dust Emission
• The magnetic field in the dense photodissociation region of DR 21
• GMC Collisions As Triggers of Star Formation. IV. The Role of Ambipolar Diffusion