Self-Consistent Analysis of OH Zeeman Observations

Abstract

Crutcher, Hakobian, and Troland (2009) used OH Zeeman observations of four nearby molecular dark clouds to show that the ratio of mass to magnetic flux was smaller in the ~0.1 pc cores than in the ~1 pc envelopes, in contradiction to the prediction of ambipolar diffusion driven core formation. A crucial assumption was that the magnetic field direction is nearly the same in the envelope and core regions of each cloud. Mouschovias and Tassis (2009) have argued that the data are not consistent with this assumption, and presented a new analysis that changes the conclusions of the study. Here we show that the data are in fact consistent with the nearly uniform field direction assumption; hence, the original study is internally self-consistent and the conclusions are valid under the assumptions that were made. We also show that the Mouschovias and Tassis model of magnetic fields in cloud envelopes is inconsistent with their own analysis of the data. However, the data do not rule out a more complex field configuration that future observations may discern.

3 pages, 1 figure, accepted for publication by MNRAS Letters

References in corpus (2)

• Testing Magnetic Star Formation Theory
• Testing Molecular-Cloud Fragmentation Theories: Self-Consistent Analysis of OH Zeeman Observations

Cited by in corpus (25)

• The Big Problems in Star Formation: the Star Formation Rate, Stellar Clustering, and the Initial Mass Function
• Partially Ionized Plasmas in Astrophysics
• Rotationally-supported disks around Class I sources in Taurus: disk formation constraints
• Magnetization of cloud cores and envelopes and other observational consequences of reconnection diffusion
• Review of Zeeman Effect Observations of Regions of Star Formation
• Accretion and magnetic field morphology around Class 0 stage protostellar discs
• Dispersion of Magnetic Fields in Molecular Clouds. III
• Evidence of 200 TeV photons from HAWC J1825-134
• Searching for chameleon-like scalar fields with the ammonia method. II. Mapping of cold molecular cores in NH3 and HC3N lines
• An Early Transition to Magnetic Supercriticality in Star Formation
• Formation of collapsing cores in subcritical magnetic clouds: three-dimensional MHD simulations with ambipolar diffusion
• On the shape and completeness of the column density probability distribution function of molecular clouds
• Star Formation in Molecular Clouds
• Technique for separating velocity and density contributions in spectroscopic data and its application to studying turbulence and magnetic fields
• Magnetic fields in molecular clouds: Limitations of the analysis of Zeeman observations
• Self-Consistent Analysis of OH-Zeeman Observations: Too Much Noise about Noise
• Global dynamics of the interstellar medium in magnetised disc galaxies
• Collapse of Turbulent Cores and Reconnection Diffusion
• The driving of turbulence in simulations of molecular cloud formation and evolution
• Gravity Versus Magnetic Fields in Forming Molecular Clouds
• Tracing Magnetic Fields with Ground State Alignment
• The Origin of Filamentary Star Forming Clouds in Magnetised Galaxies
• The impact of magnetic fields on the chemical evolution of the supernova-driven ISM
• Statistical analysis of the mass-to-flux ratio in turbulent cores: effects of magnetic field reversals and dynamo amplification
• Characterization of Turbulence from Submillimeter Dust Emission