Colloquium: Comparison of Astrophysical and Terrestrial Frequency Standards

Abstract

We have re-analyzed the stability of pulse arrival times from pulsars and white dwarfs using several analysis tools for measuring the noise characteristics of sampled time and frequency data. We show that the best terrestrial artificial clocks substantially exceed the performance of astronomical sources as time-keepers in terms of accuracy (as defined by cesium primary frequency standards) and stability. This superiority in stability can be directly demonstrated over time periods up to two years, where there is high quality data for both. Beyond 2 years there is a deficiency of data for clock/clock comparisons and both terrestrial and astronomical clocks show equal performance being equally limited by the quality of the reference timescales used to make the comparisons. Nonetheless, we show that detailed accuracy evaluations of modern terrestrial clocks imply that these new clocks are likely to have a stability better than any astronomical source up to comparison times of at least hundreds of years. This article is intended to provide a correct appreciation of the relative merits of natural and artificial clocks. The use of natural clocks as tests of physics under the most extreme conditions is entirely appropriate; however, the contention that these natural clocks, particularly white dwarfs, can compete as timekeepers against devices constructed by mankind is shown to be doubtful.

9 pages, 2 figures; presented at the International Frequency Control Symposium, Newport Beach, Calif., June, 2010; presented at Pulsar Conference 2010, October 12th, Sardinia; accepted 13th September 2010 for publication in Reviews of Modern Physics

References in corpus (17)

• The Physics of Neutron Stars
• The fundamental constants and their variation: observational status and theoretical motivations
• Tests of general relativity from timing the double pulsar
• A Double-Pulsar System - A Rare Laboratory for Relativistic Gravity and Plasma Physics
• Sr lattice clock at 1x10^{-16} fractional uncertainty by remote optical evaluation with a Ca clock
• New Limits to the Drift of Fundamental Constants from Laboratory Measurements
• Precision timing of PSR J0437-4715: an accurate pulsar distance, a high pulsar mass and a limit on the variation of Newton's gravitational constant
• New limit on the present temporal variation of the fine structure constant
• Enhanced sensitivity to variation of the fine structure constant and m_p/m_e in diatomic molecules
• Timing stability of millisecond pulsars and prospects for gravitational-wave detection
• Long-distance frequency dissemination with a resolution of 10-17
• The absolute frequency of the 87Sr optical clock transition
• An empirical model for the beams of radio pulsars
• Measuring the evolution of the most stable optical clock G 117-B15A
• Cryogenic sapphire oscillator with exceptionally high long-term frequency stability
• Variation of fundamental constants: theory and observations
• High-resolution optical frequency dissemination on a telecommunication network with data traffic

Cited by in corpus (16)

• Topological states in engineered atomic lattices
• Ultra-low-phase-noise cryocooled microwave dielectric-sapphire-resonator oscillators with 1 x 10^-16 frequency instability
• Review of X-ray pulsar spacecraft autonomous navigation
• Microwave-clock timescale with instability on order of $10^{-17}$
• Milky Way Accelerometry via Millisecond Pulsar Timing
• The Lorentz-violating real scalar field at thermal equilibrium
• Structural Phase Transitions of Optical Patterns in Atomic Gases with Microwave Controlled Rydberg Interactions
• Manipulating quantum Hall edge channels in graphene through Scanning Gate Microscopy
• Shining Light on Quantum Gravity with Pulsar-Black Hole Binaries
• Pulsar Positioning System: A quest for evidence of extraterrestrial engineering
• Measuring clock jumps using pulsar timing
• PSR J0437-4715: The Argentine Institute of Radioastronomy 2019-2020 Observational Campaign
• Astrophysics with the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
• Radiative Capture of proton 14N(p,γ) 15O at Low Energy
• The Statistics of the Cross-Spectrum and the Spectrum Average: Generalization to Multiple Instruments
• A Temporal Map in Geostationary Orbit: The Cover Etching on the EchoStar XVI Artifact