Absence of significant cross-correlation between WMAP and SDSS
arXiv:1001.4000 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/200912763
Abstract
AIMS. Several authors have claimed to detect a significant cross-correlation between microwave WMAP anisotropies and the SDSS galaxy distribution. We repeat these analyses to determine the different cross-correlation uncertainties caused by re-sampling errors and field-to-field fluctuations. The first type of error concerns overlapping sky regions, while the second type concerns non-overlapping sky regions. METHODS. To measure the re-sampling errors, we use bootstrap and jack-knife techniques. For the field-to-field fluctuations, we use three methods: 1) evaluation of the dispersion in the cross-correlation when correlating separated regions of WMAP with the original region of SDSS; 2) use of mock Monte Carlo WMAP maps; 3) a new method (developed in this article), which measures the error as a function of the integral of the product of the self-correlations for each map. RESULTS. The average cross-correlation for b>30 deg. is significantly stronger than the re-sampling errors--both the jack-knife and bootstrap techniques provide similar results--but it is of the order of the field-to-field fluctuations. This is confirmed by the cross-correlation between anisotropies and galaxies in more than the half of the sample being null within re-sampling errors. CONCLUSIONS. Re-sampling methods underestimate the errors. Field-to-field fluctuations dominate the detected signals. The ratio of signal to re-sampling errors is larger than unity in a way that strongly depends on the selected sky region. We therefore conclude that there is no evidence yet of a significant detection of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect. Hence, the value of Omega_Λ~ 0.8 obtained by the authors who assumed they were observing the ISW effect would appear to have originated from noise analysis
arXiv comment5 pages and three figures. Accepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics. V2 corrected to match the published paper
References in corpus (18)
- The Seventh Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Data Processing, Sky Maps, and Basic Results
- Correlation of CMB with large-scale structure: I. ISW Tomography and Cosmological Implications
- An Imprint of Super-Structures on the Microwave Background due to the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- Combined analysis of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and cosmological implications
- Detection of the ISW and SZ effects from the CMB-Galaxy correlation
- No large-angle correlations on the non-Galactic microwave sky
- Cross-correlation of the CMB and radio galaxies in real, harmonic and wavelet spaces: detection of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and dark energy constraints
- Cross-correlation of WMAP 3rd year and the SDSS DR4 galaxy survey: new evidence for Dark Energy
- Error analysis in cross-correlation of sky maps: application to the ISW detection
- A reassessment of the evidence of the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect through the WMAP-NVSS correlation
- ISW measurements with photometric redshift surveys: 2MASS results and future prospects
- Absence of anti-correlations and of baryon acoustic oscillations in the galaxy correlation function from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey DR7
- Cross-correlating WMAP5 with 1.5 million LRGs: a new test for the ISW effect
- On the Presence of Thermal SZ Induced Signal in the First Year WMAP Temperature Maps
- Photometric Selection of Emission Line Galaxies, Clustering Analysis and a Search for the ISW effect
- Implementation of a Fourier Matched Filter in CMB Analyses. Application to ISW Studies
- Some doubts on the validity of the foreground Galactic contribution subtraction from microwave anisotropies
Cited by in corpus (25)
- Planck 2013 results. XIX. The integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect
- The observational status of Galileon gravity after Planck
- The significance of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect revisited
- A Possible Cold Imprint of Voids on the Microwave Background Radiation
- The integrated Sachs-Wolfe imprints of cosmic superstructures: a problem for ΛCDM
- Tests and problems of the standard model in Cosmology
- The stacked ISW signal of rare superstructures in ΛCDM
- Measuring the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- Observational Constraints on Kinetic Gravity Braiding from the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- On the signature of superclusters and voids in the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect
- Integrated Sachs Wolfe Effect and Rees Sciama Effect
- Alcock-Paczynski cosmological test
- Revisiting the WMAP - NVSS angular cross correlation. A skeptic's view
- Galileon: modified gravity with massive neutrinos as a testable alternative to CDM
- The SDSS-III Baryonic Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Constraints on the Integrated Sachs Wolfe effect
- The ISW-tSZ cross correlation: ISW extraction out of pure CMB data
- Measuring the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect from the low-density regions of the universe
- Peaks in the CMBR power spectrum. II. Physical interpretation for any cosmological scenario
- Cosmic microwave background with Brans-Dicke Gravity: I. Covariant Formulation
- Missing large-angle correlations versus even-odd point-parity imbalance in the cosmic microwave background
- A Multi-frequency analysis of possible Dark Matter Contributions to M31 Gamma-Ray Emissions
- Cross-correlation analysis of CMB with foregrounds for residuals
- Integrated Sachs-Wolfe tomography with orthogonal polynomials
- Anomalous anisotropic cross-correlations between WMAP CMB maps and SDSS galaxy distribution and implications on the dark flow scenario
- Cross bispectra and trispectra of the non-linear integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and the tracer galaxy density field