Revisiting the WMAP - NVSS angular cross correlation. A skeptic's view
arXiv:0909.4294 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/200913344
Abstract
In the context of the study of the ISW, we revisit the angular cross correlation of WMAP CMB data with the NVSS radio survey. We compute 2-point cross functions between the two surveys in real and in Fourier space, paying particular attention on the dependence of results on the flux of NVSS radio sources, the angular scales where correlations arise and the comparison with theoretical expectations. We reproduce previous results that claim an excess of correlation in the angular correlation function (ACF), and we also find some (low significance) similarity between the CMB and radio galaxy data in the multipole range $\el \in $ [10, 25]. However, the S/N in the ACFs increases with higher flux thresholds for NVSS sources, but drops a 30 - 50% in separations of the order of a pixel size, suggesting some residual point source contribution. When restricting our analyses to multipoles $\el \gt $60, we fail to find any evidence for cross correlation in the range $\el \in [2,10]$, where according to the model predictions and our simulations 50% of the S/N is supposed to arise. Also, the accumulated S/N for $\el \lt $60 is below 1, far from the theoretical expectation of S/N. Part of this disagreement may be caused by an inaccurate modeling of the NVSS source population: as in previous works, we find a level of large scale ($\el \lt $70) clustering in the NVSS catalog that seems incompatible with a high redshift population. This is unlikely to be caused by contaminants or systematics, since it is independent of flux threshold, and hence present for the brightest () NVSS sources. Either our NVSS catalogs are not probing the high redshift, large scale gravitational potential wells, or there is a clear mismatch between the ISW component present in WMAP data and theoretical expectations.
arXiv comment16 pages, one extra figure (13 total), matches accepted version in A&A
References in corpus (42)
- HEALPix -- a Framework for High Resolution Discretization, and Fast Analysis of Data Distributed on the Sphere
- Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Detection of the Baryon Acoustic Peak in the Large-Scale Correlation Function of SDSS Luminous Red Galaxies
- The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: Power-spectrum analysis of the final dataset and cosmological implications
- Detection of Gravitational Lensing in the Cosmic Microwave Background
- A correlation of the cosmic microwave sky with large scale structure
- Correlation of CMB with large-scale structure: I. ISW Tomography and Cosmological Implications
- Looking for with the Rees-Sciama Effect
- Combined analysis of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and cosmological implications
- Detection of the ISW and SZ effects from the CMB-Galaxy correlation
- First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Dark Energy Induced Correlation with Radio Sources
- Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect from the cross correlation of WMAP3 year and the NRAO VLA sky survey data: New results and constraints on dark energy
- The Pseudo- method: Cosmic microwave background anisotropy power spectrum statistics for high precision cosmology
- Cosmic microwave background anisotropy power spectrum statistics for high precision cosmology
- The Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Source Catalog
- Measurement of the gravitational potential evolution from the cross-correlation between WMAP and the APM Galaxy survey
- Cross-correlation of the CMB and radio galaxies in real, harmonic and wavelet spaces: detection of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and dark energy constraints
- Cross-correlation of WMAP 3rd year and the SDSS DR4 galaxy survey: new evidence for Dark Energy
- Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect in Cross-Correlation: The Observer's Manual
- Correlating the CMB with Luminous Red Galaxies : The Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- Measurement of the angular correlation function of radio galaxies from the NRAO VLA Sky Survey
- Error analysis in cross-correlation of sky maps: application to the ISW detection
- Detection of the ISW effect and corresponding dark energy constraints
- Detection of the ISW effect and corresponding dark energy constraints made with directional spherical wavelets
- A reassessment of the evidence of the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect through the WMAP-NVSS correlation
- The integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect -- Large Scale Structure Correlation
- Non-blind catalogue of extragalactic point sources from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) first 3--year survey data
- Spectral Energy Distribution of Radio Sources in Nearby Clusters of Galaxies: Implications for Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Surveys
- Primordial Non-Gaussianity and the NRAO VLA Sky Survey
- The angular power spectrum of NVSS radio galaxies
- Cross-Correlation of the Cosmic Microwave Background with Radio Sources: Constraints on an Accelerating Universe
- Investigating the Far-IR/Radio Correlation of Star Forming Galaxies to z=3
- Impact of Scale Dependent Bias and Nonlinear Structure Growth on the ISW Effect: Angular Power Spectra
- Cross-correlating WMAP5 with 1.5 million LRGs: a new test for the ISW effect
- Absence of significant cross-correlation between WMAP and SDSS
- The large scale clustering of radio sources
- Optimal ISW detection and joint likelihood for cosmological parameter estimation
- Photometric Selection of Emission Line Galaxies, Clustering Analysis and a Search for the ISW effect
- A linear filter to reconstruct the ISW effect from CMB and LSS observations
- Implications of bias evolution on measurements of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect: errors and biases in parameter estimation
- Implementation of a Fourier Matched Filter in CMB Analyses. Application to ISW Studies
- Using peak distribution of the cosmic microwave background for MAP and Planck data analysis: formalism and simulations
Cited by in corpus (35)
- Planck 2015 results. XXI. The integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect
- Planck 2013 results. XIX. The integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect
- Improved Primordial Non-Gaussianity Constraints from Measurements of Galaxy Clustering and the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- Probing the Cosmological Principle in the counts of radio galaxies at different frequencies
- The significance of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect revisited
- A Possible Cold Imprint of Voids on the Microwave Background Radiation
- The integrated Sachs-Wolfe imprints of cosmic superstructures: a problem for ΛCDM
- Constraints on Primordial Non-Gaussianity from Large Scale Structure Probes
- Measuring the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- Observational Constraints on Kinetic Gravity Braiding from the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- On the signature of superclusters and voids in the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect
- Integrated Sachs Wolfe Effect and Rees Sciama Effect
- On the proper kinetic quadrupole CMB removal and the quadrupole anomalies
- The SDSS-III Baryonic Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Constraints on the Integrated Sachs Wolfe effect
- Removal of two large scale Cosmic Microwave Background anomalies after subtraction of the Integrated Sachs Wolfe effect
- An optimal estimator for the CMB-LSS angular power spectrum and its application to WMAP and NVSS data
- The angular two-point correlation of NVSS galaxies revisited
- Measuring the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect from the low-density regions of the universe
- Measuring ISW with next-generation radio surveys
- Integrated Sachs-Wolfe map recovery from NVSS and WMAP 7yr data
- Integrated Sachs-Wolfe map reconstruction in the presence of systematic errors
- A cross-correlation analysis of CMB lensing and radio galaxy maps
- On the ISW-cluster cross-correlation in future surveys
- Cross-correlation analysis of CMB with foregrounds for residuals
- On the recovery of ISW fluctuations using large-scale structure tracers and CMB temperature and polarization anisotropies
- A Simple Gravitational Lens Model For Cosmic Voids
- The first direct measurement of gravitational potential decay rate at cosmological scales and improved dark energy constraint
- Anomalous anisotropic cross-correlations between WMAP CMB maps and SDSS galaxy distribution and implications on the dark flow scenario
- Integrated Sachs-Wolfe tomography with orthogonal polynomials
- An integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect vs redshift test for the cosmological parameters
- Embedded Lensing Time Delays, the Fermat Potential, and the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- Theoretical Estimates of Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect Detection through EMU-ASKAP Survey with Confusion, Position Uncertainty, Shot Noise and SNR analysis
- Probing the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect using embedded lens models
- Cross bispectra and trispectra of the non-linear integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and the tracer galaxy density field
- CMB lensing tomography with clustering estimation of lens redshift distributions